Those 12-inchers in Luke Wholey’s portable livewell aren’t the day’s catch. They’re bait.

A restaurateur and scion of the family behind the Strip District fish market, Mr. Wholey is an experienced fisherman who specializes in catching big ones close to home. He regularly fights legal-plus muskellunge, Northern pike and flathead catfish to the shore of the Allegheny River, sometimes using live bait bigger than another angler’s keepers.

In winter, Mr. Wholey stays off unstable ice on the river but makes weekly trips to frozen regional lakes. He shrugged off the big fish he released Monday at Lake Arthur in Moraine State Park, Butler County.

“I don’t want to sound, you know, bragging,” said the owner of Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaska Grille in the Strip District. “We do pretty well.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Wholey and fishing buddy Nicholas Colangelo of Colangelo's Bakery and Cafe in the Strip District will lead a free Basics of Ice Fishing workshop at 8-11 a.m. Feb. 3 at Raccoon Creek State Park in Beaver County. Information, registration: 724-899-2200 or events.dcnr.pa.gov.

Pulling anything through the ice is special, and bluegill, perch and trout are common ice-fishing catches in Pennsylvania. On a frozen lake everything is different -- tackle, bait, the fight, the risks. But Mr. Wholey says that even under a hard top one thing stays the same:

“The fish are still eating, and if they’re eating they’re catchable,” he said.

Like the old adage about the three keys to real estate -- location, location, location -- Mr. Wholey said targeting big fish through ice is mainly about where the holes are augered. Habitat, habitat, habitat, he might say.

“I do a lot of work on hydrographic maps looking for ambush points and points of travel, contour lines showing big drop-offs from weeds to open water,” he said.

Advertise with us

“Ambush predators like to hide in those weeds or just outside the edges under ice. In deep basins, fish get big because they don’t follow the normal patterns that fish take because there’s so much food.”

Visual topography such as points and steep or shallow hillsides, he said, generally continue underwater.

“A lot of people get tripped up on shoreline structure. I look for structure under ice,” said Mr. Wholey. “Where the main forage is shad, I fish at different depths in the water column.”

Ice fisherman Nico Summaria of Peters has a similar theory for targeting big fish under ice. Last winter, he and friends pulled 30 fish through the ice in six full days on glacially formed Conneaut Lake in Crawford County, where he targets native Northern pike.

“The way we targeted our bigger fish was always setting up our tent at 12 feet [from shore] right where the weed edges tend to be during the winter,” he said. “[We] had tip-ups with smaller bait towards the shoreline, and tip-ups with larger baits 8 inches and up on quick-strike rigs in the deeper water.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Summaria said the smaller pike stayed in the weeds.

“The deeper fish seemed to cruise the deeper flats and come towards the weeds when they are ready to feed,” he said. “Most of our 30-inch and up fish are coming on bigger baits just off the weed edges.”

Big fish want big baits, said Mr. Wholey, but foot-long suckers are expensive to buy and difficult to seine, especially when skim ice covers streams. For ice fishing, he likes a store-bought shiner in the 3- to 4-inch range pierced in the back with a No. 4 shiner hook on 15- to 20-pound fluorocarbon line. He rigs tip-ups over the maximum permitted five holes, each mandated to be no more than 10 inches in diameter.

“The main thing is, in Pennsylvania, you’re allowed five lines per person [for ice fishing], instead of three lines in the summer. You can put as many baits on a line as you want, but too many and you get tangled up.”

Three baits per line are permitted at Pymatuning Reservoir.

Advertise with us

“If you put two or three baits on a line 2 or 3 feet apart in five holes, you can cover the whole water column.”

Fish metabolism is slower in cold water, and running panfish and trout are generally easy to retrieve on a tip-up spool. A legal Northern pike or muskellunge, not so much.

“A big one will take a nice run on you, snap the line if you horse him or cut the line on the ice,” said Mr. Wholey. “It’s a whole different fight.”

Mr. Summaria and Mr. Wholey are conservationists who practice catch and release. On ice that often means shaking the fish off the hook before pulling it through the hole.

“I grab the gill plate with pliers while it’s still in the water,” said Mr. Wholey. “A big fish can get damaged being pulled through a 10-inch hole or flopping around on the ice. I don’t want to kill them. It’s enough to catch them.”

Advertise with us

     PG Outdoors Poll                                                                                                     

LAST WEEK: Should the no-wake zone near the Three Rivers confluence be extended

up the Monongahela River and down the Ohio River?

Yes 63 %

No 37 %

Advertise with us

872 responded

This poll is an unscientific tally of web postings generated by CivicScience.