West Overton Village and Museums originally was home to what became known as Old Overholt rye whiskey, which had been last distilled at that Westmoreland County historic site before Prohibition. Then, in 2019, the place fired up a new still and started again making Pennsylvania — or, Monongahela rye, as it became known.
On Nov. 5, guests will be among the first to try what they’re calling West Overton Distilling Monongahela Rye Whiskey at a fundraising dinner and panel discussion, “What exactly defines Pennsylvania rye whiskey?”
Distiller Aleasha Monroe made it with a classic grain bill of 80% rye and 20% malted barley, which may be what Abraham Overholt used commercially there starting in the early 1800s. Settlers found it more efficient to concentrate their rye grain — it grew well in Pennsylvania’s rocky, clay soil — into whiskey and send it down the Monongahela River to distant markets, where it made a name for itself.
Rye whiskey almost disappeared in the 1950s and ’60s, losing out to lighter boozes, but it has roared back with the recent craft spirits boom.
West Overton will be serving several of them on this special night, including its own Monongahela rye, which was aged for 15 months in a new 30-gallon charred oak barrel.
Guests will also be able to try Liberty Pole Spirits Rye Whiskey from Washington, Pa.; Dad’s Hat Bottled in Bond Pennsylvania Straight Rye from Bristol; Stoll & Wolfe Pennsylvania Rye Whiskey from Lititz; and a contemporary version of Old Overholt, which is said to be the oldest continual U.S. whiskey brand. It’s now owned by Beam Suntory, which sells a bonded straight rye version, meaning it is federally required to be aged for four years, bottled at 100 proof, and contain liquid that is the product of a single distillation season.
Read More
This throughout a light, fall-flavored dinner, starting with Poached Pear Salad with blue cheese crumbles, roasted butternut squash and champagne vinaigrette, followed by Oysters Rockefeller. The main course is a choice of Filet Medallion or Broccoli & Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast served au jus, Tri-Color Duck Fat Mashed Fingerlings and French Beans. Dessert is an Apple Brie and Caramel Tart.
What’s really loaded is the panel, which will be moderated by West Overton board member and rye whiskey historian Sam Komlenic, a native of nearby Ruffs Dale. He’ll mix it up with some big names:
- David Wondrich, Ph.D., who has written five books and countless articles for a wide variety of publications and is now senior drinks columnist for The Daily Beast. The Brooklyn, N.Y., resident is editor-in-chief of the new “The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails.” Drinks International’s inaugural list of the 100 most influential people in the bar world in 2019, based on a poll of industry pros, ranked him No. 3.
- Lew Bryson, also is a veteran writer on beer and spirits, is currently The Daily Beast’s senior drinks writer and a Craft Spirits magazine columnist. The Central Pennsylvania resident authored “Tasting Whiskey,” a broad survey of the whiskeys of the world, and “Whiskey Master Class,” a deep dive on all aspects of whiskey flavor creation.
- Steve Bashore is the director of historic trades at George Washington’s Mount Vernon, which means he oversees the reconstructed Washington’s Distillery and Gristmill there.
Tickets for the evening, which runs from 5 to 8:30 p.m. Nov. 5, are $150 per person.
Ms. Monroe, who also West Overton’s chief operations officer, says she “packed a ton of value” into the event, which will help the village and museums continue its mission of illustrating the rise of the American Industrial Revolution.
So will bottle sales of the West Overton rye, which should be ready by early November in the attraction’s new tasting room, open during tour hours later this fall and winter. The 375-milliliter bottles look to be priced at $50 each.
Ms. Monroe is starting with what she calls “Barrel No. 1,” which she filled from numerous distillations in 2019 and 2020. She says the resulting rye, weighing in the barrel at 114 proof, has “a real nice grassy floral-ness.” She was planning to proof it, with Mr. Komlenic’s help, at between 92 and 96 proof, which is higher than the 80 proof that was historically produced here. But today’s craft rye drinkers like it a bit stronger.
Barrel 2 could be ready in December, while Barrel 3 has a ways to go, she says. “We’ve done everything by taste.”
West Overton doesn’t know the exact grain bills that were used here, but Ms. Monroe’s colleague, director of education Aaron Hollis, recently was researching a new exhibit on Abraham Overholt and discovered an inventory of the full barrels (of 108 proof) he owned when he died. They included both a pure rye whiskey and a Monongahela whiskey as well as a pure wheat whiskey.
Is Monongahela rye a particular subset of or just another name for Pennsylvania rye? That’s one of Ms. Monroe’s questions that will come up at the dinner discussion, which is sure to be spirited, as what is Pennsylvania rye continues to be open to interpretation.
Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.