I have spent a lot of time, more than is healthy, with the city of Pittsburgh’s operating budgets. But when I’ve pored over the documents in order to understand and reveal just how bad the city’s finances are, I’ve always been aware of what I didn’t, and couldn’t, know about the reality behind the numbers.
The budgets can tell you how much the city plans to spend down to line items like office supplies for the Department of Parks and Recreation ($15,000) or health insurance for employees of the Office of Management and Budget ($316,400). And they can tell you how much the city spent the prior year in all those categories. They’re actually among the most user-friendly public-finance documents I’ve encountered.
But they’re still only a snapshot of the underlying financial reality. More precisely, they’re a snapshot of what the people who generate them want you to see. Budgets don’t and can’t capture the true movements of funds, including financial transfers and commitments that go beyond their scope. For that, you just have to trust that the people creating the documents are presenting the underlying reality honestly.
It is now clear that the Gainey administration was not doing so, that their budgets — which already described a precarious financial situation — concealed at least as much as they revealed. And the result is that Pittsburgh will be forced to limit spending on exactly the priorities the prior administration valued so highly: support for community groups and affordable housing.
Beyond the worst predictions
The O’Connor administration estimates that its predecessor’s spending projections were off by $250 million over the next five years. That’s nearly twice the city’s fund balance, meaning that without a firm intervention, Pittsburgh won’t be able to make payroll by the end of the decade — and would be eligible for state oversight, once again, before that.
This is worse than commenters who were often derided as alarmists, such as the former Post-Gazette Editorial Board, ever described or predicted.
There was no single cause but rather numerous instances of necessary costs that weren’t budgeted and bills that hadn’t been paid. This was possible because only the executive branch has access to the city’s internal finance software — not City Council and not the city controller. These are the kind of errors and hijinks that longtime civil servants would have prevented, but in a manner reminiscent of the Trump administration these professionals were sidelined during the Gainey years in favor of the mayor’s new-to-governing appointees.
Thus, the published budgets substantially understated the extent of the unnecessary and preventable crisis. It’s a stark reminder that governance and leadership matter.
There is no solution that does not involve substantial reductions in spending. Last December’s 20% property tax increase must not be replicated: Pittsburgh cannot afford to become even less competitive with other cities and its own suburbs. Mayor Corey O’Connor and City Council should be open to other creative revenue options, but the city’s taxing power is closely hemmed in by state law.
But there is some low-hanging fruit to pluck.
Painful but responsible
One of the more curious aspects of Pittsburgh’s budgeting, which has allowed it to maintain the appearance of a surplus without the reality, is that tens of millions goes out the door after the operating result has been calculated. Most of this, $20 million, goes to two trust funds: Housing Opportunity and Stop the Violence.
Ending those contributions wouldn’t resolve the city’s problems, but it would make them manageable. Doing so will be painful but responsible.
Terminating, or at least pausing indefinitely, transfers to these funds would not end them: Both have healthy balances the city could draw on for years to come: $28.5 million for HOF and $16.7 million for STV, at the beginning of this year. Which goes to show that the city already struggles to process and spend the allotments.
The $10 million annual transfers to the HOF are meant to support Urban Redevelopment Authority housing affordability programs, such as down payment assistance and weatherization support. STV funds were supposed to be distributed among community organizations that have the potential to serve youth and disrupt violence, but that’s become a relatively small portion of the program. Mostly, the money pays for employees in the city’s Community Services and Parks and Recreation departments — and funds the entire Office of Community Health and Safety.
Both trust funds, however, have come under scrutiny in recent years. In 2024, city Controller Rachael Heisler released a report detailing how few tangible results were associated with the HOF. Meanwhile, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. has strongly implied that his inquiry into the Gainey administration involves the misuse of STV funds, specifically those granted to hyperlocal nonprofits.
While the intentions behind the funds’ creation were noble, the realities have been disappointing.
Cautionary tales
The funds’ purpose is to place certain priorities — support for community groups and affordable housing — beyond the reach of the annual budget process. This is precisely because they are beyond the scope of a lean municipal government, and would be among the first to go when cuts are required.
Well, cuts are required. And Pittsburgh is not the kind of city that can afford anything other than a lean government. So, despite the intentions of previous councils and administrations, it’s necessary to cancel these transfers.
To repeat, this would not liquidate the trust funds. Rather, it would allow the city to draw them down while it considers better ways to promote their purposes. This would include eventually moving OCHS out of STV and back into the general budget.
The HOF and STV funds should not be considered sacrosanct. Just the opposite: They should be considered cautionary tales. And it’s time to apply their lessons.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How Ohio juices growth with liquor sales, and what we can learn from it.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.