“It is as if some titanic and aberrant genius, uncompromisingly inimical to man, had devoted all the ingenuity of Hell to the making of them. They show grotesqueries of ugliness that, in retrospect, become almost diabolical.”

These are the words of the Sage of Baltimore, H.L. Mencken, describing the hill-and-valley towns of Western Pennsylvania. The surrounding essay, “The Libido for the Ugly,” published almost exactly a century ago, is among the meanest (but also most entertaining) things ever written about Pittsburgh.

Happily, the Post-Gazette’s new Baltimore-based owners seem to have been more favorably impressed by the region.

I’ve long taken Mencken’s diatribe as a kind of love letter, one befitting his personality. Pittsburgh was so remarkable to him that he was compelled to set his pen to the topic, producing one of his great pieces of invective.

Advertise with us

Mencken’s visit occurred close to the height of the region’s industrial power, when the towns he observed between Pittsburgh and Greensburg were thriving economically, even if not aesthetically. I wonder, then, what the Sage of Baltimore might write if he made the same tour today? I suspect his verdict would be even more damning.

Magnets of misery

Last weekend my family checked another local National Park Service site off our list: Friendship Hill, country estate of Albert Gallatin, above the Monongahela River in Fayette County. It’s a beautiful place.

The drive there, however, passes through some of the most derelict human settlements in America.

This is where the Rust Belt meets Appalachia, where America’s postindustrial economy has little or nothing to offer. And what it does offer, all too often, is predatory and ugly.

There was one amenity, if you can call it that, in just about every town on our journey. You see the garish signs, especially those window-hung LED monstrosities, everywhere: gas stations, convenience stores, fire halls, pizza shops, bars and, most discouraging of all, standalone 24/7 parlors. In a few short years, they’ve gone from a curiosity to a plague.

Advertise with us

“SKILL GAMES.”

Pennsylvania courts have ruled that these horrible devices, predominantly built by the Georgia-based but Pennsylvania-powerful company Pace-O-Matic, rely primarily on skill, rather than chance, to determine outcomes.

If this is true, and I have my doubts, it is true only in a highly technical sense. Anyone who’s ever seen the way the machines work in real life — given their ubiquity, at this point that must include just about every Pennsylvanian — knows that for all intents and purposes they function like gaudy casino slots.

I’ve never seen someone playing a “Pennsylvania Skill” game who looks to be enjoying him or herself. They attract misery, and then only deepen it.

Hooked on ugliness

The reason they exist is that they work, at least in the sense that their creators intend them to work: They separate sad and lonely and desperate people from their money, and distribute it between the games’ hosts and producers. This is capitalistic predation in one of its purest forms.

Advertise with us

The games’ operators tend to be small business owners who can use an extra revenue stream to stabilize their balance sheets. This allows the producers to posture as supporters, even saviors, of community institutions. But this is like taking credit for getting a dying man hooked on opioids: It might dull the pain, but it hastens the demise.

I believe that at some level, perhaps even a supernatural one, there’s a connection between morality and aesthetics. In a deep sense it’s good, for instance, for human beings to create beautiful objects. It seems to me very significant, then, that everything associated with skill games is so profoundly, irredeemably ugly.

The devices themselves are garish and their graphics misshapen and grotesque. Their signage and marketing lack even the pretense of creativity. Their parlors are uniformly seedy and unkempt. The entire operation seems to emanate from a deep hatred for humanity and humaneness.

And now they blight communities across Pennsylvania, but particularly those most in need of real attention, real assistance, real care. Instead these people and places are offered ugliness, and are told to be grateful for it.

The face of greed

The ugliness doesn’t end with the skill games. Vape shops are hideous. Dollar stores are characterless. And now Pennsylvania’s next big idea is cannabis. I just drove through much of Michigan, where drivers are treated to billboard after ugly billboard for ugly cannabis shops hawking their ugly products.

Advertise with us

“Here is something that the psychologists have so far neglected: the love of ugliness for its own sake, the lust to make the world intolerable.” Mencken identified something real but, ever the frosty elitist, his targets were wrong: He thought the bearers of the “libido for the ugly” were the everyday people who lived in and loved their homely neighborhoods.

His 1920s complaints were reducible to bad planning and bland architecture. In the 2020s, though, he would discover the intentional, predatory imposition of ugliness on people and communities with neither the power nor the will to resist it.

This is where the “libido for the ugly” really lies: It is the “lust to make the world intolerable” for everyone else, in order to make it comfortable for oneself. This ugliness is the face of greed.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Where did all of Pittsburgh’s ARPA money go?”