Matt Hickey struts to the center of the upstairs room at Caliente Pizza & Drafthouse’s Aspinwall location following the conclusion of the local chain’s weekly managerial meeting. The gathered crowd whoops as the top-hatted commissary manager, dressed in the green-and-glitter of an end-of-the-rainbow leprechaun, begins to swing to the introductory chords of Dropkick Murphys’ “I’m Shipping up to Boston.”
As the thumping song builds momentum, Hickey, like a flair bartender from the “Cocktail” era, spins two soft-green, pizza-shaped dough rounds into the air. His teammates burst into applause as he completes his first move.
Hickey is here to test-drive the acrobatics routine he’ll present at the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas this week. It runs from Tuesday through Thursday.
“Vegas is the World Series, the Super Bowl and the Stanley Cup final of pizza. If you win Vegas, you change your life forever,” says Caliente’s executive regional chef Eric Von Hansen.
Now in its 40th year, Pizza Expo bills itself as “The Largest Pizza Show in the World.” Nearly 10,000 pizza makers, personalities, suppliers and enthusiasts will convene at the Las Vegas Convention Center for three days of classes, product demonstrations and networking. Many will compete in or watch the Olympics of the pizza world: the culinary competition of the International Pizza Challenge and the athletic gusto of the World Pizza Games.

Pittsburgh is showing up in force this year.
Read More
Approximately 30 pizza makers (19 in competition) are getting their dough recipes, ingredients and energy together to make their way to Vegas for contests, camaraderie and to see what components will change how they make their pizza for Pittsburgh.
Count on camaraderie
Eddie Stalewski has an ever-growing encyclopedia of knowledge of various styles of pizzas. He also counts 168,000 followers on Instagram, who relish in videos of his lively explorations of the craft, and he has brand sponsorships from heavy hitters such as the popular Ooni home pizza ovens.
He doesn’t, however, have a commercial-grade PizzaMaster electric oven in his house and he needs one to bake the cast-iron skillet pie he plans to prepare in Vegas as his competition pizza.
Lucky for Stalewski, he has a lot of friends in the Pittsburgh pizza world, and he’s always welcome at Iron Born Pizza in the Strip District to bake and get feedback on what he hopes will be a return of his 2022 crown as best non-traditional pizza in the Northeastern division.
“They’re amazing. Every year I come down here and they take care of me,” he says.

Stalewski works full time at coatings giant PPG, with 27 years in demand planning and supply chains, but pizza making is his heart. He bakes at home on Saturdays and works the pizza oven at Mercurio’s in O’Hara (that restaurant will also be competing in Las Vegas) on Wednesdays.
This year marks his fifth Pizza Expo.
“I was so enamored by the whole thing the first time I went. I took classes and met people, and just started making pizzas all the time after that,” he says.
Stalewski is going big with a medium-thick crust prepared in his hefty cast iron pan. He’s topping it with artichokes, roasted red peppers and grilled chicken. It’s finished with Alfredo vodka sauce, red pepper flakes, sauteed broccolini, Parmesan and a lemon wedge.
“The lemon brings out the whole flavor of the pizza,” he says.
He’s practicing, just as he did last year, with one of his fiercest competitors: Sara Boyer.
Last year was Boyer’s first in Vegas. The Iron Born pizza maker took home first place in the Northeast and third overall in the non-traditional competition, which covers pizzas that don’t fit in the classic traditional, Neapolitan, pan and cheese slice categories. It rewards creativity and technique.
“I try to find a unique ingredient or technique and build out from there,” she says.
Last year, she looked to her Cleveland roots and used a triple-smoked Slovenian sausage from the Ohio city’s Raddell’s Sausage Shop, with smoked and roasted mushrooms, herby white wine garlic cream sauce and Parmesan crisps.
For 2024, her focus is on potatoes. She’s using Iron Born’s Detroit-style dough, but replacing the pizzeria’s signature crispy cheese frico with thinly sliced potatoes. She’ll top her vegetarian pie with Raddell’s potato sausage and, by turning its “best sauerkraut ever” into what she’s calling “finishing kraut,” which eats like crispy salt-and-vinegar flavor bombs atop the pizza.
Victory is sweet, she says, but pleasing Pittsburgh’s customers is even better.
“Sometimes people do things that aren’t practical. Last year, the guy who won used bone marrow, which isn’t going to translate into a menu. But they don’t really care because it’s a contest,” she says. “The way I look at it is that it has to be something that would also make sense to sell at the shop.”
Her champion-level “Vegas Pie” has been on the menu since that competition and established a long-term relationship with Raddell’s, which typically doesn’t ship its products to restaurants.
In continued fellowship, Iron Born welcomed Gus Franco’s owner Patrick Elston to use its PizzaMaster oven a few days later. Elston is also competing in non-traditional with a “Cacio On The Cob” pizza.

Caliente competitors
Caliente’s Von Hansen is also competing in the non-traditional category. While other Pittsburgh pizza makers look to other pizzaioli for research and development advice, Von Hansen has an in-house advantage: He’s part of a company that shoots for gold and glory, as it has for almost a decade.
Among Von Hansen’s victories are, in 2016, best pan pizza in the world, and, in 2018, overall winner for non-traditional and a win for the Northeastern division for traditional.
Von Hansen’s non-traditional menu this year includes 35-day-aged New York Strip steak, black cherry and tupelo honey, red currant gastrique, pink peppercorn-infused creme with Boursin and mascarpone cheeses, and a spinach and shiitake mushroom medley.
It’s too cost-prohibitive to make it a regular menu item across the company’s seven shops and numerous stadium outlets. However, a gold medal does bring pride and name recognition.
“When we get back from Pizza Expo, we literally say '365 days to Pizza Expo.’ We count down and prepare for this the whole year,” says Nick Bogacz, Caliente president and founder. “When we get to 100 days, everyone is excited and counting down.”
A total of 16 Caliente crew members will fly together to Vegas — all paid for by the company. Bogacz says they’ll be seen in matching 1980s-style tracksuits and wearing Caliente-branded chef jackets during competition.
They’ll participate in every culinary competition except Neapolitan. Hickey, winner of last year’s “Pizza Triathlon” — which consists of dough tossing, stretching and box folding — is leading a team from Caliente in the World Pizza Games.

Pittsburgh pride
“We [Pittsburgh pizza makers] hang out with each other more in Vegas than we do in Pittsburgh,” says Iron Born owner-chef Pete Tolman. “Other than Eddie. We’re neighbors.”
Tolman hasn’t done much advance work since he started competing in 2019, when he placed first in the Northeast in non-traditional. This year, he says, he’s in it to win it again.
“This is the most serious I’ve taken practicing. I keep losing, so that was probably a sign to do a little more preparation,” he says.
Tolman is preparing a “top secret” spin on the MVP pizza (streaked with marinara, vodka sauce and pesto) that likely will involve ranch and ube, a purple tuber first grown in the Philippines.
“This pizza is going to be very polarizing for a lot of reasons. It looks so shocking, I hope it lands well,” he says.
“You’ll need to bring some of your fine-dining chef tweezers,” jibes Stalewski as Tolman pulls some microgreens to garnish his pie.
Pittsburgh’s 2024 Pizza Expo Roster includes representatives from Iron Born, Caliente, Slice on Broadway, Mercurio’s and Gus Franco’s, Badamo’s Pizza owner Anthony Badamo, social media sensation Ryan Peters, pizza consultant Kevin Konn, John McCaffrey of Yellow Bridge Brewing, Eddie Stalewski and Pennsylvania Macaroni Company/Greco & Sons.
“I remember when I started going out here you wouldn’t see a lot of people from Pittsburgh,” Bogacz says. “Now, we’re everywhere.”
Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, X @halbklein and IG @halbklein.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.