MEADVILLE, Pa.— A Pleistocene-era glacier scooped out a 925-acre pothole, and as the ice wall receded a huge chunk of ice and stone broke off into the depression. It melted in time and the hole overflowed, eroding a 13-mile channel that emptied into French Creek, which itself had been turned around by the glacier.

The resulting “kettle hole” became Conneaut Lake, Pennsylvania’s largest natural lake. The slow-moving water of the lake’s drainage grew into Geneva Marsh, the largest remaining emergent marsh in the state.

That’s where fishing guide Bo Bartholomew took me to catch another prehistoric relic, the bowfin. The species that exists today is the last of a once-large group of ocean and freshwater fishes that thrived about 150 million years ago.

Not considered a game species, bowfin swim under the radar of anglers in swampy areas throughout the Northeast. Despite the fish’s widespread and stable population, Pennsylvania considered it a candidate for threatened conservation status until the bowfin was delisted just a few years ago. Despite its size, predatory nature and proclivity to be caught, most anglers know little about it. The Pennsylvania native is usually considered an incidental bycatch or worse, misidentified as an invasive snakehead and killed.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know why people don’t know about these fish,” said Bartholomew, sprawled across the bench seat at the back of his aluminum boat. “The long dorsal [fin] almost from head to tail looks creepy, like a dinosaur, but I’ve been catching them all my life. I started targeting them, and now it’s just about all I fish for.”

His main job is manufacturing and exporting small to mid-size multi-species soft plastic lures for his BC Bait Co. This year, Bartholomew placed within the top 20 in a national bowfin contest. He recently got a state guiding permit in hopes of helping Pennsylvania anglers rediscover the bowfin.

“They don’t need pristine water. Wherever there’s calm, grassy, swampy water, they may be there. They tolerate warm water and they’re pretty easy to catch,” he said, piercing the thawed flesh of a frozen shrimp with a No. 5 circle hook under a ¾-ounce slip sinker. He uses a light- or middle-weight spincast rod.

Anchored in 12 feet of calm evening water at the edge of a dense tangle of floating weeds, he plopped his rig into a clearing about three rod lengths from the boat.

“I have an underwater camera. I’ve seen them backed into the weeds at the edge of a channel, their eyes looking out for passing fish,” he said. “They’re ambush predators. They eat bluegills and other small fish.”

Advertise with us

The words had barely left his mouth when the line tightened and the rod bowed. The fish dove and twirled, smacked the surface and dove again before Bartholomew brought it to the starboard side and netted it. He carefully avoided its hard, toothy mouth, and his fingers slipped on the smooth skin-like scales.

“They have a swim bladder and can breathe air,” he said, holding up the fish for a photo. “They have barbels by their nostrils, like a catfish but smaller, and there are no spines in the dorsal. Males, mostly young males, have a dark spot, a false eye, on the tail.”

A minute after he released it, I hooked my first. The fish tangled in weed stems and got off. I fought the next one to the boat. In about two hours of easy fishing, we netted and released 12 bowfin as big as 22 inches. Days before, Bartholomew said he guided a father and son to the same spot, where they caught and released 25. A schooling fish, bowfin will continue to take baits until the water cools and they relocate.

Bartholomew’s catch-and-release policy notwithstanding, a long, stout bowfin provides a lot of white, flaky meat that plates well.

Bowfin are occasionally caught in nearby Pymatuning Reservoir, Lake Wilhelm, Presque Isle Bay and elsewhere. Smaller populations live in Pennsylvania’s southeast corner. When the state delisted the fish in 2016, Fish and Boat put it in a management category with panfish, catfish and carp: no closed season, no minimum size and a daily creel limit of 50.

Advertise with us

“Technically, they’re categorized S-4, ‘apparently secure,’” said Mike Parker, Fish and Boat spokesman. “We’ve basically seen an expanding population since the early 2000s in the French Creek and Allegheny River drainages, in part due to improving environmental conditions and probably people — ‘bucket biologists’ — moving them around.”

Parker said bowfin have some protections. Adults need a fishing license to catch them, and there is a creel limit, if high. As a native of the state, it receives the same level of protection as all aquatic species.

Parker conceded that bowfin are “not very much discussed.” But the Fish and Boat website stresses the physical differences between bowfin and snakehead, which are to be destroyed on sight.

“Bowfin have a small following. They are big fish and relatively easy to catch,” he said. “If their following continues to grow and the population does as well as they’ve been doing, they will probably be included in future management plans.”

Bo Bartholomew’s guiding service and BC Baits can be reached at 724-704-1723, bcbaitshadley@gmail.com.

Advertise with us