Among the ice cream flavors in regular rotation at Happy Day Dessert Factory, Fruity Pebbles Cheesecake started out as a one-off, a birthday treat for a co-owner.
Galen Moorer Jr. was turning 21, months after he and his father, Galen Moorer Sr., opened the ice cream shop not far from their home in the Mexican War Streets. But it proved to be so popular that it’s often among the dozen flavors available on a given day.
“It’s really good, so I’m glad that it turned out really well, and everybody else likes it, too,” says the younger Moorer, who’s staring down an encroaching 23rd birthday in September.
As Moorer Sr. notes, “All of these flavors have a story.” And with nearly 60 varieties in rotation at Happy Day, well, sit back. The Moorers have some tales to tell.

“We started experimenting, with flavors that he grew up with, that he liked, and flavors that I grew up on and I liked,” Moorer Jr. says of himself and his dad. “His favorite is the Danish sweet cream — it tastes like the cream between Oreos, that’s how I describe it. Black raspberry is a family favorite. My grandma loves black raspberry. ... She gets that for her birthday cake every year, black raspberry ice cream cake every year.”
Happy Day Dessert Factory opened March 18, 2020, at the very beginning of the pandemic shutdown. But, deemed an essential business, and with a business model that, Moorer Sr. says, is a bit different from many other eateries — “you don’t linger at an ice cream parlor,” he notes — it thrived. With people working from home, he says, neighborhood residents were around during the day to patronize shops like his, and maybe even try flavors such as Butterfinger.
Read More
The Butterfinger ice cream started as a solution to a problem: Too much leftover Butterfinger topping.
“The Butterfinger topping would stick together, so you’d have to throw it away. We had all this Butterfinger,” Moorer Sr. recalls. “So I said, ‘You know what, we’re going to make a Butterfinger flavor ice cream, see if it will work. It’s so popular now, that it’s probably in our top 10 flavors.”

The Moorers, who have a history in frozen treats — Moorer Sr. ran a Rita’s franchise on East Ohio Street from the time Jr. was in single digits — embrace flights of fancy when it comes to their hard ice creams, which they make in-house. Sure, you can find basic chocolate and vanilla soft serve here, but what kid (or adult in touch with their inner kiddo) can say no to Cookie Monster?
Moorer Jr. is all smiles talking about that flavor, which is, but of course, in the same hue of its namesake.
“My favorite thing, I will say, is interacting with the customers and seeing their reaction when they try different flavors of ice cream. Children, they love the Cookie Monster ice cream. It's a blue ice cream with a whole bunch of different cookies in it. Fudge Stripes, Oreos, regular cookie dough,” he says. “They love it. It’s one of my favorites too.”
The list of fun flavors, and favorites, goes on, as Happy Day is fueled by family. Moorer Jr., seated on one of the parlor’s candy-red chairs, points to his dad and his girlfriend, Deja Robinson (her top pick: blueberry), working behind the counter, and notes that his younger sister, Ameriah Fisher, and cousin, Ameriah Winston (for both: Cinnamon Toast Crunch), work at the shop, too. “It’s basically my whole family down here.”
Don’t feel limited by ice cream, however. Cooling treats include water ices in about 20 flavors, and frozen custard and yogurt, plus you can mix and match for, say, an ice cream sandwich (cookies are baked in-house) or stacker (custard layered with water ice). Or go for a funnel cake sundae, another offering with a story.
“It takes me back to Kennywood,” Moorer Jr. says. “My dad and I used to go there at least once a summer to get one.”

Happy Day Dessert Factory: 906A Western Ave., North Side; happydaydessertfactory.com
Polly Higgins: phiggins@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1960, Twitter @higginspolly, IG @pollyhig.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.