It’s come to this at the Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations: The humans are relating to each other so poorly that both their chairman and solicitor think they should be replaced.

At the end of a Monday meeting characterized by accusations of bad faith and racism, chairman Winford Craig said he’ll write a letter requesting that Mayor Bill Peduto replace all 14 current commissioners.

“This is a passion of mine,” Mr. Craig said of the commission, which investigates claims of discrimination. “I love the work it does.” But the commission has been without an executive director since Charles Morrison retired in early 2014, and Mr. Craig said the search for a replacement has created too much bad blood.

“Every time I tried to move things forward” at Monday’s two-hour meeting, he said, “I got pushed back.”

Advertise with us

Under the city code, the mayor may remove a commissioner, with city council approval, for “just cause.” In this case, Mr. Craig said, “The just cause is that we are totally dysfunctional.”

Monday’s meeting offered ample evidence for that diagnosis. Hardly anyone escaped criticism, and the commission’s own solicitor, Kevin Trower, urged members to resign, saying, “What you don’t have as a group is integrity.”

Much of the discussion focused on whether commissioner Helen Gerhardt, who has publicly voiced concerns about the hiring process, had run afoul of the commission’s media policy, a set of guidelines dating to 1969. The policy states that official communications are to come only from the executive director or the chair. Mr. Trower said that while the policy allows commissioners to voice their own opinions, previous commissioners “were always mindful of how [doing so] could potentially impact the overall mission.”

Ms. Gerhardt has faulted a lack of transparency in the hiring progress, including the fact that when the personnel committee recommended a candidate, other commissioners weren’t given resumes of other finalists to compare qualifications. She called that “unprecedented.”

Tim Smith, who chaired the personnel committee, noted that in not forwarding resumes, he’d merely followed a process approved by the full board. Other commissioners observed that such concerns hadn’t stopped Ms. Gerhardt from supporting an earlier choice for director, Fred Brown, who declined the position. Mr. Smith’s committee then recommended Patricia Rogers, a former school board candidate. But the full board rejected her in August.

Advertise with us

Leah Williams-Duncan, who preceded Mr. Craig as commission chair, said Ms. Gerhardt’s complaints about the commission’s leadership had damaged her and the commission. “Because [the process] didn’t turn out the way you wanted, that doesn’t mean it was inappropriate,” she said. She drew a parallel between the vote on Ms. Rogers and complaints about her leadership.

“This is how we treat black females on this commission,” she said.

Ms. Gerhardt said that while “it’s always important to question ourselves” on racial issues, “I don’t think my process concerns were in any way related to race.” She said she backed Mr. Brown, who was black, because of his qualifications and because “I was tired of fighting.”

Commissioners including Mr. Smith have accused Ms. Gerhardt of leaking Ms. Rogers’ name to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, though it was first disclosed by Mr. Craig at an open meeting. Mr. Smith, one of her accusers, apologized to her Monday.

Mayoral spokesman Tim McNulty said the mayor will review the chairman’s letter with Valerie McDonald Roberts, the city’s chief urban affairs officer and the mayor’s liaison to the commission.

Advertise with us

Mr. Craig said he planned to write to Mr. Peduto within a week, several days before the commission is scheduled to take an Oct. 31 retreat to help resolve tensions. Mr. Craig said the retreat hasn’t been canceled — though “it may be the last meeting we have.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.