There’s hardly an American city more different from Pittsburgh, in its geography and culture and economy and reputation, than Miami. Yet this week, the fates of these two cities became bound together.
In only two years, Carnegie Mellon University plans to begin enrolling students at CMU Miami — not to be confused with the police procedural starring sunglasses-clad David Caruso — in that city’s trendy Wynwood neighborhood.
It’s the result of the largest gift in the history of higher education, $3 billion, from billionaire hedge fund manager Ken Griffin, whose firm Citadel is located in Miami.
Two-thirds of the donation is earmarked for the new South Florida campus, which will reject the traditional model of major disciplines, such as English and Mathematics and Computer Science, in favor of allowing students to focus on solutions to global social challenges, such as “human health and biological discovery” or “energy and climate resilience.”
Whether this is a gimmick or a breakthrough, only time will tell.
The remaining one-third of the gift is to be spent somewhat vaguely on or around CMU’s home base in Squirrel Hill: half for the soon-to-be-named Griffin School of Computer Science and half on other priorities, such as recruitment and affordability.
Read More
The move establishes an institutional link, and a globally prestigious one at that, between the Steel City and Magic City (or, as the case may be, Vice City), potentially connecting the former’s talent with the latter’s capital.
Yet it also seems designed in a (very expensive) lab to tickle Pittsburgh’s anxieties: Are we about to get overshadowed by Miami’s glamour, a university’s ambition and a billionaire’s dream?
Pulling away
That may be Pittsburgh’s insecurity talking, but it’s not unrealistic.
It’s not hard to see CMU’s focus, whether in Qatar or South Florida, consistently and inexorably moving beyond southwestern Pennsylvania. It’s not hard to imagine it becoming yet another Pittsburgh-based institution, whose interests are primarily elsewhere, rather than a truly Pittsburgh institution.

Indeed, the second paragraph of the New York Times story on the Griffin gift certainly gives this impression: “Although the university is based in Pittsburgh, the donation … will largely go toward the development of a campus in Miami.” You don’t want to be in the “although” clause in this kind of sentence. That means you’re the afterthought.
The university has gone to great effort to avoid this interpretation, with President Farnam Jahanian making the announcement at a “fireside chat” on the Squirrel Hill campus, as opposed to a splashy presser on South Beach.
Even so, the magnetic pull of Miami’s money and glamour is strong, and it’s certain that the university’s main focus in the coming years will be the successful launch of its Florida campus. Multi-billionaires like Ken Griffin can afford to shop for universities the way you and I shop for cars or televisions.
Finding synergies
But it would not be productive to focus entirely on doom and gloom. Let’s consider how Pittsburgh can make the best of its newfound tropical connection.
The differences between Pittsburgh and Miami also make them complementary. As CMU described in some of its own materials on the deal, Pittsburgh has strengths in manufacturing, technical talent and frontier research, while Miami plays a much more substantial, and fast-growing, role in global finance and capital markets.
One of the biggest factors holding back Pittsburgh’s startup ecosystem has long been access to capital. While Miami doesn’t have Silicon Valley’s density of venture capital, it’s much more dynamic than Western Pennsylvania. Establishing links between Pittsburgh and Miami-based firms could blast some oxygen onto this city’s entrepreneurial embers.
This kind of “cross-pollination” doesn’t just happen. It takes leaders to make sure that the connections take place, and that Pittsburgh gets its share of the benefits — including that our talent and the profits from our companies don’t just flow to South Florida without anything flowing back.
Home sweet home
Here are a few concrete suggestions for making this link work best for Pittsburgh.
Regional technology and economic development organizations should already be planning embassies to Miami, and CMU leaders should offer to mediate introductions. The Allegheny Conference on Community Development, the Pittsburgh Robotics Network, the Pittsburgh Technology Council, the Pittsburgh Life Sciences Alliance, the AI Strike Team and so on can begin to get to know the players and the systems in South Florida, and to discern what mutually beneficial relationships can be made.
It would also be a strong signal, as well as a practical aid to cross-pollination, if American Airlines were to add more direct flights between Pittsburgh and Miami. Right now there are two outbound flights from PIT a day, one morning and one evening. Allegheny County Airport Authority CEO Christina Cassotis should make getting a third, midday flight a priority.
Lastly, CMU should create a commission or task force whose primary purpose is to seek out and build out ways CMU Miami’s work can benefit not just CMU Pittsburgh, but the Pittsburgh region as a whole. If this move is going to deepen the university’s Pittsburgh roots rather than pull them up, then it will have to be a priority of the university to actively resist South Florida’s gravitational pull.
There’s no doubt Ken Griffin’s historic gift is more about Miami than Pittsburgh. The question, the answer to which will depend on the actions of university and civic leaders in the years to come, is whether CMU’s center of gravity is permanently shifting from Steel City to Magic City.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How new housing authority director can shake off her Oregon scandal.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.