A prosecutor's phone call to a potential defense witness in the middle of trial led an Allegheny County judge to dismiss the entire case and bar the charges from being refiled.
Now, the state Superior Court must decide if that call was simply an error in judgment or prosecutorial misconduct.
A three-judge panel heard argument Tuesday morning on the case against James Taric Byrd. The Allegheny County District Attorney's Office appealed the decision by Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel that bans Byrd from being retried on the gun charges on double jeopardy grounds.
Byrd was arrested Feb. 23, 2015, in McKeesport on gun and drug charges. The gun case went to trial in November 2016. When Assistant District Attorney Lawrence Sachs learned on Nov. 30 that Byrd planned to call Brandi Wilson as a character witness the next day, Mr. Sachs called her to find out what she planned to say.
During the conversation, he told the court that he asked her if she knew Byrd's criminal history; told her Byrd was one of the most dangerous people he'd ever prosecuted and then told her that he knew more about her than he should — referencing that he'd listened to recorded jail calls between Byrd and Ms. Wilson.
Several hours later — about 1 a.m. — Ms. Wilson left a lengthy message for Judge McDaniel in which she said she felt threatened by Mr. Sachs and was afraid of him and possible retaliation.
Read More
Later that day, Judge McDaniel declared a mistrial — without taking testimony from Ms. Wilson — and said that the woman's perception was what mattered.
The judge also banned Mr. Sachs from ever again appearing in her courtroom. He was later moved from the DA’s narcotics unit to become an area prosecutor in the Mon Valley. He retired from the DA's office in recent weeks after more than 30 years.
In March 2017, Judge McDaniel threw out the entire case against Byrd, finding that he could not be retried. That decision was made despite evidence presented by a new prosecutor, who said that Ms. Wilson spoke to Byrd at the jail in a recorded call before she called Judge McDaniel's chambers. In that call, Byrd told Ms. Wilson she should tell the judge Mr. Sachs scared her.
"Let me be in control of the conversations for this time right here," Byrd said on the recording. "You’re coming to the thing, and I know that he scared you, Brandi. I know that he spooked you with that [expletive].”
“If you just listen to me, you read between the lines and understand,” Byrd continued. “If you let these people know — if you even called the lady [on Judge McDaniels’ staff] back that called you and tell them that he called you and said all those derogatory things and he threatened you and he scared you and that’s why you’re not coming, it helps me.”
At oral argument on Tuesday, Assistant District Attorney Kevin McCarthy told the Superior Court that the recording shows it was Byrd who "planted the seeds” in Ms. Wilson’s mind of being threatened.
"She never once in that conversation said 'he threatened me or she felt threatened by him,' " he said.
Mr. McCarthy also argued that Mr. Sachs' actions in calling Ms. Wilson did not violate any rules of criminal procedure, statute or rules of professional responsibility.
They did, he noted, violate an internal office policy that requires any prosecutor to have a witness in the room during such a phone call to protect against allegations like the ones in this case.
Mr. McCarthy said the case should turn on Mr. Sachs' intent.
"Did the prosecutor intend to deprive the defendant of a fair trial?"
But attorney Frank Walker, representing Byrd, told the court that if the situation were reversed, and a defendant or a friend of a defendant called a prosecution witness in the same way, there is no question that charges of witness intimidation would be filed.
"I believe this was egregious conduct," Mr. Walker said. “I believe it was prosecutorial misconduct.
"Words matter. The context and totality of the circumstances of that phone call and his position as an assistant district attorney ... present prosecutorial misconduct."
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.