The state Superior Court on Monday reversed an Allegheny County Common Pleas judge who said that prosecutors were not permitted to use jail visit recordings in a criminal prosecution.
That means that the rape case against James Taric Byrd, which has been on hold for more than a year, can go forward.
In October 2016, Judge Donna Jo McDaniel suppressed recordings in which prosecutors said Byrd admitted sexually assaulting a woman.
The recordings were made when the woman visited him at the Allegheny County Jail.
Byrd's attorney argued that the recordings were obtained through an illegal wiretap after a state Supreme Court decision in 2016 found that the devices inmates and visitors used to speak with each other in the jail are not telephones.
In that case, a lower court in Clinton County ruled that the handsets used to facilitate the visits were not telephones, did not involve the dialing of a telephone number and did not use wires connected to a telephone company. Therefore, the court found, their use does not fall under the wiretap exception for jail phone calls.
Read More
Prosecutors with the Allegheny County District Attorney's office tried to argue to Judge McDaniel that the recordings could fall under the separate wiretap exception of mutual consent because when a jail visitation begins, a message is played to alert the inmate and visitor that conversations are being recorded.
Judge McDaniel rejected that argument, finding that the commonwealth failed to prove that Byrd heard the warning prior to the conversation.
"It is not outside the realm of possibility that [Byrd] did not have the receiver to his ear when the recording played, and therefore may not have heard it," she found.
However, in the 18-page Superior Court opinion, the three-judge panel said Judge McDaniel's "hyper-technical analysis requires that in these instances, the commonwealth must always establish on the record that the inmate had the telephone to his ear, listened to the message that announced the conversation may be recorded, and then consented to the message."
"This type of requirement is unreasonable because under such scrutiny and logic, an inmate could easily avoid the consent element by simply holding the phone away from his ear for a period of time prior to speaking with a visitor, in order to evade hearing that message,” wrote Judge Paula Francisco Ott,
In addition, the panel found that Byrd was clearly aware he was being recorded when he said to a visitor in one conversation, “ 'I'm gonna say it on the phone. I don't give a [damn].' "
Also, since the conversation was in an open visitation area in the jail, Byrd should have known it could be recorded, the appellate court found.
"The mutual consent exception permits interception of conversations in instances where the defendant ‘knew, or should have known, that the conversation was recorded,' " Judge Ott wrote.
In the same opinion, the Superior Court panel also found that Judge McDaniel erred in suppressing evidence seized in a gun and drug case against Byrd.
In that case, McKeesport police were called about 6 p.m. on Feb. 23, 2015, for a report of a woman being threatened.
When officers arrived, they found the suspect, Byrd, 39, inside a pickup truck. The officers first asked him to open his window, and when he did, there was a strong smell of marijuana.
Byrd refused to get out of the truck and was acting nervously, the officers said, and when they attempted to remove him, he struggled and tried to flee.
Officers took him into custody. They said they found a handgun on the seat of his truck in plain view and then, during a search, found 20 stamp bags of heroin in an unlocked lock box on the passenger seat, as well as a bullet proof vest and two cell phones.
Judge McDaniel suppressed the vest and evidence in the lock box, saying the officers needed a search warrant to obtain it.
Prosecutors, however, argued that the search met the federal automobile exception to the warrant requirement recently adopted in Pennsylvania. The exception allows officers to search a vehicle when there is probable cause, even if the only exigent circumstance is that the vehicle can be driven away.
The Superior Court found that there was probable cause to search the vehicle and that Judge McDaniel “did not properly apply the law to the facts of the case.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.