A friend raised an eyebrow as I eagerly dug into the last bites of a plate of house-made emulsified pork sausage with celeriac puree, roasted apples, gruyere and fish-sauce caramel playing savory, soft, sweet, sharp and funky notes.

“You are house-ing these plates,” he said.

We eat together often, so he knows it’s rare for me to dive headfirst into every dish of a multicourse meal. With Oak Hill Post’s reimagined diner menu, I couldn’t fight that temptation.

Each plate offered opportunities for a “perfect bite,” combining all the elements to maximize joy. What impressed me even more, however, was how every component also stood on its own and worked as a complementary note to any other part of a dish.

Advertise with us

If you like dining out in Pittsburgh, you’ve probably heard of Oak Hill Post.

For the past four years, the restaurant stood as one of Pittsburgh's best attention-to-detail daytime dining destinations in a city that doesn’t have a lot of them. The Brookline establishment was a draw for its modern-day diner menu, including a Hall of Fame-worthy hamburger and crisp-fluffy biscuits that would make any proud Appalachian home cook smile.

The restaurant offered hospitality as comforting and attentive as its thoughtful coffee program.

Co-owners Christian Schulz and Rebecca Nicholson have revamped the menu at Oak Hill Post. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Over the summer, owners Christian Schulz and Rebecca Nicholson decided it was time to shake things up. The grinding rhythms of breakfast service began to feel limiting.

“Running a breakfast spot is valuable and important work, but it felt like we’d backed ourselves into a corner,” Schulz says.

Advertise with us

They temporarily closed in August, stepping back to reset the table.

When the couple signed a lease in March 2020, they’d planned to open a refined version of their late 2010s dinner party pop-up, Menuette. Their timing, as we all know now, was … bad.

Schulz and Nicholson pivoted to a casual concept they called Oak Hill Post, offering house-made pasta, soups and sandwiches for takeaway. Dinner was part of the mix for the first couple of months of on-site dining, but the couple soon dropped the nighttime hours. Demand for daytime service was high, and there was too little staff to cover both.

Now, they’re finally pursuing an updated version of their original vision.

When Oak Hill Post reopened in November, the only things that remained on the menu from before were the French press, Chemex and nitro cold brew coffees and the kombucha on tap.

Advertise with us

Goodbye breakfast, hello dinner.

Schulz’s new evening menu is a nifty package of four starters and four mains. The plating is artful and contemporary, drawn with an ease that doesn’t distance diners with pretension.

Although many of the dishes, such as the endive salad, have a lot of elements, they all serve a purpose. Every component feels tied to something else, which allows for experimenting with different flavor combinations. In that salad, for example, a bite of end-of-season fig offers a sweet balance to the bitter winter greens while that same fig turns savory with the dish's briny olive tapenade.

Pork sausage with celeriac puree, roasted apples, gruyere and fish-sauce caramel. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The cuisine is what we'd generally call New American, a catch-all term for ingredient-driven cooking rooted in Western European traditions blended with the dynamic flavors and techniques brought to the United States through global migration.

“My goal is to make something that I haven’t made before or other people haven’t tasted before. It’s not different for the sake of being different, though,” Schulz says.

Advertise with us

His background in music and work in labor trades is on display in the rhythm and structure of his dishes.

“It informs everything I do,” Schulz says. “You’re playing in ensembles with other people, which gives you a solid grasp on teamwork and performing your role in a group.

“Flavors and textures are counterpoints but they are also architecture. What is this component supporting? Does it have the support that it needs? Is it weighing something down?”

The pork ribs, for example, deliver a sly heat via a gochujang rub, offset by a tart buttermilk dressing. The knife-tender ribs offer a bit of chicken wing vibe that adds playful familiarity, while the dish’s overall softness adds balance to some of the bolder flavors on the rest of the menu.

Dessert brings fish caramel full circle with a semifreddo that’s sweet, salty, rich and funky. Pair it with pour-over coffee, and you get a pseudo-affogato that adds a welcome hint of bitterness to punctuate the end of the meal.

Advertise with us

Nicholson studied hospitality at Penn State University and worked in New York City and California restaurants prior to returning to her native Pittsburgh. She’s an equal partner in the venture, working as a sounding board for menu development and overseeing the congenial front-of-house and business sides of the operation.

The endive salad at Oak Hill Post. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Director of operations Nathan West's spirit-free drinks program is exceptional. He’s offering a fresh, intentional approach to nonalcoholic options that far too often lack the complexity of traditional cocktails. His striking layers of flavor are evocative of a trip to the beach (Leaving on a Jet Plane) or a cozy sweater (Among the Sunflowers). They’re balanced, fun, come at a lower price than a boozy cocktail and are tastier than many.

The refreshed Oak Hill Post is currently open Friday and Saturday nights, with Thursday evening service slated for the end of the month. Sunday brunch is on the horizon, too. Reservations for the 25-seat space tend to fill up quickly, but there is room for walk-ins, especially for small parties.

On the drive home, my pal and I agreed it was one of the best meals we’d had this year.

I hope they keep it up because Oak Hill Post’s reboot isn’t just about an established restaurant rejiggering to offer a tasty new menu — it’s a reminder that hospitality centering joy and creativity over ego is what makes dining out an evocative experience.

600 Brookline Blvd., Brookline; oakhillpost.com