Pittsburgh officials described Monday “repeated failures” of an emergency gate system meant to block traffic during heavy rain at a flood-prone roadway in the East End and acknowledged that the gates had not been inspected in three years.
Their comments came a day after a storm flooded Washington Boulevard, stranding several people inside their cars until police, firefighters and others could help rescue them and block the roads.
Maintenance of the system has been a subject of debate in recent years, with the city saying it took responsibility for the gates only this summer. The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, however, in a 2013 letter transferred “ownership, operation and maintenance responsibilities ... to the city of Pittsburgh Department of Public Works.”
“I’m very disappointed, and it’s alarming for all of us,” said Councilwoman Deb Gross, whose district includes one side of Washington Boulevard. She added that she was told just 10 days ago that the system was functioning properly. “It’s dangerous, and it looks like very little has been done.”
Mayor Bill Peduto and his administration said Monday that they had approved an $8,000 contract for a company to evaluate the floodgates. They also promised semi-regular inspections of the gates and expressed hope that they could meet with the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority and the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority to discuss larger plans to try to reduce flooding.
To some, their statements sounded familiar.
Read More
The floodgates are “just sort of putting a Band-Aid on a more serious problem, and obviously not a very good Band-Aid, because it’s not working,” said Alan Perer, an attorney who represents the relatives of some of the four people killed in a flood along Washington Boulevard in August 2011.
Pittsburgh officials said they narrowly avoided fatalities again Sunday. Meteorologists sent out a storm warning hours before the flooding began, and the city said it sent out crews to clean catch basins.
About 6:15 p.m. — four hours after the National Weather Service sent out its first warning — city officials “were made aware of a storm that was developing along the east side of Pittsburgh,” public safety director Wendell Hissrich said during a news conference Monday.
About 6:30 p.m., Mr. Hissrich said, officials learned of flooding along Washington Boulevard and a car that was trapped. Three people were rescued from that vehicle.
About 15 minutes later, he said, a 54-year-old woman in a van was stranded near the Zone 5 police station on Washington Boulevard. First responders rescued her, too.
“I’m positive without their valor in attempting to save her... that we may have lost another life on Washington Boulevard,” Mr. Hissrich said.
By 6:48 p.m., a spokeswoman said, police had blocked Washington Boulevard near the intersection of Negley Run Boulevard, where one of the floodgates would have dropped had it been working.
When the first calls came in for flooding, spokeswoman Sonya Toler said, police were wrapping up a SWAT call in Bloomfield.
“There was a manpower issue because of that major event with ... SWAT,” she said. “We can’t afford to have cars just sitting there when we have other 911 calls that need to be addressed.”
PennDOT paid $400,000 to have the floodgates installed after the August 2011 flood killed four people. The plan, one former city official said, was for the city to take over maintenance of the gates.
That was even announced in a news release sent by city officials in 2012, when then-Mayor Luke Ravenstahl promised a gate system that would ensure that “during flash flood situations no vehicles enter this part of Washington Boulevard."
“There was an agreement. Everybody knew it,” said Rob Kaczorowski, former director of the city’s Public Works department.
PennDOT sent a letter May 3, 2013, telling city officials that the gates had been “fully activated” two months prior and workers who checked them found “no malfunctions.”
The letter also says that the state “grants, conveys and assigns ownership, operation and maintenance responsibilities ... to the City of Pittsburgh Department of Public Works.”
Until recently, city officials said, they were trying to figure out who had ownership of the gates. Copied on that 2013 letter was then-public safety director Michael Huss, who still works in City Hall. Mr. Huss said through a spokeswoman that he did not remember the letter.
Officials in Mr. Peduto’s administration said their law department spent some time “studying how the gates would be taken over,” according to a spokesman.
Kevin Acklin, current chief of staff to Mr. Peduto, said he “never had a conversation with Mike Huss about this system,” and he does not believe the letter constitutes a formal exchange of ownership for the gates.
“A party can’t just send a letter to someone and assign a responsibility to them,” Mr. Acklin said.
Mr. Acklin said city officials met with state officials and a contractor in June to discuss taking over maintenance of the gates, which had by that point “started to show signs of failure.”
One of the gates, at the intersection of Negley Run and Washington boulevards, broke in early July after it “unexpectedly dropped” and a driver hit it. The city then began sending officers to block the road if there was a threat of flooding.
Sunday night, officials said, all of the gates malfunctioned, and officials couldn’t get them to go down automatically or by hand.
“As it became something that wasn’t functioning, we addressed it and that’s what we’re in the process of doing,” Mr. Acklin said. “It worked for a while.”
Reporters Jonathan D. Silver, Madeline Kennedy and Diana Nelson Jones contributed. Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1438 or on Twitter @LizNavratil.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.