LAS VEGAS — According to a panel of expert judges at the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas, Rico Lunardi, owner of the small chain of Slice on Broadway pizza shops, makes one of the best cheese slices in the world.

On Tuesday, Lunardi was named the winner in the preliminary round of the World’s Best Cheese Slice, ranking nearly two points above the rest of the competition. That would have been enough in previous years to declare him the out-and-out winner. This year, however, organizers decided to reinstate a pre-COVID-era final round where the top five in each category would face off again on the final day of the expo.

He produced a similar pizza — a thin-ish New York-style slice with a touch of oregano — but not with quite the same result. Andy Huynh, owner and executive chef of Cowabunga Pizzeria and Cowabunga+ in Hamilton, Ontario, landed in first after finishing fourth in the preliminaries. Nevertheless, Lunardi, Slice on Broadway and Pittsburgh can be proud of a preliminary victory and top-five finish in a field of 100 global competitors.

The expo serves up two main competitions — one for pizza makers, the other showcasing an array of pizza-connected physical challenges.

Advertise with us

Competition pizza

Trade magazine Pizza Today’s taste-based International Pizza Challenge runs across five categories: World’s Best Cheese Slice, Neapolitan, Pan, Traditional and Non-Traditional, with additional brand-sponsored throwdowns by the portable oven manufacturer Ooni (traditional and pan) and a dairy-free category from the plant-based Daiya Foods.

More than 20 Pittsburghers competed across all categories at the 40th International Pizza Expo, which kicked off at a very un-Las Vegas 7 a.m. on Tuesday. While the rest of the city’s revelers were likely sleeping, ambitious pizza makers were already sorting through ingredients behind the curtains in the Las Vegas Convention Center.

“I like it. It’s peaceful here early in the morning before all the hubbub begins,” said Pete Tolman, owner of Iron Born Pizza in the Strip District and Millvale. He competed in the Pan competition and was there early to set up his ingredients and take photos for the World Pizza Champions team.

Tolman joined the team of elite pizza pros, seen throughout the expo in branded chef jackets, in 2019. Nick Bogacz and Eric Von Hansen of Caliente Pizza & Draft House and Joseph Mercurio, Michael Mercurio and Anna Crucitt of Mercurio’s are also members of the nonprofit with a mission to promote the profession of pizza maker through “international competition, educational outreach, public demonstrations and community-based service.”

The first competition pie to emerge from the array of ovens came from Alex Blinn, head pizza maker for Pizzeria Davide in the Strip District. He slid an Old World-style cheese pizza topped with a bit of red sauce and finished with basil oil onto the display table for World’s Best Cheese Slice.

Advertise with us

Pizza makers could prepare components, including dough, at home or working in the backstage area, complete with three giant walk-in coolers. They shaped and topped their competition pizzas in front of onlooking crowds, cheered on by comrades standing paparazzi-like in front of the tables and from the audience housed in bleacher-style seating.

They had a row of 13 ovens, all top-of-the-line and suited to fit their particular style, to cook in. Brand representatives, such as Denver-based Drew Richards, were there to help with the final bake.

“We’re all pizzaiolo,” said the Marra Forni brand rep. “The idea is they work all year perfecting their pizza. When they come here, the oven may not be exactly how they envisioned it. So we’re here to help them with that extra 1% that they need and get them over the hump.”

Pete Tolman of Iron Born, left, and Joe Mercurio cheer on Joe's brother Michael Mercurio as he prepares a pizza in the Neapolitan competition category.(Hal B. Klein/Post-Gazette)

Competitors dropped the completed pizzas on a display table and cut four slices they felt were worthy of being taken backstage for blind judging by a team of experts from across the pizza world. There, a team of judges — who swap in and out throughout the day to avoid palate fatigue — score without discussion amongst each other. Each pizza is tasted by four of the judges. The top and bottom scores are averaged and added to the two middle scores.

Joe Mercurio, co-owner of Mercurio’s in Shadyside and O’Hara, was one of the judges. This was his 10th expo.

Advertise with us

“They bring you back a slice and let you know what category it’s competing in. There’s a criteria for each,” he said. “You look at the bottom, the top to see how it’s cooked. Are the toppings balanced?”

The largest contingent of Pittsburghers competed in the Non-Traditional category, with no restrictions on style, toppings or saucing.

Tracy Dykeman of Slice on Broadway placed second in the Northeast with a tavern-style pizza topped with bacon, fennel, pepper jam, goat cheese and green onions. Eric Von Hansen of Caliente was right behind in third place with his chef-inspired pie that included aged New York Strip steak, red currant gastrique and pink peppercorn-infused creme with Boursin and mascarpone cheeses.

Eddie Stalewski of Eddie’s Pizza 412 and Sara Boyer of Iron Born also landed in the top third of competitors in the category.

Sara Boyer of Iron Born Pizza displays her potato-crusted pizza.(Hal B. Klein/Post-Gazette)

Perry Bogacz of Caliente finished third in the Northeast in Traditional, a category that limited competitors to a select few classic toppings.

Advertise with us

There is, of course, a “take this with a grain of salt” aspect to the culinary competition. There are, after all, a whole lot of pizza shops in the world.

Not every pizza maker has the means nor inclination to come to Las Vegas. Participating in or winning a competition is exciting, but it doesn’t determine the overall worth or deliciousness of a pizza. Some pies might easily translate to menu offerings or are already presented just like they’re sold back at home, while others, particularly in the Non-Traditional category, might be economically impossible to repeat on a larger scale.

Nevertheless, this is a serious, high-level competition. A total of 502 competitors showed up this year, including approximately 100 who were competing for the first time. Most came from the United States or Italy, but the event was truly global, with representatives from every continent except Antarctica.

Do it with style

The World Pizza Games — the flair portion of the festivities — took place on the other side of the competition area. Here, pizza makers had the opportunity to demonstrate their focus, speed and dexterity in five categories: Freestyle Acrobatic Dough Tossing, Fastest Dough, Largest Dough Stretch, Fastest Pizza Box Folding and Pizza Triathlon (fold a 12-inch pizza box, toss out a 22-ounce dough ball to cover a 16-inch screen and toss a 22-ounce dough ball to cover a 24-inch pizza screen). 

It was a terrific week for Matt Hickey, commissary general manager of Caliente, which has numerous locations in and around Pittsburgh. He took home gold in the Largest Dough Stretch, using a smooth, excellent technique to get his dough to a nearly transparent 94.1 inches in average diameter.

Advertise with us

“I like to work the table longer, and then you want to avoid stretching the center until the last possible minute. No sudden jerks, no sharp objects like fingertips and elbows,” he said.

Matt Hickey of Caliente Pizza & Draft House, uses a deliberate technique to stretch his competition dough to nearly translucent.(Hal B. Klein/Post-Gazette)

Hickey earned first place in the preliminaries for his dynamic, St. Patrick’s Day-themed Freestyle Acrobatic Dough Tossing. But he fell short and landed a silver in the finals — much to the chagrin of the onlooking crowd, which jeered the judges’ lower-than-expected marks in dexterity. Hickey also placed third overall in the Ooni Traditional category on the culinary side.

Bogacz, the 21-year-old son of Caliente founder and president Nick Bogacz, also had a good showing in the World Pizza Games, where he finished third in the Pizza Triathlon.

John McCaffery of Yellow Bridge Pizza Company in Delmont placed fourth in the event.

For Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh had a strong presence throughout the three days of the Pizza Expo, with more than 50 pizza makers from the region.

Advertise with us

They represented classics, such as Mineo’s and Danny’s Pizza and Hoagies; newcomers like Emilio and Francesca Veneziano of Vitalia Wood Fired Oven, and Yellow Bridge’s McCafferty; local mini-chains, including Slice on Broadway and Caliente; and artisanal purveyors Mercurio’s, Badamo’s, Iron Born and Gus Franco’s, all there to compete, demonstrate products and/or share knowledge.

“When it comes down to it, we’re all on the same team. Pittsburgh people support Pittsburgh people,” said Michael Mecurio, co-owner of Mecurio’s.

In order to get to Las Vegas for his initial Pizza Expo, McCaffery took a commercial airliner for the first time in his life.

“I grew up in Meadville, and I’d been on a little three-seater. But never a jet before. It was a real experience,” he said.

Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, X @halbklein and IG @halbklein.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.