In the legal gunfight surrounding the National Rifle Association's lawsuit against the City of Pittsburgh, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Judith L.A. Friedman has fired off a salvo of her own.

Last week, the NRA appealed Judge Friedman's decision to put a stay on its case, which argues that Pittsburgh gun ordinances run afoul of state law. Judge Friedman issued that stay after a March 2 hearing in Motions Court, where a rotating judge often decides preliminary legal matters. The judge agreed with a city attorney that the lawsuit should be put in limbo because the state's Act 192 of 2014 — which allows gun organizations like the NRA to file such lawsuits — was itself being challenged in the state's Commonwealth Court.

Judge Friedman, who was a late replacement for the regularly scheduled judge, acknowledged in court that she hadn't read briefs filed in the case. NRA's attorney Jonathan S. Goldstein argued in his appeal that Judge Friedman was wrong to decide the question without "properly familiarizing herself with even the minimum elements of the matter."

In her opinion, the judge responded that while "plaintiff seems to believe that its Brief ... was so compelling it should have been studied even after the argument," Mr. Goldstein had "ample time" to present his argument before her.

Advertise with us

"A later reading of the Brief did not reveal anything" that would change her determination, Judge Friedman's opinion added.

It also addressed another procedural concern raised by the NRA: that there was no court reporter on hand to provide a written transcript. Such reporters are not routinely provided for Motions Court proceedings, the opinion said, and while Judge Friedman had a "personal preference to always have a reporter in Motions Court ... this policy does not exist."

The NRA claims Judge Friedman failed to provide a court reporter "despite a request by Plaintiff"; the judge's opinion assert that the NRA didn't make the request "until the argument was over and the stay had been granted."

Ultimately, the opinion said, "The standards for granting or denying a stay are not obscure or difficult," and letting this case proceed could "constitute a waste of judicial resources and taxpayer money" were the Commonwealth Court to decide that Act 192 is unconstitutional.

A judge in Lancaster, whose gun ordinances have also been challenged by the NRA, reached the opposite conclusion, denying an effort to stay a lawsuit there. A hearing on the matter is scheduled for later this month in Philadelphia, where a third NRA suit has been filed.