A Carnegie man will stand trial on charges he shot and killed a man after he attempted to rob and then shot another man on a mid-October night, according to police.
Lucas Guggenheimer, 20, was held for trial in the death of Justin Granda, 28, of Mount Oliver on Oct. 11 by District Judge James Hanley today at a preliminary hearing at City Court, Downtown.
Police said that Guggenheimer went with Granda late on Oct. 10 to the Turtle Creek home of Sean Sperber to buy marijuana. But once at the house, police said, Guggenheimer tried to rob Mr. Sperber and shot his brother, Seth Sperber, in the leg after a struggle ensued over the gun.
Seth Sperber said that Granda ran out of the back door after Guggenheimer yelling, “Why would you do that to him, why would you do that to him?” according to a criminal complaint.
The Sperbers have not been charged in the case.
Guggenheimer was charged with attempted homicide from that altercation, a charge which defense attorney Ralph Karsh argued because, he said, the gun went off during a struggle and there was no attempt to shoot Seth Sperber.
District Judge Hanley would hold the charge for court.
A short time after leaving the Sperbers' house, by then early Oct. 11, according to police, Guggenheimer was in the 2800 block of Arlington Avenue in Arlington with Granda and another man, who was not identified. Police said Mr. Guggenheimer shot Granda several times in his back and in the back of his head.
The Allegheny County medical examiner’s office said the bullet casings from the bullet that struck Mr. Sperber matched the bullets that killed Granda, and determined that they were fired from the same gun.
"It's very tough to hear where bullets entered your son," said Granda's mother, Terelynn Turner, 56, of Mount Oliver, after the hearing.
The prosecution showed still photos from security camera video that they said proved Guggenheimer was with Granda on Arlington Avenue just before the shooting. Mr. Karsh, however, said it was impossible to identity anyone in the photos because they were not clear.
But the district judge held all charges except for a tampering with evidence charge that he dismissed.
Guggenheimer has been lodged in the Allegheny County Jail since he was arrested by the Western Pennsylvania U.S. Marshal's Fugitive Task Force on Oct. 30.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.