In spring 2012, less than a year after four people died in a flash flood on Washington Boulevard in Pittsburgh’s East End, Raymond V. DeMichiei oversaw two tests of a $450,000 automated gate system meant to block traffic and save lives along the flood-prone roadway.

Testing consisted of closing the street that runs by the city’s Zone 5 police station, making a dam around a sensor, filling it with water until a trigger point was reached and watching to see whether the system activated. Gates at three locations were supposed to descend like those at a railroad crossing and prevent vehicles from entering the boulevard.

Mr. DeMichiei, the city’s former deputy director of emergency management, said the first test failed — likely because of interference with the radio frequency that controls the gates — but the second one worked.

“I signed my name on it, saying it functions as advertised,” Mr. DeMichiei, who is retired, said Tuesday. “As far as I know, it wasn’t tested since then.”

Advertise with us

Although a private company in California, High Sierra Electronics, put the system through its paces a year later in April 2013, just before it went live, and found no malfunctions, Mr. DeMichiei was right: The city acknowledged this week that “the system has not been fully inspected since it was erected...” Mr. DeMichiei said he knew the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation intended to install the system and then transfer ownership to the city.

“That was the plan,” Mr. DeMichiei said. “It was never agreed to.”

As a result, who would perform ongoing inspections and maintenance was left unclear and unresolved between May 2012 and this summer.

That lack of city testing, and what a Pittsburgh official this week called “repeated failures” of the system, laid the groundwork for an incident last weekend during heavy rains that bore disturbing similarities to the August 2011 flood, which killed a 72-year-old woman, a mother and her two young daughters. When the gates failed Sunday and motorists became trapped by rising waters, emergency responders had to scramble to rescue several people from their vehicles.

Mike Gable, director of Pittsburgh’s Public Works department, said the city has not been keeping a log of problems with the flood gates. He said he thinks the number of problems has been increasing based on the number of emails he receives about the gates, most of which come from public safety officials.

Advertise with us

“There has been more of an increase in frequency or failure,” he said Tuesday. “There’s been no eyes on this thing until now.”

He said the city will have a list of things to check when it begins inspecting the gates.

Those inspections, Mr. Gable said, “will be performed monthly or quarterly or once or twice a year,” depending on what comes out of a contractor’s evaluation of the system.

Inspections are crucial for proper upkeep of the system, according to Mr. DeMichiei.

“It’s a piece of equipment. It has to be maintained. It has to be looked at. It has to have a high degree of maintenance because it’s an emergency piece of equipment,” Mr. DeMichiei said.

Advertise with us

After the last inspections of the system involving the city on May 1 and May 2, 2012, which PennDOT said included Mr. DeMichiei and then-public safety director Mike Huss (the city’s current deputy public safety director), PennDOT effectively washed its hands of any maintenance.

Mr. DeMichiei acknowledged that he received a May 3, 2013, letter from PennDOT conveying “ownership, operation and maintenance responsibilities” of the gate system to the city. However, he said, things were not so simple.

“I did a check on them when they were completed. They worked. PennDOT sent us a letter saying they’re now yours. I said, ‘Whoa. It doesn’t work that way. You write up an agreement letter and send it to the city Law Department that officially accepts the transference of the gates from PennDOT to us.’ And I sent that up to the Law Department, and I have no idea what happened after that,” Mr. DeMichiei said.

“I was more than willing to be responsible for the yearly testing. No one ever told us it was ours. No one ever told us it was our system for me to go test,” Mr. DeMichiei added. “We never signed the piece of paper that said this is our system. So I’m not going to test a system that is not mine.”

Dan Cessna, executive director for the PennDOT district that covers Pittsburgh, said he did not receive any written responses from the city regarding the letter PennDOT sent transferring ownership of the flood gates.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cessna said Mr. DeMichiei contacted him to ask “whether a formal ownership and maintenance agreement was possible.”

“We said we would consider it and prepared a draft agreement,” Mr. Cessna said Tuesday in an email. “We never received any comments on it, nor was it executed by the City.”

In May, when Mayor Bill Peduto was in charge, Mr. Cessna said the city told PennDOT that it consulted with its law department and “agreed a separate contract to cover this was not necessary.”

Mr. DeMichiei said he did not think anything nefarious had occurred. Rather, he said, he believes the issue slipped between the cracks during the change in mayoral administrations in 2014.

Dan Regan, city solicitor for the administration of the city’s previous mayor, Luke Ravenstahl, said Tuesday, “To my recollection, there was never a legal duty for the city to maintain that system,” he said.

Advertise with us

Tim McNulty, spokesman for Mayor Bill Peduto, said he could not speak to what happened during the previous administration.

“I know that our law department had concerns in studying the transfer of the ownership of the gates at the start of this administration and how that would be structured, if there had to be special legal agreements put in place. And eventually we decided, along with the public works department, that none of that was necessary and that we could take the gates over like we take over traffic signals,” Mr. McNulty said.

“We started looking at the operation of the gates this summer, June, July, when failures had been reported. However, we’re fairly certain most of the system has been working until fairly recently,” Mr. McNulty said. “There are very few reports, if any, of the gates not working. Up until recently the manual switch-on from the Zone 5 station was working.”

Mr. DeMichiei, who said he remains troubled by the deaths in 2011, hopes Sunday’s event serves as a warning.

“Knock on wood, we learned a lesson the other day that the system isn’t working the way we thought it was going to work. For whatever reason, nobody died. Now we better make sure it works right. We dodged a bullet,” Mr. DeMichiei said.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1438 or on Twitter @LizNavratil.