The deer are bedded down to conserve energy. Squirrels and rabbits are huddled deep in their dens, and even hearty ruffed grouse have dived beak first into soft snow banks to protect themselves from Pennsylvania’s near-zero arctic freeze.
Below the ice, however, it’s winter business as usual and the game fish are hungry, if a bit lethargic.
“Minnows are still schooling. Bigger fish are still chasing after them. Even in this weather,” said Ed Vaccari of Tackle Unlimited in Jefferson Hills. “It’s all just happening slower, so you have to fish slower and put your holes over a good spot.”
It’s been several years since some of the state’s western counties have hosted a safe and prolonged ice fishing season. Unlike regional freeze-overs in recent memory, this one didn’t increase ice thickness progressively over a matter of weeks. The current “bomb cyclone” dropped air temperatures some 40 degrees -- to well below freezing -- in a day or less, and blanketed some places with snow as deep as 6 feet. Some anglers and amateur ecologists lamented publicly that a “flash freeze” effect might solidify shallow-running fish.
But even in the strange physics of water, it doesn’t work that way. NOAA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, describes a “bomb cyclone” or bombogenesis as a rotating mid-latitude cold air mass colliding with a warm air mass, which rapidly drops atmospheric pressure in a short period of time -- as quickly as 24 hours -- drawing in a rush of colder air from farther north. Precisely the once-in-40-year event that recently plunged the American Northeast into ice-fishing weather.
Wild fish didn’t freeze like frozen food, however, because “bomb cyclones” do not drop temperatures fast enough or low enough to create waterborne poly-crystalline solids. So much for steam-in-bag bluegill fillets. Pennsylvania anglers bundled up and provided their own fish dinners the old fashioned way -- through holes augered over waters from Lake Erie to the West Virginia line.
Read More
Part of the ice-fishing challenge is determining where to cut the holes. Vaccari said he likes to find spots over vegetation where baitfish hide from predators.
“We used to find drop-offs and deep weeds in the summer and remember those spots in the winter,” said Vaccari. “Now they use GPS and a lot of electronics, even cameras you put down and look around. But it costs money to get outfitted that way.”
Jeff Staaf of Poor Richard’s Bait and Tackle in Erie County said choosing a spot on Presque Isle Bay, a popular ice fishing destination, can be like “rolling the dice.”
“A lot of people like to fish through ice around the Stink Hole where there’s a little bit of a drop off,” he said, “but a lot of times they just go to Misery Bay, Horseshoe Pond or the marina where the ice thickens faster.”
Later in the season, said Staaf, some fish will start moving toward weed beds and shallower water. Panfish can be caught by chance just about anywhere, and yellow perch and walleye are generally caught deeper, but Staaf said the few anglers who target bigger prey start with bigger bait.
“A guy caught a 32-inch northern in Horseshoe Pond, and [Wednesday] another guy caught a 35-inch northern in Misery Bay,” he said. “They like to have bigger baits -- 2 ½-inch to 3-inch chubs -- but we don’t carry those sizes [at Poor Richard’s]. The northerns go back into the lagoons where it’s not safe to fish, but some are caught near the [Perry] monument and in the area at the head of the bay.”
Northerns and muskellunge are often caught deep, but Staaf said the apex predators sometimes cruise just under the ice where they can be caught on dead minnows.
Finding trout under ice can be easier, said Mike Milvet of Cross Creek Bait Shop in Avella, Washington County.
“I’ve targeted trout at Dutch Fork Lake using [paste bait], mealworms and maggots,” he said. “In lakes where they stock trout, even using the same baits you’d use for panfish, I’ve hardly ever caught a bluegill or crappie when I was ice fishing for trout.”
Milvet said anglers pulled pike through the ice recently on High Point Lake using 3-4 inch shiners. A few fishing huts were up last week on Cross Creek Lake, and anglers said they pulled out bluegills and crappies in 10-22 feet of water using tipped ice jigs.
“The thing about ice fishing, they could be 10 feet from you and if you’re in the wrong spot you get nothing,” said Milvet. “We go down and drill multiple holes in a pattern, and stick a fish finder in to see what we’ve got. If there’s nothing there we move a good ways away and do the same thing until we find fish all stacked up. The pattern gives you a good spread and better access to a greater number of fish.”
Ice fishing can be fun but it’s not worth dying for.
“I don’t like [fishing over] moving water because you don’t know where a [soft] spot might be,” said Vaccari. “People do it and some catch some nice fish, but it’s risky because even when it’s 4 inches or more the ice is always moving [on a river or creek] and you don’t know where a spring might be coming in underneath or where cracks are forming when it’s covered with snow.”
Anglers should stay just as vigilant over lakes and ponds. In mid-December emergency crews recovered the body of a Pittsburgh-area fisherman who fell through 3-inch ice on Lake Arthur at Moraine State Park, Butler County. Last week the state Fish and Boat Commission announced that ice breaking activities and commercial shipping would soon begin in Presque Isle Bay.
“The public should be advised that all portions of the bay could be impacted by this work,” stated the media release. “Extreme caution should be used at all times when accessing the bay for any and all recreational purposes.”
Fish and Boat recommends that anglers keep off ice less than 4 inches thick; avoid “stickups” such as brush, logs, plants or docks; and stay away from areas with multiple pressure cracks. Safety accessories should include personal flotation devices and ice awls or picks, and anglers should stay within reach of a length of rope anchored to shore or something solid. General guidelines for ice-fishing safety and special regulations are posted at fishandboat.com.
Rising temperatures this week, including rain showers and a high of 45 expected Jan. 11-12 in the Pittsburgh area, will degrade ice and render some previously solid spots unsafe for fishing. But through the rest of January average temperatures from Erie to Washington, Pa., are expected to remain in the mid- to high-30s. For the first time in years western Pennsylvania could get weeks -- maybe a month -- of good fishing under ice.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.