No one ever accused Abe Overholt of being smiley. Nor, apparently, did anyone ever depict him that way.

But even he might get a kick out of a new image of him that nicely immortalizes his frown.

After his Mennonite family settled in Westmoreland County in 1800, Abraham Overholt started commercially making a rye whiskey there. After his sons and grandson had taken over, starting in 1888, it became known — nay, renowned — as Old Overholt. For years, bottles featured his frowny face, as drawn from a period portrait.

The no-nonsense brand survived Prohibition (when it was sold as medicine) and changing consumer tastes to be the only nationally distributed rye whiskey and the oldest continually made rye in America. It also survived ownership changes, including in 1987, when Jim Beam bought it and moved production to Kentucky. Beam added some corn to the recipe. But it is believed that Abe’s visage was lightened up at some point by previous owner National Distillers Products Co., which may have used a more smiley Abe first on bottles bound for Europe in the late 1950s or early 1960s.

Advertise with us

This past year, the global Beam Suntory that now owns it decided to update the liquid and brand. That included restoring Abe’s scowl, a job they gave to San Francisco artist Stephen Noble, whose work you might recognize from his gladiator icon of American Express.

Now, Abe as his friends, if he had any, knew him scowls at customers in liquor stores and bar shelves and sometimes at events at West Overton Village & Museums, where this all started 220 years ago. (They’re making their own rye there again, with some financial support from Beam Suntory, and Aleasha Monroe, who has the cool title of West Overton’s “chief operating officer and distiller,” says, “I really appreciate the time and attention that were paid when refreshing Abe's new look.”)

Shawn Hudgins, who’s helping with Beam Suntory’s global rebranding, says it’s “probably the only time anyone in package design has said, ‘The guy on the label would be better if we made him look mean like his paintings.’ ” He and colleagues are trying to fill in holes in the history, such as when and why exactly Abe first smiled, but unlike some brands, they don’t have to make any of it up.

Rye, after having almost died out in the 1960s, is enjoying a resurgence, and fans are smiling at new expressions of Old Overholt as an 11-year straight rye and a 114-proof straight rye that are being sold in limited amounts only in Pennsylvania and Ohio. The Rust Belt is especially loyal to the much more affordable regular 3-year-old version, that also got a bit of an update to 86 proof and now is non-chill-filtered, a characteristic shared by the new bottled-in-bond version, too. That last one made Whiskey Advocate’s list of “Top 20 Whiskies of 2020.” All the new Overholt bottles have old-school red caps.

And on all of them, Abe is not happy about any of it.

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr