Personal taste often determines which cookie one grabs from the holiday dessert table. Some love thin and crispy while others go crazy over anything dusted with powdered sugar or heavily spiced with traditional Christmas flavors like cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger.
A great backstory can also help differentiate between a ho-hum treat worth tracking down the baker for the recipe from one that’s just not worth the extra calories.
All of the finalists in the Post-Gazette’s 2023 Holiday Cookie Challenge did exactly that — made our mouths water while also making our hearts sing by pairing scrumptious-sounding recipes with heart-warming stories about how the cookies came into their orbit.
While family tradition and childhood memories inspired many of our entrants, especially in the popular Family Favorite category, some of the winning recipes from our 12 finalists claimed more modern roots.
Pine resident Sandy Bacchus has only been baking her delicate maple-iced maple cookies — the winner in our Iced category — for about three years. Yet the ritual of making them during the holidays never fails to bring to mind her mother, Carol, who passed two years ago.
“She loved maple anything,” she says.
Read More
The top entry in the Chocolate category, a dense and chewy chocolate chip cookie from Devin O’Leary of Whitehall, is based on a recipe from food writer J. Kenji López-Alt, whose science-based “The Food Lab” won a 2016 James Beard Foundation Award. O’Leary added his own touch with brown butter.
Joyce Lynn Doyle’s amaretti cookie recipe was handed down from her grandmother on her father’s side. Made with only five ingredients, including almond extract, the traditional Italian cookie was a winner for the Penn Hills resident in our Family Favorite category.
And cheers to Jane Wright of McCandless, who entered a homemade version of the caramel-filled bakery cookie she snuck from a wedding cookie table a decade ago. The winner in our Bar category, the crispy shortbread filled with caramel and topped with Maldon sea salt flakes is as easy to make as it is sweetly satisfying.

Call for entries
This year’s contest featured four new categories, and drew a whopping 61 entries — nearly twice that of last year. Just as exciting was our first-ever community partner: Cafe Momentum Pittsburgh, a nationally recognized nonprofit restaurant and professional training facility that gives teens who’ve been involved with the justice system a second chance with hands-on restaurant experience.
Adding to the “wow” factor was our first celebrity judge, WQED producer and Bethel Park native Rick Sebak, and some seriously stepped-up prizes. In addition to a check and apron from the Post-Gazette, the winner in each category received a gift certificate to the cafe from executive director Gene Walker, who was also a judge along with teenage intern Malakai.

The judging also moved from food editor Gretchen McKay’s house last year to a blind taste-test in Cafe Momentum’s stylish dining room on Dec. 4.
What didn’t change was the challenge’s charitable focus. Understanding that many Pittsburghers take baking and sharing cookies during the holidays for granted, we made sure any leftovers would go to Cafe Momentum’s favorite charitable organizations. And that they did after the final numbers were tallied at around 4 p.m., with hundreds of cookies boxed up for distribution to The Pittsburgh Project, Catholic Youth Association’s Stephen Foster Community Center and Citipark’s West Penn Recreation Center and Healthy Active Living Senior Centers in Hazelwood and Morningside.
Cookies, made by PG staffers, were ranked on a 1-5 point scale for texture, taste and overall appeal.
As the overall Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion, Bacchus won $150 from the PG and a $150 gift certificate to Café Momentum. The other three category winners were awarded $100 plus a $100 Café Momentum gift certificate.
My kitchen, at least, was covered in flour and sugar after a weekend of intense baking that included an ill-timed power outage, and it also was hard work sampling and judging all those cookies in front of the people who’ve made them time and again. But we’re delighted with the sweet results, and are hoping at least a few of them will find their way into your recipe box or folder.
And if you’ve already got your favorites lined up? We might do a second story early next year on some of the cookies that didn’t make the final cut but sound great and have interesting stories.
Happy Holiday baking!

HOLIDAY COOKIE CHALLENGE CHAMPION
Maple Iced Maple Cookies

PG tested
Cookie contests can be splashy, so Sandy Bacchus wasn’t sure this soft and fluffy maple cookie she makes in her mother’s honor at Thanksgiving was worth entering.
“It’s such a simple recipe, I thought it might not be special to other people,” she says.
That said, the first time the Pine baker made them, “people went on and on.” Fans included her mother, Carol, who loved all things maple and whose death two years ago still hurts. “When I make them, I think of her and that makes me feel good,” Bacchus says. The special touch, she adds, “is the love you throw in at the end.”
For cookies
1 cup unsalted butter, softened
2 cup granulated sugar
3 eggs
1 cup buttermilk
½ teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 teaspoons maple extract
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon baking powder
4½ cups all purpose flour, divided
For icing
½ cup unsalted butter
1 cup brown sugar
¼ cup milk
2 tablespoons maple syrup (add more for more maple flavor)
Pinch of salt
2 cups powdered sugar
Milk, if needed
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
In a large mixing bowl with hand mixer, or in the bowl of a stand mixer, cream together butter and sugar until light and fluffy.
Add eggs, one at a time, mixing after each addition.
With the mixer on low, slowly pour in buttermilk and mix until combined.
Add salt, vanilla extract, maple extract, baking soda and baking powder and mix well.
Add half of the flour, mixing until combined, then add remaining flour and mix together.
Drop dough by 2 tablespoon scoops onto a parchment-lined baking sheet about 2 inches apart. Bake for 6-8 minutes. Cookies will be pale in color — do not over bake!
Allow cookies to cool a few minutes before transferring to a cooling rack to cool completely.
Prepare icing: In a saucepan over medium heat, melt butter and brown sugar. Bring to a boil for 2 minutes, whisking constantly.
Add milk, maple syrup, and salt and boil again for 1 minute while whisking.
Turn off heat and cool for 15 minutes, then add powdered sugar, whisking until it reaches a glue-like consistency. If too thick, add milk, 1 tablespoon at a time, until you get desired consistency.
Quickly dip cookies into icing and swirl to remove excess. The icing will thicken as it cools, just add more milk as needed to spread it easily over each cookie.
Allow icing to set up before storing in a covered container.
Makes 4 dozen cookies
— Sandy Bacchus, Pine Township
Tester’s note: The scary part of this very easy and super-light cookie is believing they’re actually done after just 8 minutes of baking; I had to obsessively check the bottoms to be sure. But wow, they’re exactly what you think of when you think of a holiday cookie! I iced the cookies with a knife instead of dipping them because it was faster and less messy.
WINNER: BAR
Salted Caramel Shortbread Bars

PG tested
Jane Wright knew she had to recreate this bar cookie she tasted 10 years ago at her friend’s son’s wedding. “I was tasked with picking up some of the cookies that were being purchased to fill out the cookie table of homemade cookies,” she says, “and snuck a caramel-filled cookie since it looked so good.” It took her a while to create a crust with the flavor of shortbread — the ones she found online were too thin or eggy — but “it’s always a hit.”
For crust
4 sticks salted butter, softened
1 cup sugar
1½ cup powdered sugar
2 tablespoons vanilla extract
4 cups all-purpose flour
½ teaspoon salt
For filling
1 11-ounce bag Kraft caramel bits (or unwrapped caramels)
¼ cup heavy cream
½ teaspoon salt
1½ teaspoons flaky sea salt (I use Maldon)
Line a 9- by- 13-inch metal baking pan with parchment paper (or grease the pan with butter) and preheat to 325 degrees.
Using a mixer, combine butter and sugars, then add vanilla and flour and mix until combined.
Press ⅓ of the dough evenly into the pan to form a bottom crust. Place the remainder in the refrigerator to chill. Bake the crust for 20 minutes until the edges are just starting to turn light brown.
While the crust is baking, place the caramel bits and heavy cream in a microwave safe bowl. Microwave on low power in 1 minute increments, stirring after each minute, until melted and smooth.
Pour caramel over warm crust, sprinkle with 1½ teaspoons flaky sea salt. Crumble the remaining crust over the top of the salted caramel layer.
Return to the oven for 20 minutes or so. It is better to under-bake these. Don’t wait until they start turning golden brown or the edges will get too hard. Remove from the oven and cool pan on a wire rack.
After cooling, lift from the pan with the parchment and cut into small squares. Trim off the edges before cutting into squares if the edges are overbaked.
Makes 24 squares.
— Jane Wright, McCandless
Tester’s note: This outstanding bar cookie has a wonderful crumble that’s not only delicious but incredibly easy to make. It’s unwrapping all the Kraft caramels that will drive you crazy if you don’t have a helper! The Maldon salt flakes sprinkled on top are the yin to the yang of the super-sweet caramel filling.
WINNER: FAMILY FAVORITE
Amaretti

PG tested
Joyce Lynne Doyle struggled with making this chewy cookie handed down from her paternal grandmother for years. It was only after finally sitting down with her mom, who made them for countless weddings, communions and Christmas, that she learned she wasn’t beating the eggs stiff enough. Though her mother is gone now, “I am glad to have her cookie recipes to be able to continue to bake the traditional Italian cookies she lovingly made,” the Penn Hills resident noted.
6 egg whites (medium or large eggs)
1½ pounds sugar
3 tablespoons almond extract
1½ pounds almonds (whole with skin, ground fine)
12 tablespoons flour
1 pound pignoli nuts, optional
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Beat egg whites until they are very stiff (should be able to turn the bowl over without them falling out). Gradually beat sugar into egg whites (¼ cup at a time). Add almond extract, ground almonds and flour. Dough should not be sticky.
Roll into balls approximately the size of a walnut. Press ball into pignoli nuts (optional) and place on parchment-lined cookie sheet.
Bake for 16-18 minutes. Slide parchment paper with baked cookies onto a wet towel. After about 5 minutes, cookies should easily come off the parchment.
Place on cooling racks until cool.
Makes about 7 dozen.
— Joyce Lynne Doyle, Penn Hills
Tester’s note: These were so easy to make. I'd recommend using a stand mixer to whip the egg whites (unless, of course, heavy whisking is your thing). Other than that, there isn't much to it, just gently folding the handful of ingredients. This recipe does make a heap of cookies and rolling them into little balls prior to baking is what takes the longest. Did not include the optional pine nuts, though I bet the cookies would be even better if they were included.
WINNER: CHOCOLATE
Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookies

PG tested
Devin O’Leary considers this recipe “my perfect chocolate chip cookie.” Adding milk powder to the brown butter creates a deeper nutty flavor, and he also makes his own vanilla extracts. “It is chewy, dense and packed full of flavor,” the Whitehall baker writes.
8 ounces unsalted butter (2 sticks)
2 tablespoons of low-fat milk powder
1 standard ice cube (about 2 tablespoons)
11 ounces all-purpose flour
¾ teaspoon baking soda
2 teaspoons Diamond Crystal kosher salt or 1 teaspoon table salt
5 ounces granulated sugar (about ¾ cup; can do half vanilla sugar)
2 large eggs
2 teaspoons whiskey vanilla extract (regular vanilla extract is fine, too)
5 ounces dark brown sugar (about ½ tightly packed cup plus 2 tablespoons)
8 ounces semisweet chocolate, roughly chopped with a knife into ½- to ¼-inch chunks
Coarse sea salt, for garnish
Melt butter in a medium saucepan over medium-high heat. Cook, gently swirling pan constantly, until milk solids begin to form.
Add in the milk powder and continue to heat until milk solids start to turn golden brown and butter smells nutty, about 5 minutes. Remove from heat and continue swirling the pan until the butter is a rich brown, about 15 seconds longer.
Transfer to a medium bowl, whisk in ice cube, transfer to refrigerator, and allow to cool completely, about 20 minutes, whisking occasionally. (Alternatively, whisk over an ice bath to hasten the process.)
Whisk together flour, baking soda and salt in a large bowl and set aside.
Place granulated sugar, eggs, and whiskey vanilla extract in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. Whisk on medium-high speed until mixture is pale brownish-yellow and falls off the whisk in thick ribbons when lifted, about 5 minutes.
When brown butter mixture has cooled (it should be just starting to turn opaque again and firm around the edges, but still mostly liquid), add brown sugar and cooled brown butter to egg mixture in stand mixer. Mix on medium speed to combine, about 15 seconds.
Fit paddle attachment onto mixer. Add flour mixture and mix on low speed until just barely combined, with some dry flour still remaining, about 15 seconds. Add chocolate and mix on low speed until dough comes together, about 15 seconds longer. Transfer to an airtight container and refrigerate dough at least overnight and up to 3 days.
When ready to bake, adjust oven racks to upper- and lower-middle positions and preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Using a 1-ounce ice cream scoop or a spoon, place scoops of cookie dough onto a nonstick or parchment-lined baking sheet. Each ball should measure approximately 3 tablespoons in volume, and you should be able to fit 6-8 balls on each sheet.
Transfer to oven and bake until golden brown around edges but still soft, about 12-13 minutes, rotating pans back to front and top to bottom halfway through baking.
Remove baking sheets from oven. While cookies are still hot, sprinkle lightly with coarser salt and gently press salt down to embed. Let cool for 2 minutes, then transfer cookies to a wire rack to cool completely.
Makes 2 dozen.
— Devin O’Leary, Whitehall
Tester’s note: This is more of a passion project than a quick mix, as there are a lot of little steps to follow, as well as a recommended overnight resting period prior to baking. Nevertheless, it's a pretty fun recipe to make (though perhaps not best for a beginning baker). Even though it's complex, the recipe is easy to follow. The brown butter with added milk powder adds a nice depth of flavor and the addition of crunchy salt in the final step sends the flavor of a classic chocolate chip/chunk into a higher dimension.
FINALISTS: BAR
Walnut Slices

PG tested
Made for holidays and special occasions, these rich and sweet “old school” cookies from Carol Colaizzi’s school-teacher mom are a “labor of love.” She always cut them on the diagonal to make the cookies diamond-shaped for that little extra “fancy touch,” the New Castle resident remembers. What makes them even more special is the hand-written note at the bottom of the typewritten recipe that reads: “Before marriage/before Bessie married.”
For crust
1 egg
1½ cups flour
½ cup and 1 tablespoon butter, melted
For second layer
2 eggs
1 cup light brown sugar
½ teaspoon baking powder sifted with 1 tablespoon flour
1 cup chopped nuts
½ teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon vanilla
½ cup shredded coconut
For icing
4 tablespoons butter
2 cups confectioners sugar
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla
Enough canned, evaporated milk for spreading consistency
Chopped nuts, optional
Prepare first layer. In bowl, mix together egg, flour and melted butter. Pat into 8-by-12-inch pan. Bake for 5 minutes at 350 degrees.
While crust is baking, prepare second layer. In bowl, combine eggs, brown sugar, baking powder, nuts, salt, vanilla and shredded coconut. Mix well, then pour over crust. Bake until it feels spongy when you touch the top, about 25 minutes.
While bars are cooling, prepare icing by creaming together butter and sugar, then adding egg (if using), vanilla and enough evaporated milk for spreading consistency. Ice cookies then sprinkle with chopped nuts if you desire.
Makes 24 bars.
— Carol Colaizzi, New Castle
Tester’s note: The fact that the recipe had three layers made it a little tricky, but none of the individual layers was difficult. You can tell that if you made this regularly, you'd have it down pretty quickly. We first made the crust with a wheat flour and it didn't come out quite right, so we switched to an unbleached white flour — working the dough a little with our hands to warm it up and get it to come together properly. There's lots of butter in the different layers and we generally softened it up with a quick trip to the microwave. The icing recipe called for a raw egg. After consulting with the food editor and the finalist, we played it safe by leaving that out. The icing seemed to work OK anyway. Personal taste is key but this baker might have snuck in a few more walnuts because she really likes walnuts and it fills out the cookie.
Bourbon Bars

PG tested
Amy Formica lives on a horse farm in Butler, so this recipe started out as a pie she would make for the Kentucky Derby as well as the Preakness and Belmont Stakes. “We loved it so much that we added it to our holiday lineup as well,” she writes. In an attempt to make it gluten-free, they removed the crust and make it into bars with sweet success.
½ cup oat flour
½ cup granulated sugar
½ cup brown sugar
2 eggs
½ cup melted butter or margarine
3 tablespoons bourbon
1 teaspoon vanilla paste
1 cup chopped walnuts
1¼ cups semi-sweet chocolate chips
½ teaspoon kosher salt
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Spray a 9-by-9-inch baking pan with cooking spray and line with parchment.
In two separate bowls, mix dry ingredients together, and mix wet ingredients together. (Note: The butter needs to be cooled before incorporating.) Then combine the two.
Pour batter into the prepared pan.
Bake at 350 degrees for 30-35 minutes. When cool, cut into squares.
Makes 2-3 dozen cookies, depending on how small you cut them.
— Amy Formica, Butler
Tester’s note: Save money on the oat flour (which wasn’t available at my Trader Joe’s and Shop ‘n Save), I made my own from steel-cut oats I had in the cabinet. I used a coffee grinder to get it nice and fine. Score one for Trader Joe’s: I found vanilla paste there.
FINALISTS: FAMILY FAVORITE
Swedish Go-To-School Cookies

PG tested
This chocolate recipe has been in Minnie Zhukas’ family for well over 100 years, and is a true family favorite. It was captured on paper by her beloved mother, Nancy Shorsher, who would double the recipe every Christmas for her four daughters and their families to enjoy. No one is sure where the name came from, but her maternal grandmother, Esther Nelson, made them with homemade sour cream, as store-bought was not available commercially.
For cookie
½ cup butter
1 cup brown sugar
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 1-ounce squares unsweetened chocolate, melted and cooled
2 cups flour
½ teaspoon baking soda
¼ teaspoon salt
¾ cups sour cream
1½ cups chopped walnuts
For icing
¼ cup butter
2 tablespoons cocoa
2½ teaspoons instant coffee, or more to taste
Dash salt
3 cups confectioner's sugar
3 tablespoons milk
1½ teaspoons vanilla
Prepare cookies. Cream butter and sugar until fluffy. Beat in egg and vanilla. Stir in melted chocolate.
Add dry ingredients alternately with sour cream. Mix well. Stir in nuts.
Drop generous portion from teaspoon 2 inches apart on greased baking sheet or parchment paper. Bake at 350 degrees 8-10 minutes.
Prepare icing. In large bowl, cream butter, cocoa, coffee and salt. Slowly add sugar alternately with vanilla and milk. Beat until smooth. Drizzle over cooled cookies and enjoy.
Makes 4 dozen.
— Minnie Zhukas, Forest Hills
Tester’s note: These easy drop cookies are simple to make and full of chocolate flavor. I had lots of the rich and fluffy icing left over, which doesn’t drizzle as much as spread. (I used it to ice some brownies.) I substituted espresso powder for the instant coffee because that’s what I had on hand. “Yes, need more!” one of the judges wrote on the scorecard.
Apricot Horns

PG tested
Paula Pfrommer’s 99-year-old mother, Audrey Steinmetz, can’t remember where or how she found this recipe, but it has been the star of Christmas cookie trays for more than 60 years. The ingredients are simple, but what really makes the cookie a standout is the process of assembling them, the Ross resident writes.
Son Matt rolls the dough, his fiancé Shelley adds the filling, daughter Kate dredges the horn in beaten egg whites “and I cover the cookies with fine walnut crumbs and arrange on the cookie sheet for freezing,” she says. “It is a treasured Christmas tradition for our family to gather together!”
For dough
1 pound butter
1 pound creamed cottage cheese (see below)
4 cups all-purpose flour
For filling
18½ ounces dried apricots
½ cup sugar, or more to taste
For coating
1½ cups ground nuts
1¼ cups sugar
2 egg whites
Confectioners’ sugar, for garnish
Holding back some of the flour, mix butter, creamed cottage cheese and flour in large bowl until dough forms, adding the remaining flour as needed. Shape into 1-inch balls, place on parchment covered cookie sheets and refrigerate overnight. You should get about 100 balls.
Make filling. Add apricots to a large sauce pot and add water until just covered. Cook on low heat, stirring occasionally, until apricots break down. Stir more frequently toward the end so the apricots do not burn. Add sugar to taste and purée until thick. Cool.
Make cookies. Lightly beat egg whites in a small bowl. In a larger bowl, mix ground nuts and sugar until well combined.
Working in small batches to keep the dough cold, roll dough balls into 2-inch-wide ovals. The dough should be thin, but still able to be handled. Place a generous teaspoon of filling in upper third of the oval, keeping away from the edges. Roll dough into a log and pinch the ends closed. (You might need to dab dough with a little water to make it stick.) Dip into egg whites, then roll into nut mixture to cover.
Form into horn (half-moon) shape and place on cookie sheet. Refrigerate or freeze until ready to bake.
To bake, preheat oven to 375 degrees. Bake for 12 minutes (longer if frozen) or until lightly brown. Dust with confectioners’msugar.
To make creamed cottage cheese from full-fat cottage cheese, place in strainer over a bowl and drain overnight. Place drained curds in a bowl and add cream to equal a pound.
— Paula Pfrommer, Ross
Tester’s note: I never heard of creamed cottage cheese (which is easy to make, if you have a kitchen scale) so I was intrigued by this recipe. The one drawback is it takes time (you need to refrigerate the dough overnight) and there’s a bit of skill in rolling, filling and shaping the dough into horns. It makes 100 cookies, so you definitely need a baking partner. My batch required several more eggs and about twice as many nuts; I used pecans instead of walnuts.
FINALISTS: CHOCOLATE
Mocha-Peppermint Cookie Sandwiches

PG tested
“I always looked forward to Christmas as a child because it was the one time of year my dad baked chocolate espresso cookies,” writes our youngest competitor, Brooke Schmitz of McCandless. She increased the “Christmas vibes” of his addictive cookies with peppermint bark and peppermint frosting.
“The only way to indulge these fudgey cookie sandwiches,” notes the University of Pittsburgh senior, “is with a large mug of hot chocolate, plenty of marshmallows and a peppermint candy cane!”
For cookies
1⅛ cups (2¼ sticks) butter, room temperature
¾ cup dark brown sugar
¾ cup granulated sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
½ teaspoon peppermint extract
2 large eggs, room temperature
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 cup Hershey’s unsweetened cocoa powder
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon coarse salt
⅛ cup Medaglia D’Oro instant espresso powder
8 Ghirardelli milk chocolate peppermint bark squares, chopped into large shards
8 Ghirardelli dark chocolate peppermint bark squares, chopped into large shards
For peppermint cream cheese frosting
½ cup (1 stick) butter, room temperature
8 ounces cream cheese, room temperature
3½ cups confectioners’ sugar
1 tablespoon milk
½ teaspoon vanilla extract
½ teaspoon peppermint extract
⅛ teaspoon coarse salt
6 Brach’s peppermint candy canes, crushed
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
In a large mixing bowl, beat butter, sugars and extracts until creamy. Add eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition.
In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, salt, and espresso powder.
Slowly beat the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients until just combined. Stir in the chocolate shards.
Using a ¼-cup measuring cup, scoop the dough onto a cookie sheet, arranging 6 cookies about 2 inches apart on each pan. Gently flatten the tops until they are 1-inch thick.
Bake for 12 minutes.
Cool on the baking sheet for 2 minutes then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.
Meanwhile, in a large bowl, beat the butter and cream cheese on medium speed for 2 minutes until smooth. Beat in the milk, extracts, and salt until creamy. Beat in confectioners’ sugar, 1 cup at a time, until fluffy. Gently fold in the candy canes.
Once the cookies are completely cool, scoop the frosting onto half the cookies and top with the remaining cookies, gently pressing each sandwich closed.
Makes 18 cookies (9 cookie sandwiches).
— Brooke Schmitz, McCandless
Tester’s note: I made these cookies a little smaller than suggested to increase the yield of just 9 cookie sandwiches. I used the bottom of a beer-tasting glass dipped in flour to flatten the cookies into a perfect circle. Be sure to crush the candy canes used in the icing completely, or it will make it difficult to sandwich the two cookies together. The cream cheese icing is delicious — perfect for adding a little holiday cheer to brownies or cupcakes.
Chocolate Mint Bars

PG tested
Anne Cochran always thinks of her mother when she makes these treats because she taught her “how to be patient and careful when putting on the thin top layers.” A family favorite when the Squirrel Hill resident was growing up, they are super chocolatey with a “fabulous” texture. (We agree!) Cochran also loves this recipe because it can be easily adapted for gluten- and dairy-free diets.
For brownie layer
1 stick (4 ounces) softened butter (or margarine)
2 ounces unsweetened chocolate
2 eggs
¾ cup sugar
½ teaspoon peppermint extract
½ cup almond flour (or regular flour)
For peppermint frosting layer
3 tablespoons softened butter (or margarine)
1½ tablespoons milk (or non-dairy milk)
1 teaspoon peppermint extract
1½ cups confectioners’ sugar
For chocolate layer
1 ounce unsweetened chocolate
1 tablespoon softened butter (or margarine)
Grease and flour a 9-by-13-inch pan (or line with parchment and grease the parchment). Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Prepare the brownie layer: Gently melt butter and chocolate together, then remove from heat and allow to cool slightly. In a separate bowl, beat eggs until well combined. Add sugar. Beat eggs and sugar together about 5 minutes. Slowly blend in chocolate mixture.
Stir in the peppermint extract and flour. Pour into pan, and bake approximately 20 minutes. Let cool to room temperature. If you can put it in the fridge to chill, even better.
Prepare the mint frosting: All together in one bowl, blend butter, milk, peppermint and confectioners’ sugar until smooth. Put small spoonfuls of the frosting dotted around the top of the brownies, and then carefully spread them out into a thin layer. Return to refrigerator for about 20 minutes, or freezer for 10.
Prepare the chocolate topping: Gently melt butter and chocolate together, then remove from heat and allow to cool slightly. Using a small brush, brush the chocolate carefully over frosting in a very thin layer. Or, drizzle over the frosting in a pretty pattern.
Chill until chocolate is set, then cut into small(ish) pieces and serve.
Makes about 48 pieces.
— Anne Cochran, Squirrel Hill
Tester’s note: I used regular flour in this delightful recipe and don’t think it made any difference. The batter for the brownie layer seems quite thin, but don’t worry — it will fill the pan. I used an offset spatula to spread the mint frosting over the chocolate layer and a silicone brush to drag the melted chocolate across the frosting. Very minty! A little goes a long way.
FINALISTS: ICED
Orange Cookies

PG tested
Janine Peiritsch was in first grade when she saw Kay Newman making these delicious orange drop cookie on “Kay’s Kitchen.” She immediately ran into the kitchen to ask her mother to write down the recipe “and the rest is family history!” she writes. They have graced the cookie tables at every family wedding and are a staple on Christmas cookies trays.
“My dear sister-in-law, who passed away back in 1993, loved the cookies so much that she said I had served my purpose in life by having my mother write down that recipe!” she says.
For cookies
1 cup butter, softened
2 cups granulated sugar
2 eggs
Grated rind and juice of 1 orange
4½ cups all-purpose flour, divided
2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon baking powder
1 cup sour milk (add 1 tablespoon vinegar OR lemon juice to 1 cup milk)
For orange Icing
½ cup (1 stick) butter, softened
1 pound confectioners’ sugar
Grated rind of 1 orange
Juice of 1 orange
In large bowl, cream butter and sugar until smooth. Add eggs and beat until light. Stir in orange juice and zest.
Add dry ingredients alternately with sour milk.
Drop by teaspoon onto greased cookie sheets (use butter or margarine to grease pans). Bake at 350 degrees for 8-10 minutes.
Make icing: Cream butter, confectioners’ sugar, orange zest and enough orange juice as needed to get desired consistency.
Frost cookies with orange icing when cooled.
Makes 5-6 dozen cookies.
— Janine D Peiritsch, Mt. Lebanon
Tester’s note: This is a very easy recipe. I did not substitute anything, although I decreased the white sugar by about ¼ cup. I did use ¼ cup juiced orange to smooth out the icing. I did not melt the butter, but let it sit out for about half an hour before starting recipe. Better with smaller-sized cookie rather than usual chocolate chip size.
Strawberry Pretzel Cookies

PG tested
“I absolutely love strawberry pretzel dessert,” writes Holli Bobick of Munhall, “so I started experimenting making a strawberry pretzel cookie.” After a few different trials and errors, she developed this delightful cookie, which features strawberry preserves and an icing made with three kinds of fat — butter, margarine and Crisco shortening. She says rolling all the balls before dipping them in the pretzel coating will help speed the process.
For cookies
2 cups crushed thin pretzels
¼ cup butter
2 tablespoons sugar
2 sticks butter (1 cup)
½ cup sugar
2 egg yolks
2 teaspoons vanilla
1 teaspoon baking powder
2¼ cups flour
1 cup strawberry preserves (you can use more if needed)
For icing
1 stick butter (½ cup)
1 stick margarine (½ cup)
2 tablespoons Crisco shortening
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 cups confectioners’ sugar
1-2 tablespoons heavy whipping cream
Prepare cookies: Crush pretzels in a food processor until crushed. Pour into a bowl.
Melt butter and sugar in a small saucepot on stove until sugar is melted. Add to the pretzels and mix thoroughly.
In a stand mixer or using a hand held mixer, cream the 1 cup of butter and ½ cup sugar. Add the 2 egg yolks and 2 teaspoons of vanilla.
Add the baking powder to the 2¼ cups of flour and stir into butter mixture. Mix until all incorporated, then refrigerate for 30 minutes.
When ready to bake, line cookie sheets with parchment paper and preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Roll dough into 1-inch balls. Dredge each ball into the pretzel mixture to coat.
Put on baking sheet and indent middle of cookie. Bake for 11 minutes
When cookie comes out add a teaspoon of preserves on top and let cool.
Make the icing. In a stand mixer or using a hand mixer, cream butter, margarine and Crisco until creamy. Add vanilla and confectioners’ sugar.
Add heavy cream 1 tablespoon at a time. Mix for 5 minutes.
Pipe icing onto cookies. I used a piping bag with the star tip, but you can also use a small Ziploc bag and cut off the corner. You can also use any tip you like.
Makes 48 cookies.
Holli Bobick, Munhall
Tester’s note: My first batch was too dry, so I added 2 additional tablespoons of butter to the batter. All butter/margarine (for batter and icing) should be pre-softened. While the recipe calls for 1-2 tablespoons of cream for the icing, you definitely need 2!
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1410 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.