When it comes to making Christmas cookies, Pittsburghers like to stir a little nostalgia into the bowl with their flour, butter and sugar.
At least that’s what the top contestants in the Post-Gazette’s 2022 Holiday Cookie Challenge made clear with their entries. All came with sweet stories of how baking the frosted, filled and nut-studded treats with their grandmothers, mothers and/or children was a treasured family holiday tradition.
Christine Ballew’s winning recipe in the Cakey category was handed down from her maternal grandmother Margaret Fichter, who was featured in Pittsburgh writer Clare Ansberry's book, "The Women of Troy Hill.” The Shaler resident gently tweaked a few ingredients after her grandma passed, so that the frosted cookie now features one of the season’s favorite cold-weather flavors — maple — with chopped pecans sprinkled on top for a festive crunch.
Susan Wiebe’s top entry in the Filled category has also stood the test of time. The Swissvale baker has been making the buttery, apricot cookies since the early 1980s, after finding the recipe in a then-20-year-old cookbook. It’s a cheesy take on a Hungarian kolache, with salty, grated cheddar adding a savory flavor to the tender pastry dough.

A layered cookie you can assemble in a single pan in mere minutes won top honors for Amy Wodnicki, of Scott, in the Ooey/Gooey category. The recipe comes courtesy of her busy and “amazing” maternal grandma Laura, who back in the day taught in a one-room schoolhouse near Kane, Pa., before becoming an elementary school teacher in Punxsutawney. “She was a woman before her time,” she says.
And finally, may we tip our collective Santa hats to Marlene Makstutis, of Baldwin, who finished first in the Crispy/Crunchy category. Every child loves Rice Krispies, right? So it’s no wonder the cookie she has such fond memories of making with her mother and sister would also become her own childrens’ favorite. Quickly stirred together and dropped by rounded spoonfuls onto a baking sheet, they delight with their sweet mix of crunchy puffed rice, chocolate chips and chewy raisins.
Read More

Calling all cookies
This was the second year for the re-booted contest, with four new categories to keep things fresh. Recognizing that many of our aging neighbors might not be lucky enough to have someone to bake for them, we thought of them for the charitable component: After judging, all the cookies were individually bagged and donated to Meals on Wheels Southwestern Pennsylvania for distribution across the North Hills. (Last year’s leftover sweets were delivered to the East End Cooperative Ministry’s Community Food Services program.)
This year’s contest drew almost three dozen entries by the Nov. 27 deadline, with the Filled category the overwhelming favorite among competitors. After narrowing the list down to three finalists in each category based on the descriptions and ingredient lists — some contestants also sent pictures — a team of PG staffers divided up the recipes and baked them.
Then, we all gathered at Food editor Gretchen McKay’s house for a taste-test, with last year’s champion, Barbara Lanke, of Ross, joining us as a guest judge. Cookies were ranked on a 1-5 point scale for texture, taste and overall appeal.
Along with some serious bragging rights, Ballew won $100 as the overall Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion. The other three category winners were awarded $50 each.
It was a daunting task, sampling (and resampling) all those cookies in one fell swoop, but also what a delicious way to kick off the holiday season. We hope you’ll be inspired to make and taste them, too, and share them with everyone you love.
Happy baking!
WINNER: Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion

Maple Pecan Cookies
PG tested
Recipes that get handed down over the generations are often regarded as sacred. And for a long while, Christine Ballew made these soft and cakey cookies exactly like her maternal grandmother Margaret Fichter did so many decades ago on Troy Hill — with root beer. After she passed in 2001, the Shaler resident ended up tweaking the ingredient list for a niece who doesn’t care for the sweet soft drink by using maple syrup instead. It proved to be a hit, especially with her daughter Mackenzie, who loves the all-natural sweetener. Maple, Ballew adds, “is a better flavor for Christmas.”
For cookies
1 cup sugar
1 cup brown sugar
1 cup butter, softened
½ cup buttermilk, or ½ cup milk mixed with 1½ teaspoons lemon juice and allowed to sit for 5 minutes
2 eggs
1 tablespoon maple extract
4 cups flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
¼ teaspoon salt
1½ cups finely chopped pecans, for optional topping
For frosting
6 cups powdered sugar
6 tablespoons half and half
4 tablespoons butter (softened)
1 tablespoon maple extract
3 tablespoons maple syrup
Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Line cookie sheet with parchment paper.
In large bowl, combine sugar, brown sugar, butter, buttermilk, eggs and maple extract. Beat at medium speed until well blended.
Add the flour, baking soda and salt and then beat at low speed until dough forms.
Measure 1 tablespoon of dough and form dough into ball. Place dough balls 2 inches apart on prepared cookie sheet. Bake 8 to 9 minutes until set. Remove from oven and cool
Prepare frosting: Place powdered sugar, half and half, butter, maple extract and maple syrup in a large bowl. Beat ingredients at low speed until smooth. Scrape down bowl and beat at medium speed for another 30 seconds. (Depending on size of mixer, you may want to make half a batch of frosting at a time). Frost the top of the cookie, and press finely chopped pecans around the edges of the icing, if using. (Easiest method is to place pecans in deep saucer or pie plate, hold iced cookie over the dish, use hand to press pecans around the edges, excess pecans will fall into the pile of pecans for the next cookie.)
Makes 6 dozen.
— Christine Ballew, Shaler
Tester’s note: Maple syrup is a year-round staple but it often becomes a star during the holidays — and not just on pancakes or waffles. These cookies are so easy to make and absolutely scrumptious. I used Pennsylvania syrup from Hurry Hill Maple Farm in Edinboro, but any quality syrup (read: the real stuff) will work its magic. I pressed crushed nuts on top of the cookies instead of around the edges.
WINNER: Crispy/Crunchy

Crunchy Jumbles
PG tested
Marlene Makstutis’ fondest tradition as a child was making cookies at Christmas with her mother and sister. “My mom was a working mom so this is probably the only time of the year we bake,” the Baldwin baker writes. Wanting to continue that tradition with her own children, she now bakes “tons” of cookies at Christmas, and each of her sons get to pick two varieties. “This cookie is their favorite.”
1¼ cups flour
½ teaspoon baking soda
½ teaspoon salt
½ cup butter, softened
1 cup sugar
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 cups Rice Krispies cereal
1 6-ounce package semisweet chocolate morsels
1 cup raisins
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
In large bowl, sift together flour, baking soda and salt. Set aside.
Measure butter and sugar into large mixing bowl; beat until well blended and smooth. Add egg and vanilla; beat well to combine.
Add sifted dry ingredients to wet ingredients, and mix until combined. Stir in Rice Krispies, semisweet morsels and raisins.
Drop by tablespoon onto a lightly greased baking sheet.
Bake cookies for 12 minutes, or until lightly browned. Remove immediately from baking sheet and cool on wire rack.
Makes 3½ dozen cookies.
— Marlene Makstutis, Baldwin
Tester’s note: I wasn’t sure chewy raisins would pair so well with the crunch of Rice Krispies. I was wrong. The dried fruit added just the right touch of sweetness to this crispy drop cookie, which is so easy to make, even the youngest cooks can lend a hand.
WINNER: Filled

Apricot Fold-overs
PG tested
Susan Wiebe, of Swissvale, found the original of this recipe back in the 1980s, in the 1966 edition of Better Homes and Gardens’ “Cookies and Candies” cookbook. She’s never made them exactly as written — she uses butter and sharp cheddar instead of margarine and American cheese — but they were a hit with her young family and have remained a favorite. “They are pretty to look at, not too sweet, with a pleasing combination of cheesy pastry and tart apricot filling,” she says, adding, “It doesn’t feel like Christmas without them on the cookie plate.”
For dough
½ cup butter
4 ounces grated sharp cheddar cheese (1 cup)
1⅓ cups all-purpose flour
2 tablespoons water
For apricot filling
1 cup dried apricots, diced
1 cup sugar
¼ to ½ teaspoon almond extract (optional)
Prepare dough: In medium bowl, cream butter and cheese until light. Blend flour into creamed mixture. Add water and mix well. Chill dough in refrigerator for 4 hours or overnight. (Chilling the dough will make it much easier to handle.)
Make filling: Place apricots in a small saucepan and add enough water just to cover. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, cover and then cook until apricots are quite soft, 20-30 minutes. Stir sugar into hot fruit, then cook until mixture boils and becomes smooth. Remove from heat and stir in almond extract, then cool to room temperature. (I sometimes mash the filling with a potato masher at this stage if it seems too chunky.) Preparing the filling can be done a day or two ahead of time.
Assemble cookies: Divide chilled dough in half. Roll each half to a 10-inch square, then cut into 2½-inch squares. (I use a fluted rotary pastry cutter to get serrated edges, and it helps to use a ruler to get consistently sized cookies.)
Place 1 teaspoon of apricot filling in the center of each square. Bring opposite corners of the cookies together and press firmly to seal. Bake on parchment-covered cooking sheet or a silicon baking mat in a preheated 375 degree oven for 8-10 minutes.
Makes about 2½ dozen cookies.
— Susan Wiebe, Swissvale
Tester’s note: These cookies take some time to prepare, since you have to both chill the dough for at least 4 hours and cook the apricots into a soft and spreadable jam. That said, the dough is super-easy to work with and the results are stellar. Shredded cheddar cheese adds a salty, savory and unexpected flavor that pairs perfectly with the fruit filling. Some of my cookies came apart during baking, so be sure to firmly press the seams together!
WINNER: Ooey/Gooey

Seven Layer Cookies
PG tested
Amy Wodnicki got this recipe from her busy maternal grandma Laura Pflugfelder, who started her teaching career in a one-room schoolhouse outside of Kane, Pa. Because she had her hands full at school — she was responsible for stoking the fire, cleaning outhouses and teaching students in grades 1-12 — “she baked these cookies which required little time but tasted rich and complicated!”
Amazingly easy, they’re exactly as billed — seven ingredients form seven layers. Which could explain why it’s one of 12 holiday cookies the Scott resident makes every year. “It’s funny,” she says. “[Grandma] always said she wasn’t a great cook, but my mother and I always make her recipes.”
1 stick butter, melted
1 cup graham cracker crumbs
1 cup shredded coconut
1 6-ounce package of chocolate chips
1 6-ounce package butterscotch chips
1 14-ounce can Eagle Brand sweetened condensed milk
1 cup chopped nuts
Pour melted butter into the bottom of a 9-by-13-inch baking pan.
Layer each ingredient in the order given on top of butter, ending with the nuts on top.
Bake at 350 degrees for 20 minutes. Cut into squares when cool.
Makes about 2 dozen cookies.
— Amy Wodnicki, Scott
Tester’s note: You’ll never find an easier cookie recipe! Seriously! Sweetened with condensed milk, this combination of chocolate, butterscotch and coconut just works, making these gooey bars a perfect addition to any holiday table. I used chopped pecans.
FINALISTS: Crispy-Crunchy

Nana Brown’s Shortbread
PG tested
“This recipe was brought from Dundee, Scotland, by my husband’s nana and given to me by his mother, Lori,” writes Darlene Turner, of Penn Hills. “These are rich and delightful.”
4 cups, minus 2 tablespoons, all-purpose flour
2 tablespoons rice flour
1 cup sugar, plus more for sprinkling
¾ cup butter
Mix flour, rice flour, sugar and butter with fork, then knead until smooth.
Divide dough into 3 pieces. With your fingers, pat each piece flat until it’s about ⅜-inch thick.
Cut into shapes with cookie cutter(s), then sprinkle with sugar. Put on parchment covered cookie sheet.
Bake cookies at 350 degrees until golden on the edges, about 20 minutes.
Makes 3½ dozen.
— Darlene Turner, Penn Hills
Tester’s note: Note the rice flour! I'd forgotten it until baking day, but found a 16-ounce bag for a (very) reasonable $2.59 at Many More Asian Market in the Strip. It's readily available at most grocery stores. Our submitter said that she likes to use a diamond-shaped cookie cutter, but I went with what I had in my kitchen: the very practical, regular-sized mason jar. Whatever the shape, this recipe does the classic, ultra-buttery cookie well.

Chip & Dip Cookies
PG tested
Josephine Murray, of Morningside, found this recipe in a magazine years ago. “Always a great alternative to putting nuts in delicious cookies,” she writes.
1 cup butter, softened
½ cup sugar
1 egg yolk
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1¾ cup of flour
¾ cup coarsely crushed potato chips
¾ cup coarsely crushed pretzels
1 cup chocolate chips
1 cup white baking chips
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
In large bowl, combine butter and sugar with mixer until light and fluffy. Add egg yolk and vanilla.
Gradually add flour and mix well.
Stir in crushed chips and pretzels, then shape level tablespoons of dough into 3-inch logs.
Place on ungreased baking sheet 1½ inches apart. Bake 14 to 18 minutes, or until edges are lightly browned. Cool completely on baking sheet.
Place chocolate chips in bowl, then microwave for 30 seconds and stir. Repeat until chocolate is melted. Dip one end of cookie into chocolate and place on waxed paper. Refrigerate until firm, about 10 minutes.
Place white chocolate chips in bowl, then microwave for 30 seconds and stir. Repeat until chocolate is melted. Dip other end in white chocolate. Refrigerate until firm.
Makes 2 dozen.
— Josephine Murray, Morningside
Tester’s note: Adding a little bit of salt is the secret to a great cookie. So why not add that salt in the form of two of the best snack foods, potato chips and pretzels, to give it a touch of crunch, too? These cookies are relatively easy to make, though the process for dipping each end in chocolate does add a little bit of time at the end.
FINALISTS: Filled

Cucidati Italian Orange Cookies
PG tested
“My cousin Rosann Breen and I inherited the tradition of these Sicilian filled cookies from our grandmothers who arrived in Pittsburgh in the early 1900s,” writes Constance Rohm, of Franklin Park. “No Christmas cookie display would be complete without this festive cookie.”
For dough
1 cup shortening (½ should be butter-flavored Crisco)
1 cup sugar
7 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
Grated orange peel
5 teaspoons baking powder
5 to 6½ cups all-purpose flour
For filling
1 14-ounce package dried Kalamata crown figs
1 10-ounce package pitted dates
Orange peel from 2 oranges
1 10-ounce package walnuts
Juice of 1 orange
¼ cup Marsala wine
For glaze
1 cup powdered sugar
2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
Colored sprinkles
In a large bowl, using an electric mixer, cream shortening and sugar. Mix in eggs, vanilla and orange peel until blended.
In a separate bowl, mix 5 cups of flour with the baking powder and slowly add to the wet mixture. If the mixture is sticky, add more flour until it is no longer sticky. Divide the dough in half, then wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 3 hours.
Make filling: In a food processor or blender, grind together the figs, dates, orange peel and walnuts. Add orange juice and Marsala wine, and continue blending until the mixture is almost (but not) gooey. Set aside.
Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside.
Remove dough from the refrigerator and allow it to rest for 10-15 minutes. Place a piece of waxed or parchment paper on a clean work surface, and dust with flour.
Take a piece of the orange dough and make a 1-inch diameter cigar approximately 15 inches long. Using a rolling pin or your fingers, flatter out the cigar so that you can put the filling in the center.
Moisten the edge of the dough with water. Spread the filling lengthwise down the middle of each strip of dough, approximately 1-inch wide. Pull up the sides to remake the cigar, and roll gently. Pinch together the seam.
Cut each cigar on the diagonal into 1½-inch pieces. Place on baking sheet. Repeat with remaining dough and filling.
Bake for 12 to 15 minutes or until the tops are golden brown. Let cook on baking sheet for 10 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack to cool.
Make glaze by whisking together powdered sugar and lemon juice in a small bowl until it forms a thick but pourable glaze. Drizzle glaze onto the top of each cookie, then top with colored sprinkles.
Makes 3-4 dozen.
— Constance Rohm, Franklin Park
Tester’s note: I’m going to be honest — I was pretty sure I wasn’t going to like what appeared at first glance to be a very old-fashioned cookie. Boy, was I wrong. The blend of dried figs, dates, orange peel and Marsala wine tucked into these traditional Sicilian cookies made with shortbread crust simply tastes like Christmas. I had to watch a YouTube video to figure out how to fill and roll the “cigars,” but once I had one under my belt, it was smooth sailing. The citrus glaze adds a sweet finish. Think Fig Newtons, only dressed up for the holidays.

Insanely Delicious Turtle Cookies
PG tested
To Hannah Lynn Kostyak, of Brentwood, these party cookies offer the “perfect mix of crunch from the pecans, softness from the dough, and ooey gooey inside from the melted caramel.”
For cookies
1 cup all-purpose flour
⅓ cup cocoa powder
¼ teaspoon salt
8 tablespoons (1 stick) butter, softened
⅔ cup granulated sugar
1 large egg, separated
1 additional egg white
2 tablespoons milk
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1¼ cups pecans, finely chopped
For caramel filling
14 soft caramel candies
3 tablespoons heavy cream
For chocolate drizzle (optional)
2 ounces semisweet chocolate
1 teaspoons shortening
Prepare cookie batter: Combine flour, cocoa and salt; set aside. With a stand mixer or electric mixer on medium-high speed, beat butter and sugar until light and fluffy, about 2 minutes. Add egg yolk, milk and vanilla; mix until incorporated.
Reduce speed to low and add flour mixture until just combined.
Wrap dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate until firm, 1 hour.
When ready to bake, whisk the 2 egg whites in a bowl until frothy. Place chopped pecans in another bowl.
Roll chilled dough into 1-inch balls (a cookie scoop helps with this), dip each dough ball in egg whites, and then roll in pecans. Place balls about 2 inches apart on a baking sheet. Using a ½ teaspoon measuring spoon, make an indentation in the center of each dough ball.
Bake at 350 degrees until set, about 12 minutes.
Prepare the caramel filling: Microwave caramels and cream together in a small bowl, stirring occasionally, until smooth, about 1 to 2 minutes.
Once cookies are removed from the oven, gently re-press the indentations. Fill each indentation with about ½ teaspoon of the caramel mixture. Cool on the pan for 10 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.
Prepare the chocolate drizzle (optional): Place chocolate and shortening in a small zip-top plastic bag. Set bag in a bowl of warm water to soften. Gently knead the chocolate with your fingers until melted and smooth, placing back in the warm water for a minute or two as needed.
Snip a very small hole in the corner of the plastic bag. Drizzle chocolate over the cooled Turtle Cookies.
Makes 2 dozen.
— Hannah Lynn Kostyak, Brentwood
Tester’s note: Using a cookie dough scoop will make portioning these chocolatey, caramel-filled cookies so much easier, but it’s not essential. Overall, they’re a fairly easy cookie to make, with a soft and pliable dough that lends itself to rolling; the hardest part of the process was unwrapping the plastic from the caramels — and trying not to sample the finished product ahead of the other judges.
FINALISTS: Ooey-Gooey

Chocolate Snowballs
PG tested
Sandy Ann Niespodzianski says she makes these powdered sugar-dusted chocolate treats for most family events, including weddings. “Everyone likes this cookie and tries to guess the secret ingredient,” the Bethel Park resident writes. Spoiler alert: It’s cinnamon.
½ cup shortening (Crisco – solid)
4 squares (4 ounces) unsweetened chocolate
2 cups sugar
4 eggs
2 cups sifted flour
2 teaspoons baking powder
¼ to ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon
¼ teaspoon salt
Powdered sugar, for rolling
Place shortening and chocolate in medium saucepan. Stir over low heat just until melted. Remove from heat and stir in sugar. Beat in eggs one at a time.
Sift flour with baking powder, cinnamon and salt. Mix dry and wet ingredients together well. Chill several hours or overnight.
Shape dough into 1-inch balls, then roll in powdered sugar. Place on lightly greased or parchment paper-covered baking sheet.
Bake cookies in 350-degree oven for 15 to 18 minutes. Remove immediately to wire rack to cool.
Makes 3 dozen.
— Sandy Ann Niespodzianski, Bethel Park
Tester’s note: Any cookie is a welcomed sight around the holidays, but some just scream "Celebrate!" more than others. Chocolate snowballs — or "chocolate crinkles," as some call them — are exactly that. Rolled in powdered sugar before baking, the balls expand into sugar-coated mounds with fudgy ravines, giving these cookies an undeniably Christmastime and wintertime look with minimal effort.

Cherry Pineapple Squares
PG tested
For more years than she’d like to admit, Shirley Ricci, of Harmony, has been baking and gifting cookie trays to family and friends. “It’s a true expression of the real meaning of Christmas to me,” she writes. She’s gotten many requests for this recipe over the years, and even has a friend “who steals them when no one is looking and hides them!”
For first layer
2 cups sifted flour
1 cup brown sugar
½ teaspoon salt
1 cup butter
For second layer
½ cup sugar
2 tablespoons cornstarch
1 small can (8¾ ounces) crushed pineapple
2 beaten egg yolks
1 cup chopped maraschino cherries
For top layer
¾ cup roughly chopped sliced almonds
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Prepare first layer: In a small bowl mix together flour, sugar and salt. Cut in butter until crumbly. Set aside 1 cup crumb mixture for top; press remaining crumb mixture in a lightly greased 9-by-13-inch pan. Bake cookies in preheated oven for 15 mins. Cool while preparing next layer.
Prepare second layer: Place sugar, cornstarch, pineapple and yolks in a small saucepan and cook until thick, stirring constantly. Add cherries and stir to combine. Spread over cooled crust.
Sprinkle reserved crumb mixture and sliced almonds on top, pressing down lightly. Bake at 350 degrees for an additional 30 minutes.
Makes 3 to 4 dozen, depending on size.
— Shirley Ricci, Harmony
Tester’s note: The crushed pineapple in this gooey bar cookie pairs perfectly with the almond and maraschino cherry. Be sure to keep an eye on the pan when you’re making the fruity second layer — it cooks quickly and you don’t want to burn it.
FINALISTS: Cakey

Galettes
PG tested
Galettes
“This recipe originated in Belgium or France, but women of many different European backgrounds in my little town of Cecil, Washington County, made these special cookies for Christmas, weddings and other special events,” writes Cheryl McLaughlin. “My personal history is that my mom always mixed the dough and it was my job to handle the iron to create the cookies on the stove top.”
2 pounds butter or margarine
2 pounds brown sugar (1 pound light brown and 1 pound dark brown)
12 egg yolks
1 cup canned evaporated milk
1 teaspoon vanilla
12 cups flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
Blend butter and sugar in large bowl with electric mixer. Beat in egg yolks and canned milk and vanilla.
Add flour and baking powder and mix into a dough with hands.
Roll dough into balls using about a tablespoon to measure. Place the balls into the iron (or a waffle iron if you don't have the "real thing"). Close the iron and remove the cookies after about 1 minute or until golden brown on the outside.
These cookies "keep" for a long time — they are soft (similar to chocolate chip cookies), but as they harden over time, they can be dunked in coffee as you would a biscotti. Joyeux Noël!
Makes many dozen cookies.
— Cheryl McLaughlin, Cecil
Tester’s note: These waffle-like cookies will remind you of stroopwafels. I wondered if my KitchenAid would be up to the task of mixing this butter- and sugar-heavy batter, especially since it calls for 12 cups (!) of flour. Surprisingly, it was, though I had to do the final mixing with my hands to make sure all the ingredients were incorporated. If like me you use one of those $10 mini waffle makers from Target, beware: This recipe makes A LOT of cookies, and it’s going to take A LOT of time to go through all the batter. You might want to put on a Hallmark Christmas movie and make a night of it.

Grandma Chambers’ Orange Cookies
PG tested
David Chambers, of Elizabeth, grew up eating these cookies. The recipe was passed from his paternal grandmother, Sarah Chambers, to his mom, Catherine Chambers. “Since mom has passed, I have made these every year,” he writes. “Everyone loves them!”
The buttermilk, he adds, “makes all the difference.”
For cookies
2 oranges, zested and juiced, divided
4 cups flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
2 teaspoons baking powder
2 sticks butter, softened
2 eggs
2 cups sugar
1 cup buttermilk, divided
For icing
20 ounces powdered sugar
1 orange, juiced
1 teaspoon melted butter
Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
Divide juice and zest from 2 oranges into two bowls (half for cookies and half for icing).
Mix flour, baking powder and baking soda in large bowl.
In bowl of stand mixer, cream butter, eggs, half of the orange rind and sugar. Add ⅓ of the dry ingredients to the mixing bowl. With mixer running, add half of the buttermilk, then half of the orange juice
With mixer running, add another ⅓ of the dry ingredients to bowl, along with remaining half of orange juice and buttermilk.
Add final ⅓ of the dry ingredients and mix until combined.
Drop by spoonful onto baking sheet, and bake for 9 to 10 minutes.
While cookies are cooling, make icing: In large bowl, combine powdered sugar, orange juice, remaining half of orange zest and melted butter until smooth and creamy.
Ice cooled cookies, and serve.
Makes 5 dozen.
— David Chambers, Elizabeth
Tester’s note: There is something about the elegant simplicity of these orange-flavored cookies that makes them so appealing. That, and the taste of citrus, which brings a lovely touch of sunshine. Buttermilk really does make the difference — it adds a subtle but pleasant tang and makes for a softer texture. Also, I love the fact all of the other ingredients are basic kitchen staples.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pittsburghpgfood.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.