After nearly a decade of arresting ghosts of himself, Pittsburgh’s last remaining graffiti detective is retiring.

“I’m the happiest I’ve ever been in my career,” Alphonso Sloan, a longtime detective, said last week surrounded by half-packed boxes and paperwork. “I’m actually leaving out at the happiest point in my career. It’s kind of bittersweet, you know, but I’m leaving on my terms.”

The artist-turned-officer, who joined the Pittsburgh police in 1995, knows his expertise inside and out — Det. Sloan is, after all, a former graffiti tagger himself.

“Never arrested,” he said, adding that there “could have been worse things to be doing at that age.”

Advertise with us

He said the graffiti crew that he ran with when he was a kid is the same type that he has been investigating off and on now for nearly 20 years. He’s still an artist himself, and he has a deep appreciation for the graffiti style and the art behind it.

“I know the mindset of the guys and their inspiration. A lot people say, ‘Why did they do that?’ I know why they do it,” he said. “I’ve had that feeling myself a million times.”

They do it for the accolades, he said — the recognition, the thrill, the excitement.

“But mainly for recognition from your peers. The more you’re seen, the more respect you get from your fellow taggers,” he said.

He still has his first sketchbook. He flipped through the pages last week, the colorful graffiti-style artwork popping off of the page. Three dimensional-style block numbers spelled out the year: 1987. A patchwork of colors revealed the camouflaged message within: “Fonz,” the detective’s signature.

Advertise with us

No one really took photos of their work — or of themselves with their work — back then.

Retiring Pittsburgh police Det. Alphonso Sloan shows graffiti drawings from his original sketchbook in his office at Pittsburgh police headquarters. The graffiti detectives was a graffiti artist himself during his teenage years. (Megan Guza / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“You would sketch it out in your book and you’d go paint a wall,” he said.

As far as he knows, none of his graffiti from his teenage years remains anywhere in the city, he said.

His progression to Pittsburgh police officer was both natural and a last resort. His mother was a city police sergeant, and his father was a Pittsburgh Housing Authority police officer. He didn’t plan to become an officer — even as the son of two cops, he said, he often experienced the same profiling and racism that other Black teens did — but the police academy was always an option.

Det. Sloan graduated from the Art Institute in 1993 and found a dearth of art-related jobs available.

Advertise with us

“I did all the things I was supposed to do — I cut my hair short, I had a nice portfolio,” he said. “I mean, I couldn’t even get a job at an art supply store.”

The call to join the police academy came at a fortuitous time — it was a necessity, he said, but he has no regrets. But there have been highs and lows since he became a patrol officer in 1995. He said the racism he experienced in those first 10 years in the bureau made them some of the worst of his life.

“I almost walked away plenty of times,” he said.

But he had seen what his mother went through as a Black woman coming up the ranks in the 1980s, and so he knew he would be walking into a tenuous situation.

“[I knew] a lot of officers are going to look at me as an adversary as opposed to a co-worker,” he said. “I  A lot things happened in that first 10 years, but my mom taught me you just got to keep fighting, you got to hang in there.”

Advertise with us

In 2005, then-Chief Nate Harper assigned him to the burgeoning graffiti squad. That’s how he ended up arresting the ghosts of his former self — young people with talent and paint and the stomach to take the chance.

“It’s a weird feeling,” he said.

He said one of his old cohorts from “back in the day” once called him a cannibal.

“I love the job that I do,” he said. “I do have mixed feelings at times because some of the people that we arrest — they’re artists, they have talent. And I know that could have been me back in my teenage years.”

He said that while he doesn’t regret any of the arrests he has made, he wishes he could have met some of those people under different circumstances. Among them: Baron Batch, an artist and running back who played a year with the Steelers from 2011 to 2012.

Advertise with us

In 2016, the growing popularity of Mr. Batch’s art linked him to graffiti along the Three Rivers Heritage Trail between the Hot Metal Bridge and the Mon Wharf, and Pittsburgh police issued a warrant on 30 counts of criminal mischief.

He turned himself in a few days later, and Mr. Batch was ultimately given an 18-month suspended sentence and entered into the Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition program (ARD), which is a program for first-time nonviolent offenders. He had to perform 150 hours of community service.

“I can’t say I regret arresting him, but I guess I do,” Det. Sloan said reflecting back on that time. “It’s weird.”

’A cat and mouse game’

After he turns in his paperwork on Monday, the graffiti squad that has been down to one for years will cease to exist. Police spokeswoman Cara Cruz said plainclothes detectives will investigate graffiti reports. The bureau has no plans to replace him or his supervisor, who retired last week.

The squad was disbanded briefly in 2013 but brought back two years later after taggers caused tens of thousands of dollars in damage to the Birmingham Bridge. PennDOT crews were in the process of a multimillion-dollar project to rehab the bridge when the massive graffiti tag — the name KELI with a peace sign, heart, and smiley face — was painted along the east side of the bridge.

Advertise with us

Its placement along the outer side of the bridge meant Pittsburgh’s “graffiti buster” team, part of the Department of Public Works, couldn’t get to it. Det. Sloan said the contractor was on the hook for some $70,000 to $80,000.

“I think that was the turning point where [then-Mayor Bill Peduto] decided to bring us back,” he said.

At the same time, the detective said, some types of graffiti have become more acceptable. For example, in the weeks after George Floyd was killed by a now-former Minneapolis police officer in 2020, guerilla artists took to the riverwalk under the 10th Street Bypass. The original mural contained just 16 12-foot letters outlined in red: Black Lives Matter.

The artists began their work in the daylight, and someone called 911 to report what was technically vandalism of city property. Det. Sloan said he knew that whatever happened, it would be a sensitive issue. He consulted with Mr. Peduto’s office.

“And he said, ‘I like the graffiti, don’t charge them, we’re going to keep it up.’ ”

Advertise with us

Indeed, the mural still stands today, although it’s evolved to include even more art — bright orange butterflies, colorful flowers, and poignant portraits of individuals killed by police.

“That’s a huge difference,” Det. Sloan said. “That wouldn’t have happened 15 years ago. It doesn’t matter what the content of your graffiti was.”

Another example are the dinosaurs (that for years many thought were geese) painted atop one of the arches of the 10th Street Bridge. Artist Tim Kaulen painted them there in the 1990s, and a petition to keep the silhouettes gained traction when the bridge was rehabbed and repainted in 2018. Officials allowed Mr. Kaulen to repaint the dino geese — legally, this time.

Other graffiti remains unwelcome. Among the most notorious taggers in the city was the late Daniel Montano, one of few taggers who actually served jail time. The prolific graffiti artist used the tag MFONE, and his first arrest was in 2005 when he was caught in the act in East Liberty. He spent five days in jail and paid a $1,001 fine.

Two years later, he was arrested again in what was described the largest graffiti bust in the country — some $500,000 in damage across the city. He ultimately pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 2½ to 5 years in prison.

Advertise with us

He was charged again in 2016, accused again of causing hundreds of thousands in damage, after another investigation by Det. Sloan and other officers who were, at the time, assigned to the graffiti squad. A conviction would have likely drawn more jail time, but he was acquitted in 2017. He died a few weeks later.

Those cases, Det. Sloan said, were some of the squad’s largest prosecutions, and the one that ended in acquittal was the only case they lost, he said.

“I always looked at is as, I don’t hate any of these guys. I understand them. I’m a huge admirer of their artwork, but they always look at me as an adversary,” he said, pointing to some standoffs and uncomfortable situations where he and former arrestees have been in the same art show. “It’s a cat and mouse game. I’m the cat, you’re the mouse. My job is to catch you; your job is to not get caught. Sometimes, I do my job a little better than yours.”