Lake Erie and tributaries (Erie County): It’s early, but steelhead that had been testing tributary mouths at night were spotted moving up Walnut and Elk creeks in daylight. Fishing shop staff said they were hitting everything. Less migration was noticed east of the peninsula. Weekend rains could spark an early run. On the lake, the walleye bite was cooling. Drift fishing on the Perch Pirate was productive near The Dump in 40-55 feet of water, and ’eyes were suspended at 55 feet in waters west of Presque Isle. Ohio anglers reported active walleye fishing at 70 feet. In the bay, shore anglers and boaters reported a good crappie bite off the city-side docks and piers.
Pymatuning Reservoir (Crawford County): As the annual winter drawdown began, anglers caught yellow perch and walleye at dusk and dawn on jigs and blade baits. A few muskellunge were landed. In 2019, Fish and Boat noted a reproducing population of invasive white perch and scolded anglers: “We can’t repeat it enough … please leave the stocking of any and all fish to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission and the Ohio Division of Wildlife.” The problem has gotten worse. With a chunky silvery body and two dorsal fins separated by a tiny notch, white perch don’t look like yellow perch and despite the name are not taxonomically related. Native to Canadian waters of northern Lake Erie and the brackish mouths of the Susquehanna and Delaware rivers, they are susceptible to overpopulation and when illegally introduced can upset the natural balance of fish populations. Fish and Boat urges Pymatuning anglers who catch white perch to remove them from the waterway.
Shenango Lake (Mercer County): Anglers caught smallish hybrid striped bass, walleye, largemouths, white bass and crappies.
Lake Wilhelm (Mercer County): No walleye were weighed in at the Lake Wilhelm Walleye tournament Sept. 11.
Allegheny River (Venango County): Good flow plus cool water equals fabulous fishing throughout the Middle Allegheny. Bronzebacks took soft plastics and crankbaits. In Emlenton, an angler released a 20-incher caught in the evening from his backyard. Anglers caught catfish at night.
Redbank Creek (Clarion County): Smallmouth bass and walleye were caught below the New Bethlehem dam and near the confluence with the Allegheny River
Read More
Keystone Power Dam (Armstrong County): Anglers caught walleye, largemouths and panfish.
Yellow Creek Lake (Indiana County): Largemouth and smallmouth bass were taken.
Ohio River (Beaver and Allegheny counties): Flathead catfish went wild from Monaca to the Point with catches of up to 40 pounds. About 30 pounds was the average. Most were taken at night and went for cut bait, live bluegills and crawlers.
Carnegie Lake (Allegheny County): Elliot Narbey, 5, of Highland Park, used a worm to catch a channel catfish.
Allegheny River (Allegheny County): With a little help from his 6-year-old son, Nate, Doug Shriber, of Natrona, caught and released a 27-inch, 9-pound walleye while trolling a 3½-inch Rapala Silver Shad Rap south of Lock No. 4.
Pine Creek (Allegheny County): From 1-3 p.m. Sept 17, while drifting crawlers with no weight near downed trees and other structure off Wildwood Road, Scott Kozelnik, of Wexford, caught and released three smallmouths measuring 15-17 inches as well as a half dozen smaller bass.
Canonsburg Lake (Washington County): Two teen anglers released four rainbow trout taken on worms under bobbers.
Correction: Thanks to Jim Nelson for catching a wrong date last week for fall trout stockings in Allegheny County. They are expected to begin Oct. 19.
File your fishing report and high-resolution digital photos (1MB minimum) at fishingreport@post-gazette.com. Include name, age (for under 18 years), town, species, size, body of water and details of the catch.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.