The National Rifle Association came out with guns blazing this week, accusing an Allegheny County judge of delaying its lawsuit against the city of Pittsburgh without “properly familiarizing herself with even the minimum elements of the matter.”
There were “numerous deficiencies” in Judge Judith L.A. Friedman’s ruling, said Jonathan Goldstein, the attorney representing the NRA. “We intend to pursue our rights.”
The NRA sued the city of Pittsburgh along with Lancaster and Philadelphia earlier this year over their local gun ordinances.
The lawsuit was made possible by the state’s Act 192 of 2014, which allows gun groups to sue over local ordinances that go beyond state law. But Act 192’s constitutionality has been challenged in Commonwealth Court, and Pittsburgh sought to put the NRA’s lawsuit in limbo until the higher court’s ruling.
That request was heard on March 2 in motions court, where a rotating judge often decides preliminary legal matters. In a brief handwritten order, Judge Friedman granted the request “until such time as Commonwealth Court issues its decision.”
The NRA has appealed that move, spelling out its objections in a three-page petition this week. While noting that Judge Friedman was “an emergency substitute for another judge,” the filling asserts that she “admitted in open court … to not having read [legal briefs] before making her decision,” and “abused her discretion — as well as denied Plaintiff due process — by not familiarizing herself with even the minimum elements of the matter.”
Read More
Reached Thursday afternoon, Judge Friedman said “it would not be appropriate to comment,” but said “I’ll be addressing those matters in my opinion,” which she said could be filed by the end of next week.
“The judge allowed the NRA’s counsel to argue its position entirely,” said City Solicitor Lourdes Sanchez Ridge. “The NRA’s counsel argued the same position three times,” after which Judge Friedman “asked the NRA’s counsel whether he had any additional argument. The NRA’s counsel stated that he had none.”
“The court seemed committed to granting a stay, and granted one,” said Mr. Goldstein.
Judge Friedman is the only judge to have done so thus far. A county judge denied Lancaster’s request for a stay last month; a hearing on a similar request in Philadelphia is scheduled for April 23.
Gun owners may not notice whether a stay is granted: The ordinances at issue in the NRA lawsuit were not being enforced even before it was filed. But Mr. Goldstein said that isn’t the point.
“The presence of an illegal law on the books, and the threat of its enforcement, is itself an infringement of liberty,” he said.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.