A second suspect has been charged in the mid-October execution-style slaying of a Mount Oliver man, authorities announced today.

Amirae Jamal Benton, 18, of the North Side was arrested today in the death of Justin Granda, 28, in the early morning hours of Oct. 11 in the 2800 block of Arlington Avenue in Arlington, according to the state attorney general’s office.

Amirae Benton

Lucas Guggenheimer, 20, of Carnegie was already charged in the death and faces trial. He is scheduled for a formal arraignment March 16.

Advertise with us

The AG’s office said that Mr. Benton was originally thought to be a witness to the homicide, but investigators later determined that two guns were used to shoot Granda. Authorities then developed Mr. Benton as a suspect, the AG’s office said. Several sources said the AG’s office took the case from the district attorney’s office because Mr. Benton’s mother works in the DA’s office.

Pittsburgh police said in October that Granda and Guggenheimer went to the Turtle Creek home of Seth Sperber to buy marijuana. Mr. Sperber’s brother, Sean Sperber, was also in the residence.

But once at the house, police said, Guggenheimer tried to rob Mr. Sperber and shot his brother, Seth Sperber, in the leg after a struggle ensued over a gun.

Granda ran out of the house after the failed robbery attempt, said police, who charged police with robbery and attempted homicide in that incident.

Seth Sperber said that Granda ran out of the back door after Guggenheimer yelling, “Why would you do that to him, why would you do that to him?” according to a criminal complaint.

Advertise with us

A short time after leaving the Sperbers' house, by then early Oct. 11, according to police, Granda was in the 2800 block of Arlington Avenue in Arlington with Guggenheimer and Mr. Benton, who authorities did not identified until today.

Police said that Granda was shot multiple times while lying on the ground by two different guns, indicating that he was shot by two different people, according to the AG’s office.

The AG’s office said that Mr. Benton gave investigators several inconsistent statements about where he was the night of the shooting.

Security camera video showed the three men walking together around the time of the incident in the area that the shooting occurred, the AG’s office said.

It was unclear when Mr. Benton joined Guggenheimer and Granda that night. A witness with a Pittsburgh cab company, however, told authorities that she drove three men that fit the description of the suspects and victim from Pittsburgh to the house where the attempted robbery occurred then back to Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Mr. Benton was placed in the Allegheny County Jail and was denied bail.

He faces a preliminary hearing March 18.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.