At a recent talk I gave to an Osher Lifelong Learning group about my work as a dining critic, many in the audience had questions about restaurant service. So I asked them: “How many of you have gone to a restaurant in the past couple of months and sent a dish back?”
Ten people raised their hands.
“How many of you wish you had sent back a dish?”
Nearly the entire crowd of 100 people raised their hands.
When it comes to buying things, most of us expect to be satisfied with our purchase. It would be absurd to walk out of a shop with a pair of shoes that are too small or a pair of pants that are too short.
Yet when it comes to restaurants, fewer people are comfortable taking charge beyond ordering and paying. If we can navigate most retail transactions in a way that’s respectful toward workers and ensures we’re buying something we appreciate, why is dining out so different?
Those in the crowd voiced several concerns as to why they’re not speaking up. They are worried about being perceived as difficult diners. They are worried about embarrassing their friends or family at the table. And, to my surprise, many people in the audience said they’re worried that if they complain someone in the kitchen will spit in their food.
Most of the time, my work requires that I accept the dining experience as-is and write about it in Thursday columns. But personally I know what I need to do to better shape the experience.
I asked a couple of local restaurateurs how they would answer the crowd’s concerns. Keith Fuller, the chef-owner of Root 174 in Regent Square, said if a plate isn’t to a diner’s liking, he should get the server’s attention and send it back before they eat half the food on the dish. “If you’re polite and nice, I’ll bend over backward to please you,” he said.
Bill Fuller confirmed, though he acknowledged that sending a dish back can be awkward. “You have to do it,” said the corporate chef for Big Burrito restaurant group. “Just be polite and tell your server.”
Partner and executive chef for Spoon and BRGR in East Liberty and Grit & Grace Downtown offers alternatives. “A complaint doesn’t have to be a shotgun blast,” he said. He noted how sending back a dish, can be especially harsh and abrupt.
“It helps if a diner voices a complaint in an honest way and also points out the good as well as the bad,” Mr. Pekarcik said. Another tack would be to take a manager aside and say something discreetly. At this point, it’s likely the manager will express regret or offer an apology.
An apology isn’t always enough to win back the loyalty of a dissatisfied diner, especially when there is so much more competition with so many new restaurants.
“I might send the table desserts,” Mr. Pekarcik said. “Word of mouth is exponential. And if a diner does not have a good experience and the restaurant isn’t doing damage control, there’s the possibility that he’ll never come back and he’ll convince others not to come here.”
It’s why Mr. Fuller at Root 174 will replate the whole dish that’s been sent back and often replace the cut of meat, even if it means a financial loss.
Yes, in the age of the review website Yelp, it’s easy enough to express dissatisfaction online. But Mr. Pekarcik said he appreciates when diners say something during their experience as opposed to afterward. Otherwise, he said at the very least to email the restaurant. “I usually tell them we’ll look into it,” he said, “and we will invite them to visit again. My main objective is to win their patronage back.”
Big Burrito also relies on comment cards. “We respond to every single comment,” Mr. Fuller said. “Whether it’s online, on the card, on Yelp or over email.”
As for that spitting-in-the-food reference, Mr. Pekarcik was also surprised. “That’s so alarming that’s actually a thought in people’s heads.”
Perhaps this incident would dispel a myth. Last year, Eater.com reported that a chef at Kennedy’s Pub in Mt. Oliver, N.J., was actually arrested and charged with tampering with food and disorderly conduct.
And in a January study at the University of Texas on how service staff dealt with customer complaints, only 6 percent reported to contaminating customer’s food. Any percent is too high, but its not as common as the crowd feared.
“No one,” said Mr. Fuller, “is spitting in your food.”
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.