Pittsburgh’s Human Relations Commission, which has been without a permanent director for nearly a year and a half, is scheduled to take another vote today to fill that void, though whether the commissioners will be able to agree on a candidate remains to be seen.
The vote also comes after what Chairman Winford Craig and other commissioners acknowledge has been a far-from-perfect process to replace Charles Morrison. Mr. Morrison spent nearly two decades at the helm of the agency, which investigates claims of discrimination in housing, employment and other areas of “public accommodation.”
Mr. Morrison retired in April 2014, and the commission has struggled replace him, partly the result of a delay in appointing commissioners by Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration but also because of internal strife over hiring procedures.
“We haven’t gone through this in many years,” Mr. Craig said. “The commissioners weren’t ready for this and we made some mistakes.”
New Commissioner Helen Gerhardt called it “an improper process” plagued by a lack of transparency and accountability and added that the next director could have an impact on the “daily lives of many thousands who work, visit, or live in Pittsburgh for decades to come.”
“If an inexperienced or unqualified executive director is hired, that person will be far more vulnerable to misinformation, manipulation and undue influences,” she said.
Read More
The job, which pays $80,000 to $84,547, was initially posted in December 2014, though the commission was unable to agree on a hire. A new search launched in the spring produced four finalists out of a field of 44 candidates. On July 6, the commission voted to offer the position to a candidate who declined. On July 30, the board tabled a vote to offer the job to Patricia Rogers, a legislative aide to state Rep. Jake Wheatley, D- Hill District.
Ms. Rogers was identified when Mr. Craig called for the commission to table a vote on offering her the position, after commissioners had deadlocked on a straw vote in a closed session. Whether she will get the job today is unknown.
Ms. Gerhardt, who has frequently clashed with the commission’s leadership over the hiring process, said commissioners were only given the resume of Ms. Rogers, the preferred candidate of the commission’s personnel committee, at the July 30 meeting. Ms. Gerhardt’s request to see the resumes of other finalists was refused.
“We were expected to do an up-or-down vote on the candidate without having the time to look at [resumes]. And commissioners were not supposed to do outside research or to bring it to the personnel committee for consideration,” she said.
Mr. Craig would not discuss Ms. Gerhardt’s concerns.
Tim Smith, chairman of the personnel committee, could not be reached for comment. Ms. Rogers would not comment. Several other commissioners either referred questions to Mr. Craig or did not respond to requests for comment.
“We’ve faced some challenges, and the point is right now for us to find the most qualified person for the position,” said Amanda Rubio, a lawyer in her second full term as a commissioner. Ms. Rubio would not say whether she favored Ms. Rogers or discuss the issues Ms. Gerhardt raised in detail.
Ira Weiss, whose Downtown law firm serves as solicitor for numerous local school boards, including Pittsburgh, said that while it’s not unusual for a large commission to delegate some responsibility on hiring to a committee, other members should be expected to take an active role, since they must vote on a finalist.
“With a job at the director level, as opposed to a lesser job, I think the board would like to at least see who the finalists were, and then talk to the recommended candidate,” he said. “I equate this job to a borough manager or a [school] superintendent. This person would be the chief executive officer.”
Mr. Morrison called the decision on who should replace him one of the commission's “most important responsibilities.”
“You have to be a person for all seasons and you have to be ethically very good. You have to be knowledgeable of the law and to have some knowledge of administrative agencies and how they work,” he said. “You have to have knowledge all of the employment laws and evidentiary matters."
The commission meets at 3 p.m. today on the ninth floor of the City-County Building, Downtown.
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo. Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3533. Twitter: @CPotterPgh



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.