Picking a single best dish, or even a handful of dishes, of the year is an impossible task. Pittsburgh’s restaurants and pop-ups offer a multitude of tasty options and, as always, I did my darnedest to explore as many as possible in 2024. What follows are the meals, dishes and moments that moved me most.
Best new meal: Fet-Fisk
I ate at Fet-Fisk more than any other restaurant in 2024, from grand, order-it-all meals to lively, communal evenings full of small bites and cocktails that felt like a roving party. Essentially, they were fixed extensions of the “fostering a great time” ethos Nik Forsberg and Sarah LaPonte fostered when they launched Fet-Fisk as a popup series in 2019, albeit now with a much more developed menu and bar program.
I think that’s why my favorite 2024 meal from the establishment was a spur-of-the-moment, casual early evening dinner at the bar with a good pal.
We shared a beef tartare appetizer, split the establishment’s now-famous roast chicken and crushed a big pile of scratch-made french fries while drinking glasses of funky orange wine. The easygoing meal reminded me how even a hot spot can feel like a welcoming neighborhood joint when its staff prioritizes warmth and connection.
Fet-Fisk is the buzziest restaurant to open in Pittsburgh in recent years, garnering well-earned praise from national outlets such as The New York Times and Eater (as well as a place on our Best New Restaurants 2024 list).
Rather than letting the hype go to their heads, the Bloomfield spot’s team remains committed to hospitality first, creating an atmosphere where guests feel truly cared for the minute they step through the front door.
My guess is that it’ll be a couple of years before the hubbub dies down. Once it inevitably does, however, it’ll be this sort of service that keeps the restaurant humming for years to follow.
Best value splurge: Morcilla
My pick for the paradoxical concept of “value splurge of the year” goes to Morcilla for its smoked beef short rib. The large-plate dish checks in at $85 plus tax and tip, so it’s by no means a causal decision (though also not outside the norm of a steakhouse price for a celebrated cut of beef).
That said, this dish is so totally worth the indulgence. Tender slices of slightly smoky, super luscious beef are carved and plated like shingles along the dramatic rib bone resting atop complementary accoutrements. When I ordered it in October, the beef was served on a bed of velvety sweet potato tahini, crunchy-creamy fried sweet potatoes and roasted peppers with an acidity cutting through the luscious richness of the meat.
Unless you’re feeling extraordinarily decadent (cheers and more power to you if that’s the case), you’re not going to order this solo and call it a night.
Place that short rib as the centerpiece of one of the best overall meals of your year because Morcilla, which I characterized as a lesson in post-hype evolution in an October review, remains one of Pittsburgh’s pinnacle restaurants.
Best Reinvention: Oak Hill Post
It’s always a little bittersweet when a favorite restaurant takes beloved dishes off the menu. After all, we often choose to revisit restaurants for a sense of comfort or to get that dopamine hit from a flavor combination that always sends you to the moon.
Oak Hill Post offered a few of my favorite dishes that reliably launched me to the moon: a top notch diner-style hamburger, a fried chicken sandwich that flew high above most others, and gorgeous biscuits. Those are gone now and that’s fine.
Christian Schulz and Rebecca Nicholson’s autumn refresh traded daytime service for an intimate, focused dinner menu. The condensed lineup of four starters and four mains work well as a shareable meal or individual plates. Among my favorite dishes from an epic autumn meal were: an end-of-season fig salad with bitter winter greens and briny olive tapenade; house-made emulsified pork sausage with celeriac puree, roasted apples, Gruyere and fish-sauce caramel playing savory, soft, sweet, sharp and funky notes; and a sweet, salty, rich semifreddo with a robust coffee pour-over.
The thread that tied the whole menu together is balance — in every dish, each component shined on its own, worked beautifully with others, and came together in “perfect bite” harmony. What’s offered won’t be the same when you or I next make it there, and that’s a good thing. When a restaurant has a chef as talented a culinary composer as Schulz, I’m all in to see what his next composition is.
Best excuse to eat nothing but dumplings
My esteemed compatriot at the Philadelphia Inquirer, Craig LaBan, shouted out Nepali Momo Kitchen as his “best excuse to eat nothing but dumplings” in his year-end favorite dishes round-up.
Well, Craig, I’ll see your momo and raise you seven more of those Himalayan gems. Plus, there’s the armada of pierogi, ravioli, mandu and manti I enjoyed while spending weeks traversing the Pittsburgh Metropolitan Area in a Mariana Trench-worthy deep dive unwrapping the story of our region’s dumplings for the Post-Gazette’s Pittsburgh Dumpling Project.
It started with Fengping Geng, who draws from her cultural identity to create miniature works of edible art at Amazing Dumplings. Talking to Ping and her husband, Feng Gao, about their journey from the northernmost reaches of China to Pittsburgh allowed me to reflect on dumplings’ role in the city’s food history — how Polish, Ukrainian and Italian immigrants in search of a better life 125 years ago brought pierogi and ravioli to the region, and how newer arrivals from Bhutan, Uzbekistan and Afghanistan continue this tradition today. Dumplings are a universal language of comfort and community.
So, I ate dumplings. A lot of them.
From the work of old-school dumpling experts like Helen Mannarino of Pierogies Plus in McKees Rocks and Dragicia “Carla” Calvitti’s massive ravioli at the classic Tillie’s in McKeesport, to newer hands like Eric White’s globally inspired PGH Dumplingz pop-ups and mandu from Simon Chough’s Garfield Korean restaurant, Soju, it was a roving, inspiring meal.
Want to start your own “best excuse to eat nothing but dumplings” quest? Check out our Best Dumplings in Pittsburgh list.
My version of this feast is ongoing. If I were to publish that dumpling list today, I’d add several more — including the gorgeous mantu at House of Shish Kebabs and the elegant, juicy xiaolongbao at Ramen King 2 — that I’ve enjoyed since wrapping the project in June.
Best new pop-up: Lulá' La Chula
The first time I enjoyed Lulá' La Chula, which roughly translates to “the beautiful Oaxaca,” was in July at the East End Citiparks Farmers Market. My grin was as wide as the Grand Canyon as I crushed my blandas, handmade plate-sized tortillas cooked to a soft-crisp texture and topped with grilled adobo pork, smashed beans, Oaxacan cheese and avocado.
Vladimir Martinez Rodriguez, also a chef at the excellent Duo’s Taqueria in East Liberty, is tapping into his indigenous Oaxacan roots with a rotating, always delicious menu of hard-to-find (in Pittsburgh) treats such as tlayudas, memelas and garnachas, plus an array of gorgeous moles and salsas.
Everything he and his partner, Meghan Raffensperger, are doing is scratch-made and true to the culinary heritage Rodriguez learned from his Mazatec mother and Zapotec father.
“We want to celebrate a part of Mexican food that is underrepresented here,” Rodriguez told me in July. “When you do it, you add your personal sazón” — meaning the feeling and love each individual puts into their cooking.
If the several meals I had over the next few months from Rodriguez and Raffensperger are any indication, Pittsburgh should be feeling a lot of love for this mobile Oaxacan feast in the upcoming year.
Best one-off meal(s): Apteka
Two end-of-year special dinners at Apteka demonstrated why the Bloomfield spot continues to pile on accolades (including a third consecutive James Beard Award semifinalist nod) nearly nine years into its run.
In November, chefs/owners Kate Lasky and Tomasz Skowronski collaborated with Aleksander Baron, executive chef of Restauracja Kapłony i Szczeżuje in Krakow, Poland. Lasky and Skowronski met Baron a few years back while he was cooking at a restaurant in Warsaw, and kept in touch with the chef they call “Poland’s Duke of Fermentation.”
The nine-course meal was a dynamic collaboration between the three chefs, starting with a selection of dynamite salads on house-made rye leading into a series of soups including a fermented rye soup with milkcap mushrooms and walnut milk soup with root vegetables and whole nuts. Baron, known in Poland as a master of meat, made a splash with vegan interpretations of head cheese (using various mushrooms set in a fleshy pink fermented beetroot reduction) and a cold-cut sandwich (using thin-sliced brined and smoked celeriac).
A few weeks later I was back for Wigilia nie Wigilia, the dessert-heavy Polish Christmas feast. Once again, the meal (technically five courses, but Lasky and Skowronski sure did pack a lot of food into those courses) began with a selection of cold salads, this time presented in little piles on scalded oat rye bread shaped to resemble a wreath, each one singing in a distinct voice.
Borscht served with a cabbage and mushroom pastry and mushroom soup with a walnut-onion soup dumpling were among the standouts of the hot courses, as were Apteka’s always excellent savory pierogi. Walnut cake with flax meringue and hazelnut, poppyseed cake and gingerbread danish were among the parade of outstanding desserts.
The two meals were unique in atmosphere and offering. The Baron collaboration dinner was boisterous, lighthearted. Wigilia felt meditative, like Lasky and Skowronski were sending us off to the quiet, darkest nights of winter with a reminder that we all need slow coziness built into our lives.
Best meal to end the year: Ramen King 2
The evolution of Pittsburgh’s regional Chinese restaurants is something I’ve been tracking for a little more than a decade. It’s an absolute treat to experience the development of the Sichuan stylings of Chengdu Gourmet’s Wei Zhu (big-table feasts at his Chengdu Gourmet 2 ranked high in my favorite meals this year); Fengping Geng and Feng Gao’s Shaanxi dumplings, noodles and large plate dishes; and the Chongqing-style hot pots and Hebei grilled skewers of Kevin Gao and Gloria Pei’s Little Corner Grill House.
I wrapped my year in Pittsburgh dining with the Northern Chinese stylings of Fu Li Zhang, the hand-pulled noodle master behind Ramen King 2 in Ross. I gathered with a group of friends for a big meal at the end of December to slurp noodle soups and crush dumplings with aplomb.
The specialty of the house is Lanzhou noodle soup, which is served in a big bowl of luxurious beef bone and chicken broth. With this one, you’ll use scissors to cut the long strands of elastic, springy hand-pulled noodles. Zhang’s thicker, chewier knife-sliced noodles, which you should get in a stir-fry resonant with wok-hei and bouncy biang biang noodles singing in hot chili oil, are on my must-get list, too.
We were all equally impressed by the work of pastry chef “Sister” Man. Her artful xiaolongbao, with a lineage that can be traced back to the ancient Chinese capital of Kaifeng, seem almost too gossamer to contain the brothy filling. Yet, contain it they do. Her gorgeous pan-fried bao — fluffy, crisp and juicy, with a crunchy lacy crust — are also superstars.
Zhang said something to me that sums up the year better than any other way I can think of: “There's no secret to our food. We just put in full effort and don't ever cut a corner. That's it. If you take shortcuts, you won't ever have the same result.”
Here’s to more effort and no shortcuts in 2025.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.