Washington Boulevard’s broken floodgate system, meant to keep people from drowning in their vehicles during torrential downpours that occasionally flood the heavily traveled road in Pittsburgh’s East End, operates with six warning signals, three gates and two sensors.

Each has its own control unit with an on/​off switch.

A recent inspection uncovered something that Public Works Director Mike Gable said he found odd: Each control unit was switched off. That means the water sensors could not work, the warning lights could not activate, and the swing arms could not descend to block traffic from entering the roadway at three key junctions.

“I really don’t want to dwell on this a lot because there’s a lot of questions to ask about that,” Mr. Gable said Monday following release of a memo he sent to his boss, Mayor Bill Peduto, about the problems with the $450,000 system. “There’s a lot to be discussed here. I need more details.”

Advertise with us

If the fact that all units were switched off were the only reason that the system failed Aug. 28, when rain swamped the boulevard and forced emergency responders to rescue several motorists, the remedy would seem obvious. But the discovery was only one of numerous technical glitches and problems uncovered recently by the Butler County contractor that built the system.

Bronder Technical Services of Prospect found an array of failures, ranging from dead batteries, to a blown surge protector, to key parts that need to be replaced, according to the memo.

All things considered, Mr. Gable said, the news wasn’t so terrible.

“From what I know about the system,” Mr. Gable said, “I'm more pleasantly surprised that it’s not as bad as it was made out to be.”

He added that while the gate arms still do not work, the flashing lights that warn motorists of potential flooding are now operational. In some cases, easy fixes required nothing more than a new fuse or swapping out a battery.

Advertise with us

“Those six signals all are operational. Right now the gates would not drop, and that’s because of different reasons: the controller on one, the radio signal on another,” Mr. Gable said. “It’s not complete failure of the whole system. I don’t think it ever was a complete failure of the whole system. All 11 units were not in total failure.”

A full report — along with recommendations from Bronder and an estimate of how much fixes would cost — is expected later this week.

Katie O’Malley, a spokeswoman for Mr. Peduto, said City Council would have to vote on any capital expenditures to repair the system.

“The report makes the repairs seems pretty straightforward. And certainly, regardless of who currently owns the system, it is important for all of us that repairs are made and the public knows that the gates are functional,” said Councilwoman Deb Gross, whose district includes one side of Washington Boulevard.

The problem-plagued system was installed in 2012 in response to the deaths a year earlier of four people trapped in a flash flood along Washington Boulevard.

Advertise with us

Disputes over whether the city or the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation owns the gates, and which entity is responsible for maintenance, led to a four-year period — from May 2012 to this summer — when apparently no one conducted a full inspection of the system.

Over that time, according to Bronder, a master sensor lost power; a main controller and radio failed; a surge protector was blown at the master controller location, apparently due to a lightning strike; and a battery lost its recharging capability.

“It was showing its age. It is almost five years old, and then nobody...looked at it for a period of time,” Mr. Gable said. “We want to get it fixed, and we want to put eyes and ears on it on a monthly basis or whatever the recommended schedule is.”

Last month Dan Cessna, executive director for the PennDOT district that covers Pittsburgh, said the city told PennDOT in May that it consulted with its law department and “agreed a separate contract to cover this was not necessary.”

On Monday, however, Ms. O’Malley, the city spokeswoman, said, “The ownership and liability for the gates were never formally accepted by the city, and remain with PennDOT.” She added that “no formal [transfer] agreement has been executed. For the sake of public safety, we are taking the initiative to move forward and fix the system, and will handle the formal legal transfer of ownership with PennDOT separately.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.