Second in an occasional series examining American Rescue Plan Act spending in the Pittsburgh area.

A very small amount of the $335 million delivered to Pittsburgh by the federal government in the American Rescue Plan Act was spent on visible improvements to city amenities. The infusion of cash was an opportunity for which the city was simply not prepared.

In my first column on ARPA spending, I noted how less than a quarter of the federal money could be tracked to a vendor, while the rest was metabolized by city government. Now let’s drill down on the roughly $74 million that went directly from the ARPA trust funds to a vendor.

It’s a discouraging story that demonstrates how the city struggles to execute capital projects and therefore decided to spend much of this windfall on everyday maintenance. This freed up city money that was used for other priorities — making new commitments that worsened the city’s financial condition once the ARPA money expired.

Advertise with us

Big projects versus core services

After combing through about 2,000 transactions, totaling $73.8 million, out of the ARPA trust funds, the spending can be divided into five capital categories: equipment, $16.3 million; facilities, $7.6 million; paving, $7.1 million; demolition, $6.9 million; and other infrastructure, $32.2 million.

This last category includes upkeep like slope remediation and city steps improvements, but also big-ticket items like lead-pipe replacement through Pittsburgh Water ($16.9 million) and the Davis Avenue Bridge in Brighton Heights ($4.5 million). These major projects — difficult to fund with city resources alone — were among the better uses of ARPA money.

The remaining $3.7 million might be called “soft” spending, for instance on arts and “food justice,” which will be the subject of a future column.

I’d like to draw particular attention to the spending on paving and demolition, because these are core city services, not capital improvements.

This could have been a good use of ARPA funds if it had significantly expanded the city’s capacity to perform the tasks, resulting in a significant reduction in deferred maintenance and neighborhood blight. But the Gainey administration’s budgets make it clear that the federal money replaced city money, rather than supplementing it.

Advertise with us

Neighborhoods left behind

In 2021, during the pandemic but before ARPA kicked in, the city budgeted $17.1 million for paving and $3.973 million for demolition.

But during the ARPA spend period from 2022 to 2026, those budgets only increased marginally and much less than inflation, averaging $17.4 million for paving and $3.974 million (now you see why I used three decimal places) for demolition.

Yet Pittsburgh spent around $14 million of ARPA money on these core services. Instead of expanding capacity, the Gainey administration reallocated the savings elsewhere, including hiring hundreds of new city workers. These new obligations set the city up for trouble.

Almost none of that $14 million was in the original ARPA spending plan, which envisioned $2 million for a burst of demolitions and nothing at all for paving. This is because these core services are, in practice, more like operating expenditures than capital projects. Filling the gap with ARPA money was not in the spirit of that program, nor was it prudent.

This raises the question of where the new $12 million came from. The answer is facilities.

Advertise with us

The original 2021 ARPA plan envisioned using $21 million to upgrade aging and decrepit recreation and senior centers around Pittsburgh. These would have been transformative investments in quality of life for city residents.

Instead, only $7.6 million has been spent on facilities, and among that nearly $5 million went to a Public Works building in Knoxville and the Marshall Mansion in Mellon Park. Less than $3 million went to the neighborhood centers.

The city simply couldn’t execute necessary capital improvement projects, so it shifted those monies to everyday maintenance.

Which way, city voters?

This points to a counterintuitive problem for a city typically accused of spending too freely, which is that Pittsburgh has trouble getting money out the door on capital projects.

There are basically two reasons, also seemingly paradoxical: too much bureaucracy and not enough staff.

Advertise with us

First, the city is bound by a complex web of rules — some of its own making and others imposed on it — that restrict its ability to move quickly. Among these are regulations regarding minority contracting that can be difficult to fulfill, depending on the availability of local women-, Black-, LGBT- and veteran-owned firms.

Second, the city lacks the staff to navigate these processes in a timely manner. For instance, Pittsburgh has a single employee, Andrea Ketzel, responsible for all playground upgrades and replacements in the city, including managing community engagement around these projects in dozens of neighborhoods. She is widely regarded as excellent and would thrive in a suburban or corporate setting — but she wants to serve the city.

This leads to the following conclusion: Unless a new political consensus forms to roll back contracting regulations and community engagement expectations, Pittsburgh will need to spend more money on staff in order to be able to execute capital projects that improve the lives of residents.

The choice on which way to go — fewer regulations or more taxation — rests with the voters of Pittsburgh.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How a radio caller taught me something new about my own family.”