Ladybird’s Luncheonette, home to some of the best hand pies, sandwiches, cookies and pastries in the Pittsburgh area, will close for retail sales this Saturday, May 6.

The shuttering of the destination-worthy daytime restaurant in downtown Beaver is a significant loss for the region’s food lovers, as chef/owner Jade Cageao excels as both a savory and a pastry chef, a dynamic that’s relatively rare in the culinary world.

On any given day, you might find offerings such as gorgeous peak-autumn pear galettes, massive molasses cookie sandwiches holding decadent miso-caramel buttercream and luscious beef bourguignon hand pies in a buttery, flaky crust, avocado toast on house-made sourdough bread that’ll make you understand why the tartine became such a ubiquitous trend in the first place.

It’s a recipe that’s proven a hit for the past four years.

Advertise with us

“We’re not closing because we’re not doing well. And I know we’re making a lot of people sad, but I wanted to be able to keep up the level of quality that we offer. And where I am in my life, I wouldn’t be able to do that if we expanded,” Cageao says.

She notes that even though business is booming, restaurants are low-margin ventures. To remain financially viable, she would have to expand the size and scope of operation beyond what she currently is capable of doing.

“I’ve been thinking about it for a while. There are a lot of factors that went into it. The birth of my second son in September had a lot to do with it, and Alex [Jordan, Cageao’s business partner] had needed to step back, too,” Cageao says.

The decision to close Ladybird’s Luncheonette echoes a trend in Pittsburgh and beyond, where we’ve seen hospitality industry business owners close shop while riding the crest of the wave of success rather than wait for their operation to fade out.

Instead, they choose to reorganize their lives away from the brutally long hours it takes to operate an independent restaurant, particularly in an era where staffing shortages and high food costs cast strong headwinds in an already demanding occupation. In Pittsburgh, we’ve seen that happen at establishments such as Onion Maiden, B52 and Bitter Ends Food Co.

Advertise with us

“A lot of that has to do with how we’ve reframed the way we think because of COVID. In the past couple of years a lot of people have realized that life is short, and people are appreciating their families and their mental health more than they did before the pandemic,” Cageao says. “It’s a good thing.”

She worked for 15 years as a chef, baker and caterer in Savannah, Georgia, and Los Angeles prior to returning to Ellwood City to raise a family. In 2019, she and her brother took over a beloved ice cream shop called Sweet Caroline’s, renaming it Ladybird’s Luncheonette in mid-2020 as she began to find her signature style for the location.

Ladybird’s quickly began building a buzz in the region through word-of-mouth praise and mouth-watering social media posts of cookies as big as your face spiked with stalagmites of potato chips and mountain-sized sandwiches decadently stuffed with scratch-made, locally sourced ingredients.

In 2021, Cageao and Jordan opened a second location of Ladybird’s in Beaver, and the second-floor shop soon became headquarters for the whole operation. They closed the Ellwood City spot in 2022.

Ladybird’s popular cooking and baking classes, as well as a small catering operation, will continue in the Beaver location until July. Cageao then plans to offer private classes in people’s homes.

Advertise with us

“It’s bittersweet. We were embraced by both communities. But this is the right time to do this,” she says.

Cageao says she has no other immediate plans but has “a lot of ideas percolating,” which might include a cookbook.

Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.