Legislation that would allow health department inspectors to start hanging A-B-C grades on restaurant doors was referred to committee by Allegheny County Council on Tuesday, but not before several local restaurant owners reiterated their distaste for the plan.

“We are universally opposed to the proposal,” said Kevin Joyce, owner of The Carlton Restaurant, Downtown.

“Good operators who are doing a good job can be made to look bad” if they are forced to post grades, he said.

A contingent of prominent local restaurant owners has been fighting the plan, which was approved by the Allegheny County Board of Health in September. The grading system, which the health department hopes to launch in January, needs council’s approval before it can be implemented.

Advertise with us

Mr. Joyce asked council members to “have an open mind” when considering whether to pass the measure.

County Executive Rich Fitzgerald has been a strong proponent of restaurant grades. On Tuesday, he urged council members to learn about the program, hold public hearings and give it their nod.

“It’s something I support,” he said.

Mr. Fitzgerald emphasized that neither the inspection process nor the criteria inspectors use to evaluate restaurants would be changing.

“We’re taking something that’s already public — an inspection report — and putting a grade to it,” he said.

Advertise with us

Proponents say restaurant grades help consumers make informed dining decisions and spur restaurants to act quickly to fix serious health code violations.

Council President John DeFazio sent the grading plan to the health and human services committee, chaired by council member John Palmiere.