First in an occasional series examining American Rescue Plan Act spending in the Pittsburgh area.
In 2021 and 2022, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the city of Pittsburgh received from the federal government two tranches of funds totaling a smidge more than $335 million. That’s about half of the city’s usual annual operating budget.
The funds had to be assigned by the end of 2024 and spent by the end of 2026. With the exception of a few relatively small line items, the city is on track to spend its entire allotment on time.
Yet I, like most Pittsburghers, would be hard pressed to identify major improvements in services or infrastructure or anything made possible by this massive gift of federal funds. This doesn’t mean the money was useless — it’s hard to say what bad outcomes might have happened without it — but it does raise the question of whether it was used wisely.
To answer that question, we have to begin with a more basic one, which turns out to be more difficult than it seems: What was the money actually used for?
Tracking the money
Since fall of 2021, when the first American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) money hit Pittsburgh’s pocketbook, the city has made over 2,000 transactions from one of two funds: the ARPA Trust Fund and the ARPA Capital Fund. Roughly speaking, the capital fund is used as a pass-through between the trust fund and recipients to allow the city to pay vendors without the money ever touching the general fund.
Read More
That’s the federal money that’s (relatively) easy to track. In fact, I compared these transactions to the city’s self-reported use of ARPA funds and was able to account for just about every dollar spent on 30 of the six dozen projects. That’s a bit more than 40% of the projects, which altogether used about $80 million, or 24% of the federal money.
While this spending is accountable, whether it was prudent will be the subject of another column.
Regardless, that leaves more than three-quarters of the ARPA funds, about $250 million. Tracking that money is a lot murkier.
The vast majority of the remaining funds took one of three paths: directly into the general fund to pay for salaries; into the general fund by way of the Office of Management and Budget to fund other city initiatives; or into the Urban Redevelopment Authority. Once these funds left the ARPA Trust Fund, they were reported to the federal government as “expended.” But it’s all but impossible for the public to know where the money actually ended up.
Hard choices
This is because Pittsburgh used an unusually large amount of its pandemic relief money to fund ongoing government operations. By far the biggest line item in its ARPA plan, approved near the end of the Peduto administration, was “avoid layoffs”: about $113 million over four years, or one-third of the total appropriation.
But this underestimates the amount the city plowed into its everyday operations. The Brookings Institution’s nationwide ARPA tracker gives a figure of 64.6% for Pittsburgh’s “government operations” spending, compared to an average of 42.2% among all local governments that received the boost. The figure I derived from the city’s spending data is a little lower, 54.5%, but still disproportionately high.
It’s important to remember that in 2021 the city was still reeling from the effects of COVID, and preserving jobs appeared to be a necessary and humane choice. It’s easy to second-guess it a half-decade on. In the long run, the problem became that the Gainey administration did not plan effectively for the expiration of ARPA funds — including significantly adding to the city’s payroll, not just maintaining it — leading to last December’s 20% property tax hike.
But that $113 million isn’t the only ARPA money that can’t be tracked to its final destination. It’s less than half of it.
Just trust us
Additionally, Pittsburgh moved another $18 million directly into the general fund, and another $47 million through the Office of Management and Budget. Once moved out of the ARPA trust fund, the city reported the money as spent — but there has never been a public-facing way to verify where, how and whether it actually was spent.
Most notably, this includes $10 million reported as spent on the “OCHS-AHN project” line item — a proposed street medicine collaboration between the Office of Community Health and Safety and Allegheny Health Network that never came to pass. It seems the money was moved into the Stop the Violence Fund to support the Reaching Out On The Streets (ROOTS) initiative, but that’s basically guesswork.
Another vague line item is $2 million for “Community Public Safety facilities.” But, again, once the ARPA money is poured into the general fund, there’s no public way to match it to a promised expense.
The general fund isn’t the only example of this: The vendor that received by far the most ARPA money was the URA: $70 million. The authority is said by the city to have used that money on several federally approved line items, such as “property stabilization” and “Homewood development,” but there’s no way to confirm (or to disprove) that this money specifically was used for those purposes specifically.
The URA’s annual audited financial statements simply fold the pandemic funds into generic “grants” monies, and the authority hasn’t released an annual report since 2022. Altogether, that means about $250 million of ARPA money was combined with other public funds, with no public way to discern where exactly it all went — other than just-trust-us documents.
Squandered opportunity
As far as I can tell, Pittsburgh has been far from unique in this regard. And there’s no smoking gun suggesting federal money was pocketed by anyone who didn’t have a right to it.
Of course, that’s partially because it’s hard to say anything at all about where the money ended up. What we can say is that massive influxes of federal money have a limited positive effect on municipal governments and, as here, are likely to reinforce or create bad spending habits.
As for transparency, it would be a great service for Controller Rachael Heisler to use the power of her office to produce a report connecting actual city expenditures to the promised ARPA line items. This was a historic opportunity to invest in Pittsburgh, which was largely squandered. Just how badly — we can’t even know.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “My kids love Downtown. Let’s keep it that way.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.