There’s been a lot of noise recently about Cracker Barrel, the nearly 56-year-old country-themed chain of restaurants and gift shops, which announced a makeover in August. Founded in Lebanon, Tenn., in 1969, it is known for serving Southern-style comfort food.

The reaction to the company’s announcement was not good, with many lashing out on social media.

Mars residents Joyce and Donald Gindlesperger, aged 63 and 85, respectively, encountered outside the Cranberry Cracker Barrel Tuesday, were well aware of the controversy. They were making their visit exactly because they wanted a last visit to the restaurant before potential changes.

Regular customers since the Cranberry location opened along Route 228 in 2017, according to the company, both heartily disagreed with proposed changes to the chain, which included new signage that dropped the image of a man next to the barrel in favor of just the text of the restaurant chain’s name.

Advertise with us

“I think it stinks,” Joyce Gindlesperger said. “Actually I’ve already written to them and told them that one of the reasons we come here, is for the ambiance and the nostalgia of it.”

She said that the proposed updated interiors would prohibit her from returning.

Referring to antique sports, farming and hunting equipment that festoon Cracker Barrel’s walls, Donald Gindlesperger said, “I look at all the implements hanging around, and I know I used them. My father, my grandfather used them.”

They planned to take pictures of the interior to retain the memory of it.

On a national level, even President Donald Trump got involved, calling for the company to return to its old logo.

Advertise with us

On Aug. 26, it did.

If you have questions about what’s going on, here are some answers.

What’s all this brouhaha about Cracker Barrel?

Cracker Barrel announced a rebrand on Aug. 19. It changed its logo from its iconic seated man — often referred to as “Uncle Herschel,” founder Dan Evin’s uncle, “the soul of Cracker Barrel,” as the company characterizes him — leaning his elbow against a barrel to a plain gold background with bold black letters.

The words “Old Country Store” were removed.

Since last year, the chain has been updating the decor in some of its locations, installing a brighter, more modern design and toning down the antiques-laden traditional look. It has also refreshed  menu items (with premium and plant-based options) and the design of its menu.

Advertise with us
The new Cracker Barrel logo is displayed on Aug. 21 in New York.(AP)

How many locations does Cracker Barrel have in Pa.?

Cracker Barrel operates about 660 stores nationwide in 44 states, according to its website, with 25 in the state of Pennsylvania.

There are four stores in the immediate Pittsburgh area: North Fayette; Cranberry, Butler County; Washington, Washington County; and New Stanton, Westmoreland County.

What has the reaction to the Cracker Barrel rebrand been?

It’s hard to believe we’re just talking about a company’s new logo here.

X users have been in conniptions. YIMBYLAND said the rebrand is “one of the most upsetting things I’ve seen in a long time,” adding, “Literally everyone I know is in shock.”

Others call the new look “generic,” “forgettable” and “absolute hot garbage.”

Advertise with us

Who has gotten involved in the Cracker Barrel controversy?

In response to an Aug. 20 post on X about the change from WokeWarRoom,” Donald Trump Jr. wrote, “WTF is wrong with @CrackerBarrel??!” The post generated 3 million views to date.

The rebrand became a lightning rod issue among conservatives, who have called the move “woke” or see it as an expression of the company’s diversity, equity and inclusion policies.

The official account of the Democratic party offered a rare across-the-aisle moment of agreement: “We think the Cracker Barrel sucks too,” it posted on Aug. 21, with 15 million views.

Celebrities have also gotten involved. Country singer John Rich posted on X, “Will you go to Cracker Barrel now that it’s going woke? This could be a ‘Bud Light’ moment in the making …,” referring to a 2023 boycott of Bud Light, sparked by a promotion that included Dylan Mulvaney, an influencer who is transgender.

Actor James Woods took his turn on X Aug. 22 by posting an image of Cracker Barrel’s LGBTQ+ Alliance page, with the comment, “So this, of course, is the cancer rotting the soul of a cherished restaurant chain with a wholesome Americana theme. It’s always this [expletive]. Always.”

Advertise with us

President Donald Trump posted Aug. 26, advising the company on Truth Social to “go back to the old logo, admit a mistake.”

Later that day, the company reversed course and ditched the new logo.

Trump approved the move: “Congratulations 'Cracker Barrel' on changing your logo back to what it was. … Make lots of money and, most importantly, make your customers happy again!”

The White House Tuesday night emailed a press release about the reversal as well. It included a statement from Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary that gave credit to Trump for the change. “President Trump has unmatched business instincts, and an uncanny ability to understand what the American people want,” Leavitt said. “Cracker Barrel is a great American company, and they made a great decision to Trust in Trump!”

What did Cracker Barrel have to say about its reversal?

Initially, Cracker Barrel CEO Julie Felss Masino defended the logo change on “Good Morning America,” saying that feedback had been “overwhelmingly positive.”

Advertise with us

Later, the company admitted it “could’ve done a better job” in communicating about the logo change, but it still stuck by the new look.

After the president’s intervention, the company changed course later that same day, and reverted to the old logo: “We thank our guests for sharing your voices and love for Cracker Barrel. We said we would listen, and we have. Our new logo is going away and our 'Old Timer' will remain,” the company said in a statement posted on social media Aug. 26.

How have the markets reacted to Cracker Barrel waffling?

Two days after the logo change, Cracker Barrel stock fell more than 14%. After the president’s recommendation that the company change its logo back, the stock rose 6%. Following the company’s reversion to the old logo, in premarket trading Aug. 27, shares had risen 4%.

What have Pennsylvanians had to say about the Cracker Barrel chaos?

Local reaction on Facebook has been relatively mild and occasionally humorous. Responding to a post on Meanwhile In Pennsylvania, Dan Powers remarked, “Changing the logo won’t make the food any better.”

Melanie Brubaker was of a similar opinion in the same thread: “The sign now matches the food…bland.”

Advertise with us

Responders to a Facebook account holder in Washington County mostly remarked on how the local Cracker Barrel had not changed. “My mom and I were there this past week. Fortunately, it’s still the same,” one said.

Another weighed in with a dose of common sense about the whole fuss: “Who cares about a logo, or the interior design. If they still have good food is all I care about.. people are just NUTS with this stupidity of logos and interrior [sic] designs.”