Attorneys general from three Great Lakes states including Pennsylvania say a $275 million federal plan for keeping Asian carp out of the lakes is too expensive and rejects the most effective possible solution.

In a long-awaited report released last summer, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers outlined three options for protecting the lake system from the invasive fish that could devastate those waters. The Corps is recommending combined technologies that would include a new electric barrier, a new "flushing lock" that would deter fish with noise cannons and a re-engineered shipping channel with water jets.

Thirty-five percent of the $275 million price tag would be paid by states and other non-federal investors. The plan would leave shipping lanes open and allow for a 10 to 17 percent chance that silver and bighead carp could move upstream and become established in Lake Michigan, inevitably spreading throughout the lake system.

According to the Chamber of Marine Commerce, shipping in the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence Seaway produces business revenues of $35 billion and creates 227,000 jobs in the U.S. and Canada. Additionally, shipping in the region contributes $4.6 billion in federal, state, province and local taxes annually and supports a consumer market of more than 100 million people.

Advertise with us

Opponents of the plan say the environmental health of the largest surface freshwater system on the Earth is invaluable. Last month Pennsylvania attorney general Josh Shaprio and his counterparts from Michigan and Minnesota co-authored a formal comment rejecting the plan in favor of a permanent separation option -- a $5.9 million plan to build a concrete wall separating the carp-infested Illinois River and Lake Michigan. Migration of the fish would be stopped cold at the wall and shipping would portage around the barrier.

What’s in a name?

It is officially OK to call game wardens game wardens. For the first time, the state Game Commission will now refer to its law enforcement officers as “state game wardens.” Originally defined by law in 1895 as “district game protectors,” they have been “wildlife conservation officers” since 1987. Executive Director Bryan Burhans said the new title is an accurate description of the job.

“The goal here is to more clearly identify our officers and their purpose. We believe ‘state game warden’ will help communicate this,” he said, in a statement. “In addition, this title already is well understood by the public. The word ‘warden’ is America’s oldest title for the men and women who serve wildlife in this capacity.”

Pennsylvania game wardens enforce hunting and trapping laws and regulations, and are the sole authority regarding wildlife and its management. They respond to calls about nuisance and injured wild animals, coordinate education programs and assist agency biologists with field research and wildlife surveys. Legally considered peace officers with statewide law-enforcement authority, game wardens are held to the same standards as police regarding civil rights, the gathering of evidence and prosecutorial conduct.