To sum up recent events, Pittsburgh has a heavily traveled road that can kill when it rains and a $450,000 fail-safe system there that works only halfway (that would be the fail half).

So, after a couple of near-fatal accidents during Sunday evening’s rainstorm, the city is talking again of doing something about Washington Boulevard. Talking about that is a Pittsburgh tradition older than Mayor Bill Peduto himself, going back at least 65 years.

After a 1951 drowning of a motorist there, and again after a flash flood killed four people on the boulevard in August 2011, there were scrambles to do something about the unnatural bathtub the roadway system creates when it pours. Yet all that came out of the 2011 hand-wringing was a floodgate meant to block traffic when it rains.

That doesn’t work. It broke in early July, stayed broken until it was purportedly repaired last week, but didn’t work last weekend at flood time. It took heroic rescues to save four people from their cars.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto, in a Monday press conference, announced big plans but it will be a long time before that road is safe. Because Allegheny River Boulevard is in effect a dam for any waters taking their natural course toward the river, the road system “is designed to fail,” the mayor acknowledged.

Making a hole in that dam has been mentioned for a decade or more, but there are no engineering plans to do that, Mr. Peduto said. Even if there were, he said, that hole wouldn’t solve the problem.

The goal has to be stopping rainwater from rushing into that valley from the surrounding hillsides, making them into something “more like a sponge than a funnel,” he said. That’s also much easier said than done.

The mayor promises a comprehensive plan, a year in the making, for better stormwater management citywide. That product of two international engineering firms, Mott MacDonald and Phronesis, is expected late next month or early October. The mayor envisions paying surrounding municipalities such as Verona and Penn Hills to find “green solutions” to soak up more rainwater there.

Five years ago, Patrick Dowd, then a city councilman, advocated “daylighting” the inadequate underground stormwater pipes that flank Washington Boulevard. A natural stream once flowed through that valley but civil engineers vanquished that a century ago. It’s not nice to fool Mother Nature. Those pipes, only 8½ and 9 feet in diameter, can’t handle a stream and rainwater, too.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto said that could be part of the solution. Former Mayor Tom Murphy said Monday nobody has reached out to him, but he’s been to the site and believes the flow can be daylighted the way Nine Mile Run was during his administration. The valley could even become a park for surrounding neighborhoods.

“Smart young engineers could figure out the original flow,” he said.

There are yellowed clippings in the newspaper’s Washington Boulevard file that show how long this fiasco of stifled plans has crawled on. “Flood Warning Lights Urged For Washington Boulevard” is from September 1953 and “Big Flood Job Planned by City” is from February 1960.

Yet here we are, 56 years later, with the men who hatched those unfinished plans mostly in the ground like the pipes. It’s another August in Pittsburgh and there’s reason to fear the rain.

“This will be a rallying cry as we meet with Alcosan,” Mr. Peduto pledged at the latest post-flood press conference.

Advertise with us

But there’s already been too much talk and way too little action. Mr. Dowd spoke of the need to build the political will to make a significant impact on that valley, but how many more signs from God does a city need before it unplugs a tub?

When I spoke to Mr. Dowd five years ago, he said, “I can’t imagine not doing something here.” On Monday, he said he still can’t imagine it.

Sadly, plenty of us still can.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or on Twitter @brotheroneill