When Market Square was first renovated nearly two decades ago, the primary activity associated with the square went from illicit transactions to al fresco dining. And Downtown’s center of gravity shifted away from Grant Street and toward the historic courtyard.
Coming out of a new $15 million refresh, today Market Square enjoys a mixed reputation. It has lost some active storefronts to banks, which contribute nothing to the public realm. But it looks better than ever, with cool programming — such as the temporary roller rink echoing PPG Plaza’s winter skating rink — and renewed interest in the remaining restaurants.
At the same time, the square has made headlines as a hub for young people who congregate in Downtown. There have been scuffles and sometimes brawls. (As of this writing, a deadly late-night shooting of an adult male in the square on May 11 appears not to be related to the youth issue.) Controversially, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, in coordination with the city, recently imposed restrictions on youth loitering there from 3 p.m. to midnight, Thursdays through Sundays.
Market Square has become a stand-in for all of Downtown. If the square is thriving, Pittsburghers think better of the Golden Triangle as a whole. If it appears to backslide, so does Downtown’s reputation.
So, what’s the truth about Market Square? I went down to see for myself — and spoke with the people who spend more time there than almost anyone: outreach workers who serve the young people drawn to this open public space. The story they tell doesn’t fit any easy political narrative.
False narratives
Von Madden is the founder and president of Shadow Student Athlete Development Services, which is located in the city’s Hilltop neighborhoods and provides mentorship to student athletes. Among its programs is A.I.M., short for Achieve, Inspire, Motivate, which involves placing trusted adults in spaces like Market Square where they can interact with youth and intercept bad decisions before they spiral out of control.
Read More
The situation Madden described to me was neither the “Mad Max”/”Lord of the Flies” dystopia you might see described on social media, nor is it a story of innocent children persecuted by greedy capitalists you also might see described on social media.
As an accessible, crowded public space, Market Square attracts young people looking for socialization and safety, according to Madden, when they struggle to find those things in their home communities.
This may surprise those who believe it’s youth looking for trouble who come to the square. But trouble is much more dangerous in a quiet alley or abandoned residential street: In the square, if trouble finds you, there are many witnesses and helpers immediately at hand.
The Market Square situation, therefore, is downstream from a lack of social stability and opportunities in Pittsburgh’s poorer, predominantly Black neighborhoods. This can be seen clearly in the presence of the most visible outreach organization in the square: Reach, a program of the Hill District-based Center that Cares.
Reaching out
Reach was designed to be a neighborhood-based anti-violence program, but the city has asked the organization to help out in Market Square. This further reduced coverage in the neighborhoods — where I first met Reach’s Jason Harris at my son’s Little League game at Ammon Park in the Hill District.
In addition to his work for Reach, Harris coaches youth baseball and football. Both Harris and Madden make it clear that kids with things to do are far less likely to get in trouble. Besides simply occupying their time, activities like sports give kids something to look forward to, something that brings them joy and gives them meaning.
Workers for Reach, A.I.M. and others know the social networks and pressure points that converge in Market Square.
They know which kids they can dissuade from bad choices by reminding them about their upcoming football game, and which they have to watch closely all evening long.
They know what a dangerous situation looks like, and what situations just look dangerous.
Therefore, they serve as effective buffers between youth and law enforcement.
The quality of policing in the square, and the level of understanding offered to the kids, differs based on the cop, both Madden and Harris tell me. Generally, though, it’s in no one’s interest to turn a small Market Square altercation into a matter of criminal justice.
Kid-friendly
Does the new curfew-style rule, requiring children under 18 to be accompanied but an adult over 21 during most afternoons and evenings, upset this balance? As a father of seven kids aged 1 to 12, I’m sensitive to unnecessary restrictions on young people’s enjoyment of public amenities. A family-friendly city is one that makes space for children, even if that means inconveniencing grown-ups a little bit.
I didn’t have a firm opinion of the rule until I talked to the people actually doing the work of youth outreach in the square. And they made it clear that not only are they OK with it: They’ve been asking for it and helped design it.
The policy, Madden said, “created the balance” that square visitors can now enjoy. He has tracked far fewer interventions in the past few weeks, even on non-curfew days, than before it went into effect.
An orderly Market Square isn’t just good for business owners and tourists and other adults: It’s good for the kids. Remember why young people are drawn to the courtyard to begin with: socialization and safety. If the square becomes too crowded with kids, and neither outreach workers nor law enforcement can adequately observe developing situations, it becomes not just inhospitable for adults but also for the kids.
There is a complication, though — one raised repeatedly during an at-times raucous panel discussion Tuesday evening convened by Brandi Fisher of Rise Up 365, which serves at-risk youth and young adults in Downtown. It’s best related as a question because right now there is no good answer: Where are kids to go, if not Market Square or other public spaces where they feel they can socialize safely?
This drives home how imposing rules on Market Square is a remedial action, responding to a lack of resources and institutions elsewhere — not just in Downtown, but in Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods. Parents and community leaders are also right to be concerned that children are being shuffled around with no plan for where to put them.
A real solution must include the proliferation of organizations like Brookline Teen Outreach, in my home neighborhood, which attracts young people from all over the city to its programming, including workforce development and mental health counseling.
The necessity of order
At the same time, it’s not prudent to let the square become unlivable until more youth spaces are established: Pittsburgh police Commander Tim Novosel said at Tuesday’s event that the number of incidents requiring police in the square have roughly tripled since last year.
Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership president Jeremy Waldrup was right to say that “doing nothing was irresponsible” and that “ignoring the problem was not compassion.” Orderly public spaces are, after all, good for everyone.
“Order” is in some circles a dirty word. To some it implies control, and therefore the absence of freedom, and therefore right-wing and even fascist politics.
But what the people who work with the kids in Market Square are saying is that order is required for kids to exercise their freedom. Youth stuck in Market Square mobs are not free in any meaningful sense. And that’s not what they’re coming to the square for: They’re there for a respite from chaos, not to experience it.
You can tell that the enforcers of this policy get this because they’re doing so gently. Kids can still walk through the square unattended and even visit the restaurants. Police have only issued one citation for violating the rule in its first few weeks.
What the policy accomplishes is giving outreach workers, private security and cops leverage to tell kids who aren’t behaving constructively to move along. This makes the square more welcoming for everyone.
As Madden put it, “The people who are supposed to be here are here” — including the young people.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “It’s porch-bird season in Pittsburgh.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.