Two men who prosecutors say killed an acquaintance to keep him from linking them to a shooting during a drug deal are headed to state prison.

But Amirae Benton, who was found guilty by a jury Friday of first-degree murder by an Allegheny County jury, will receive a mandatory sentence of life without parole, while his co-defendant, Lucas Guggenheimer, who was found guilty of third-degree murder, faces significantly less prison time.

Investigators say both killed Justin Granda, 28, of Mount Oliver on Oct. 11, 2015, during a confrontation in Pittsburgh’s Arlington neighborhood after the trio went to buy marijuana in Turtle Creek.

While Mr. Benton remained in a cab the men had taken to get to Turtle Creek, Mr. Guggenheimer and Mr. Granda went inside a house. The prosecution contends Mr. Guggenheimer pulled a gun to rob the men who lived there. A scuffle ensued, and one person was shot and wounded. Mr. Granda fled so quickly that he left his cell phone behind.

Advertise with us

The three men took the same cab back to Arlington, where Mr. Benton and Mr. Guggenheimer killed Mr. Granda.

The prosecution contended they were so angry that Mr. Granda left his cell phone behind — potentially tying them to the crime — that they killed him.

“All the evidence points to that man chasing a human being and shooting him like an animal on the cold, filthy street of Arlington Avenue,” Chief Deputy Attorney General Laura Ditka said in her closing argument in the Benton case.

In addition to first-degree murder, Mr. Benton, 19, of Manchester, was found guilty of robbery, conspiracy to commit robbery, obstruction and a gun offense.

Defense attorney Thomas N. Farrell argued that while his client has long hair, a witness on Arlington Avenue saw a tall black man with short hair get into a car almost immediately after shots were fired. He also told the jury that his client encountered police shortly after the shooting and he was calm and had no weapon.

Advertise with us

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani will sentence Mr. Benton on July 19; Mr. Guggenheimer, 22, of Carnegie is to be sentenced next week.

Mr. Guggenheimer was arrested two weeks after the slaying, but Mr. Benton wasn’t charged until March 2016. Early in the investigation, Mr. Benton cooperated and was even set to testify against Mr. Guggenheimer at a preliminary hearing.

But Ms. Ditka — whose state office handled the case because Mr. Benton’s mother works in the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office — told the jury that Mr. Benton changed his story three times, and evidence in the case pointed to him and Mr. Guggenheimer plotting the crime together.