A use-of-force expert said Thursday that a former Pittsburgh police officer was justified in shoving a drunk man to the ground and punching him during a violent encounter outside Heinz Field in 2015.

Clifford Jobe, a former state trooper testifying for the defense in the government’s civil rights case against Stephen Matakovich, said that Mr. Matakovich had to take control of a dangerous situation when he encountered Gabriel Despres, then 19, who refused to leave the stadium during high school football playoffs.

Asked by Mr. Matakovich’s lawyer if Mr. Despres had posed a threat, he said yes.

In reviewing a video of the incident, listening to testimony and reading reports, he said Mr. Despres fixed Mr. Matakovich with a stare, turned sideways as if to fight and put his hands his pockets, which he said poses a threat to any officer.

Advertise with us

Asked by Mr. Matakovich’s lawyer, Tina Miller, if an officer has to wait for someone to attack before taking action, he said “absolutely not.”

Even after Mr. Matakovich shoved him to the ground, he said, Mr. Despres faced several options that could have ended the conflict.

“Fight or flight,” he said.

He could have stayed on the ground.

“Submit. Surrender. Comply,” said Mr. Jobe.

Advertise with us

Instead, he said, he got up and fought with the officer, requiring that Mr. Matakovich defend himself with a series of strikes.

Mr. Jobe was called by the defense to bolster Mr. Matakovich’s testimony Wednesday and Thursday in which he said he reacted because he felt Mr. Despres was about to attack him.

Mr. Matakovich also said the video, the government’s key piece of evidence, shows his actions but doesn’t capture his mindset or the total circumstances.

“You can watch the video,” he said, “[but] it doesn’t show instinct, it doesn’t show emotion, it doesn’t show fear.”

Mr. Jobe agreed.

Advertise with us

“It’s just a snapshot,” he said.

Mr. Matakovich is on trial in U.S. District Court on charges of depriving Mr. Despres of his civil rights and filing a false police report justifying his use of force.

The government did not put Mr. Despres on the stand. At a preliminary hearing in state court, he had said he did not remember much of what happened.

Prosecutors instead built their case on the video and the testimony of security staff at the game who witnessed the encounter.

All of them said that Mr. Despres, while drunk and belligerent, posed no threat to anyone when Mr. Matakovich suddenly pushed him to the ground and punched him in the head repeatedly.

Advertise with us

The trial will continue Friday.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551.