Enjoying a cold, creamy ice cream delight on a hot summer evening is one of the season’s greatest joys. And since the world’s largest ice cream cone manufacturer is headquartered in this region, we thought we’d round up a few of our favorite scoops, soft serve and dairy-free options (and offer a feature about the family behind another of Pittsburgh’s beloved ice cream shops, Happy Day Dessert Factory) to get you rolling throughout the area for a treat.
Think Like a Chef: Mitch’s BBQ

Mitch Evanitsky is now 30 years deep into delighting North Hills residents with a variety of hard-scoop ice cream flavors. He and his wife, Bev, started selling handmade ice cream in 1992 in a Babcock Boulevard gas station/car wash/laundromat. They moved the business several times, landing in Warrendale in 2003. In 2018, their son Justin joined Mitch’s BBQ, which, true to its name, also serves some of the best barbeque in the region.
Justin Evanitsky is a trained chef who employs a creative culinary approach when developing new flavors. Take corn, for example. Evanitsky shucks the corn, simmers the kernels and the cobs in cream, squeezes it all out, and adds sugar, sour cream, salt and butter. Then, after a run in a Pacojet, it’s a creamy bite that tastes of high summer (and is the perfect complement to the establishment’s first-class barbecue).
Father and son talk about ideas, but each has his own voice when deciding what flavors to prepare. Their small-batch offerings run the gamut from tasty classics such as vanilla, chocolate and coffee to wilder flavors such as a zingy and vegetal carrot-ginger.
“Sometimes I just have an idea. Like with carrot ginger, I’d never had that flavor combination before so I figured I’d just experiment until I know how to make it,” says Justin Evanitsky. “I don’t even know how many recipes we have. If we had time, we’d make new flavors as often as we could.”
Read More
16070 Perry State Rte., Warrendale; mitchsbarbeque.com
Not Just Nostalgia: Page’s

Page’s (formerly Page Dairy Mart) could easily rest on nostalgia. Charles Alexander Page opened the business in 1951, making it one of Pittsburgh’s oldest continuously family-owned ice cream stands. It’s also endlessly Instagramable — the one-story shop, with its bright neon signage, hemmed into a hill, tucked beneath an underpass, is a signature destination to take a shot. Plus, what Page’s offers, from the classic soft-serve twists to its signature Arctic Swirls, is quite tasty.
Yet rather than rest on nostalgia, fifth-generation co-owner Marjorie Page Prusia is pushing forward with quality and creativity. She introduced a very good oat milk-based soft serve last year. Now, she’s restlessly experimenting with specialty soft-serve flavors, many of which, such as apple butter, rotate seasonally and of which there typically are 30 to 35 at any given time. Fruity Pebbles, introduced last year, is a cut above. It’s rich and creamy, of course, with notes of cereal milk in the vanilla base. The speckles of pebbles (about the size you might find lingering at the bottom of the box) offer a pop of tartness that cuts the richness of the dairy in the best possible way.
“It’s cool to have all the classic things but to introdcue new ideas, and see how people respond, is exciting. It keeps things interesting for us and I hope it keeps things interesting for all of our customers,” Prusia says.
4112 E. Carson St., South Side; pagedairymart.net
Non-Dairy Delight: Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream

Although Pittsburgh’s dairy-free ice cream alternatives are becoming more widely available and generally better, Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream, which introduced a line of options in 2019, still reigns supreme when it comes to balancing texture and flavor. (Though if you’re looking for a restaurant option, be sure to visit Apteka, where the sunflower seed-based ice creams are a true delight.) It’s a challenge to get the right balance between having enough body to offer the delightful mouthfeels of eating an ice cream cone without having to use a base flavor that overwhelms the situation. Millie’s uses a high-fat coconut cream, an ingredient that provides a luxurious, whipped cream texture but often can be too obtrusive if not dealt with correctly.
“We try to develop flavors that play well with coconut or overwhelm the coconut flavor,” says Millie’s president and co-founder Chad Townsend.
Take mango, for example. There’s coconut in the background, but it bolsters the sweet and slightly sour mango flavor. With dark chocolate brownie batter, on the other hand, the deep chocolate flavor drowns out any coconut noise.
Of course, there’s plenty to choose from for dairy lovers, too. Millie’s has become a titan since Townsend and his wife, Lauren, opened their first store in Shadyside in 2016. They now have six scoop shops and outposts at Kennywood and two university campuses, plus a significant presence in grocery store freezer cases.
Endless Possibilities: Antney’s

Antney’s, the South Hills gem Anthony and Lee Ann Ciotti opened in 2011, always has a bevy of crowd-pleasing flavors. Anthony, whose childhood nickname was Antney (hence the name) and manager Vikki Lane create the ice cream flavors. There are typically 16 offered at any given time, a tiny sliver of more than 600 recipes in their ever-expanding repertoire.
“We listen to our customers to hear what they’re craving. And we try to hit a bunch of different flavor marks for sweet treats. And there’s a seasonal element, too. The summer is more fruit oriented. In the fall, we’ll have more pumpkin flavors,” Lane says.
Ciotti and Lane make their bases specific to the flavors they are working on. (Most ice cream shops use a standard base and then blend in flavorings.) That means stracciatella, a creamy Italian-inspired ice cream studded with chocolate shavings, might have higher milk fat and less sugar than sweet mint, a bright scoop with Meltaway Mints incorporated into the base.
“Because everything is custom made in small batches, we have the ability to make things in a very specific way,” says Lane.
With the array of bright-colored offerings, such as the aquamarine base and rainbow-cereal-spiked Fruity Pebbles (the ice cream trend of the year), Antney’s makes for a great place to bring the kids (and kids at heart), particularly as some of the flavors here tend to run on the sweeter side. Milky Musketeers, for example, is a candy bar turned into ice cream, with the whipped mousse replaced by ice cream delight.
1316 Poplar St., Green Tree; facebook.com/antneys
Old School Charm: Hank’s Frozen Custard & Mexican Food

Hank Grosshans opened this Beaver County frozen custard stand in 1947 and, according to current owner Jeff Kohlmann, added a small Mexican food menu in the early 1970s. Kohlmann’s parents purchased the business from Grosshans in 2000, and Jeff purchased the operation from his mother after his father passed away in 2010. The building, with its iconic “Hank’s” sign, might look as old as the business, but it was built in 2001 after the Kohlmanns decided they needed a little more space to add food items.
What didn’t change were the ice cream recipes. “If it’s not broken, don’t try to fix it,” Kohlmann says. “It’s basically the same as it ever was.” (Though he did upgrade equipment, noting he swapped the old Electro Freeze machines, which required building custom parts to replace the broken ones, for a Stoelting custard freezer a few years ago.) Frozen custard is different from ice cream because it has a high percentage of egg yolks in the mix but typically is on the low end (10%) of butterfat. “It’s a richer, thicker product.”
Chocolate ice cream is best when it’s whimsical. With due respect to artisanal ice cream shops (we love you, most of the time), chocolate ice cream sold at those operations is all-too-often made to resemble a fancy chocolate bar. The most satisfying chocolate ice creams give as much importance to the cream as the chocolate. And Hank’s gets it right; there is an essence of chocolate pudding in its frozen custard, balanced with a depth of creaminess. Even though it’s a scooped ice cream, it’s meltingly satisfying, nearly a milkshake on a hot summer night.
2210 3rd Ave., New Brighton; go2hanks.com
Correction: An earlier version of this story misidentified Mitch’s BBQ co-owner Bev Evanitsky.
Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.