Despite a state law signed last year to avoid such circumstances, some communities are still applying parts of local ordinances that allow them to have “disruptive” tenants evicted if more than a few calls to 911 have been made from a residence — even when those calls result from domestic abuse.
The American Civil Liberties Union is involved in a current case in Verona and worked with a woman in Mount Oliver who faced a similar situation last summer. In 2013, the ACLU filed a federal lawsuit against Norristown, Pa., after the organization said officials there pushed for the eviction of a woman who was a victim of domestic violence.
Sara Rose, an attorney at the ACLU of Pennsylvania, said it’s hard to tell how often these types of ordinances — intended to prevent disruptive behavior — are being used as punishment when tenants call 911. Several municipalities in the state have such ordinances, but Ms. Rose said she’s not aware of any towns that have repealed or changed them since then-Gov. Tom Corbett signed the new law in November.
“Just having it creates a chilling effect on tenants who might be afraid to call the police,” she said.
The ACLU got involved in Verona when a tenant at a rental house contacted the organization. Ms. Rose said the property manager informed the family they needed to move out or the landlord was going to start the eviction process April 1.
The reason? Police responded to the property twice within the rental year for what they deemed “disruptive” behavior, Ms. Rose said. According to Verona’s nuisance ordinance, if two violations occur within a rental year involving the same occupants, the borough code enforcement officer may direct the owner to evict them.
Ms. Rose reviewed the police records: In November, she said, someone in the house called 911 when a family member with a mental illness threatened to harm herself. In February, that family member assaulted another and was threatening to hurt herself and then did, Ms. Rose said.
“The tenant called the police for help, so I think that this is squarely within what this new state law is supposed to protect,” Ms. Rose said.
That tenant, 36-year-old Pauline Sholes, who lives in the home with her partner, 16-year-old daughter and her daughter’s father, said just the thought of eviction was stressful on her family.
“I didn’t know if I was going to have to live in a hotel ... or be homeless,” she said.
Ultimately, the borough responded by telling the landlord not to impose penalties on the family, and the solicitor said he told the police chief not to enforce the ordinance on domestic abuse incidents, Ms. Rose said.
Verona police Chief Ron McLemore deferred comment to solicitor Craig Alexander, who could not be reached but declined comment through the chief.
Before the state law took effect, a similar situation occurred last summer in Mount Oliver.
Witold J. Walczak, legal director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania, said Kathleen Dolan, 48, received a letter June 11 from her landlord saying she would be evicted because borough police “designated that this property is considered a nuisance property based on the calls for services you made to them.”
Mr. Walczak said had the landlord not moved to evict her, the landlord would have faced a $1,000-a-day fine.
Police records show three domestic incidents and one “disorderly person” incident from May 18 to June 3. Mr. Walczak said two were calls for police to respond to her apartment because her ex-boyfriend wouldn’t leave the area. Ms. Dolan said police told her to file a protection-from-abuse order against him.
“I was scared because he said if I ever filed a PFA, he would kill me,” she said. Ms. Dolan was able to stay in her apartment and got a restraining order.
Mount Oliver solicitor J. Deron Gabriel said the incident prompted a review of the “older” ordinance “that most of us sort of inherited.”
“We took a hard look at it, and we wanted to make some modifications that were in line with what the state of the law is at this time,” he said.
“I think it’s one of those situations where they did not fully understand and appreciate the harm that this law was causing,” Mr. Walczak said. “Once they understood that, they were very cooperative in repealing the ordinance. ... We didn’t have to file a lawsuit and were able to fix the problem.”
Norristown repealed its law, settled the lawsuit and paid Lakisha Briggs and her attorneys $495,000.
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.