The Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations voted 9-2 against naming Patricia Rogers as its next director Monday. But there is much less clarity about what happens next in a hiring process that began in December.

“This has proved to be a much more difficult process than we thought,” said commission vice chairman John Tague Jr.

Ms. Rogers, an aide to Democratic Hill District state Rep. Jake Wheatley, could not be reached for comment. But while there are two other finalists, it’s not clear either will be offered the $80,000-a-year job.

“We’re going to look at what we’re going to do next,” said commission chairman Winford Craig.

Advertise with us

The commission investigates claims of discrimination, but its own internal relationships have been under strain while seeking a replacement for Charles Morrison, the longtime former director who retired in spring 2014. Its staff is being led by interim director Sarah DeCesaris Kinter.

Mr. Craig said that the commission’s personnel committee, which has led the hiring process, will be reconstituted next month. And the next step will be “all based on the new personnel committee.”

He said the change had nothing to do with the process thus far: Committees are reshuffled every September and may retain some previous members. The two “yes” votes for Ms. Rogers came from current personnel committee members: Tim Smith, who chairs the committee, and Leah Williams-Duncan.

If the new committee recommends against hiring either of the remaining finalists, Mr. Craig said, the commission might take another look at the initial field of 44 candidates. Then again, “Maybe the next move will be to start from scratch,” perhaps with help from a search firm.

In any event, he said, “We’re going to do it in a better way than how we did it before.” The commission hasn’t needed to hire a director since Mr. Morrison took the job nearly two decades ago, and “when you haven’t done something in a very long time,” Mr. Craig said, “sometimes you have to feel your way through the process.”

Advertise with us

Commissioner Helen Gerhardt, who has publicly expressed misgivings about the job search, issued a statement before the meeting, asking for a new search with “a process that allows for accountable, thorough, objective and transparent assessment” of candidates. She declined comment after the meeting.

Commissioners gathered for more than an hour and a half, mostly spent in two closed-door executive sessions. There was no public discussion about the vote or search. Commissioners departed, stone-faced, after the second closed-door session.

Mr. Craig said he’d draw up new committee rosters after the commission’s Sept. 14 meeting. While he said he couldn’t predict the process after that point, “We’ll be on a really fast track, because we want to get this thing done.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.