Pittsburgh officials promised to review their responses to last month’s flooding along Washington Boulevard while they work toward longer-term solutions, which could include building a retention pond and demolishing two police facilities.

In the three weeks since a storm inundated the flood-prone roadway and stranded drivers, city leaders have met with state officials and a U.S. senator to discuss plans that could prevent fatalities, according to Kevin Acklin, chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto.

Those plans could include demolishing the Zone 5 police station and an old training academy building that sit in the middle of the flood zone and building a retention pond or elevating the roadway, which dips at an angle that contributes to the flooding.

Officials have also said they will review the public safety response, given that a city plan to have officers block the road was delayed when first responders were swamped with other calls Aug. 28, the day of the last major flood.

Advertise with us

In the meantime, city officials continue to work with the state Department of Transportation to complete plans for the city to take over legal ownership of the floodgate and warning system installed after a fatal flood in 2011.

“It’s a complex problem, but I think we know what we need to do,” Mr. Acklin said.

Working on new plans

Fixing the floodgates amounts to restoring what was already a Band-Aid — a temporary fix to a larger problem that’s been brewing for decades, according to the Peduto administration.

Development around Washington Boulevard has helped turn the corridor into a major collection point for storm water.

Advertise with us

To curb future floods there, Mr. Acklin said, the city is exploring options with officials including U.S. Sen. Bob Casey and agencies such as the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority.

The PWSA conversations focus on “retaining some of the water at its sources” rather than letting it pour straight into storm sewers, Mr. Acklin said. That matches Mr. Peduto’s broader hope for widespread “green infrastructure” to tame destructive runoff.

Correcting the Washington Boulevard mess alone could take years and cost tens of millions of dollars, the mayor has warned. Mr. Acklin said the state Department of Community and Economic Development has invited Pittsburgh to submit proposals for support.

“We recognize the critical need for increased flood mitigation on Washington Boulevard,” DCED Secretary Dennis Davin said in a statement.

Previous indications of a problem

Advertise with us

The floodgates malfunctioned at least twice prior to the latest flooding.

Public safety director Wendell Hissrich said he learned that the gate near the intersection of Washington and Allegheny River boulevards did not drop during a storm June 16. Mr. Acklin said the problem was corrected “immediately” and that city and state officials met after that to discuss gate maintenance.

City officials had long maintained that the gates were owned by PennDOT, while PennDOT has said it turned them over to the city years ago.

In July, the gate near the intersection of Washington and Negley Run boulevards dropped unexpectedly and a driver hit it, breaking the arm. Officials replaced the arm.

Mr. Hissrich said he knew that there had been problems with one gate. But he said he didn’t expect a complete failure of all three.

Advertise with us

When he went to the scene Aug. 28 he was stunned. “People told me the horror stories that happened during [2011]. And, until I saw it myself, I didn’t believe it.”

Aug. 28 response

On that day, he said, police calls came quickly across the radio. The city had already responded to a SWAT call and multiple structure fires. As he approached, Mr. Hissrich said he passed two police cars. He didn’t see any barricades blocking Washington Boulevard.

Mr. Hissrich called out to dispatch to have officers lower the Washington Boulevard floodgates, which were still up.

“The dispatcher came back and said twice that they attempted and it was unsuccessful, so obviously they had attempted twice to lower the gates without success,” he said.

Advertise with us

As Mr. Hissrich pulled up near the police bureau’s training academy, he and another officer ran to help rescue a woman whose car was rapidly submerging.

“I didn’t ask whether she went around police vehicles, barricades or whatever,” Mr. Hissrich said. “She told me she thought she could make it through. “

It’s not clear exactly when the roadway was blocked. Officials have said that first responders didn’t always note arrival times because they were rushing to respond to calls for flooding.

The city’s contingency plan since the fatal flood in 2011 has been to have officers “on their own, shut the road down, because you can’t always rely on mechanical devices to always work,” Mr. Hissrich said.

Asked whether the city has enough officers to ensure that its backup plan will always work, he said, “I don’t really want to speculate on that, whether or not we have enough officers…

Advertise with us

“There comes a point in time [when] you’re out of resources. To shut those three intersections off, even with barricades, you need probably a minimum of five police officers.”

Mr. Hissrich compared making decisions about where to deploy first responders to a chess game.

“Do you save a life, or do you block the road and hope that the drivers use due caution and see the water coming up and see the police vehicles there and see the potential rescue?” he asked. “We would have been criticized if we had blocked the road with two officers and the woman drowned.”

Officials said they will create a better plan to account for keys used to turn the gates on and off. They announced that after a private company, Bronder Technical Services, found during a preliminary review that the gates, water sensors and flashing warning lights were in the off position during recent flooding.

Mike Gable, director of city Public Works, has said the city doesn’t keep a log of the keys or when they’re used. Mr. Hissrich said that in public safety only he and deputy director Michael Huss have keys for the gates.

“I think in the future, once again, you learn from your mistake or errors that there has to be an accountability of those keys,” Mr. Hissrich said. “I don’t think it was [any] mischief done here.”