The stories generally go something like this: A waiter or waitress, hoping to get even with an obnoxious customer, decides to mess with the customer’s food.

Maybe the server deliberately stomps on the customer’s steak and then re-plates it. Or worse yet, uses it to wipe down a garbage pail before placing it next to some extra-juicy broccoli florets arranged atop a dollop of spit.

Such accounts can be hard to swallow — and hard to believe.

University professors in Texas recently did a study trying to find out how often wait staff engaged in so-called “counterproductive work behavior” against customers.

Advertise with us

Results of the study were published in the fall in a paper titled “The Waiter Spit in My Soup! Antecedents of Customer-Directed Counterproductive Work Behavior.”

The bad news is, yes, the waiter may have spit in your soup. The good news is you’d probably have to be pretty awful to provoke such an act.

Of some 438 restaurant employees surveyed, 6 percent admitted to contaminating customers’ food.

“Thankfully, it’s not very often,” said the paper’s co-author, Emily Hunter.

The Baylor University business school professor collected her data by hand-delivering questionnaires to mostly independent, full-service restaurants. In many cases, she hung out in break rooms so she could personally survey the wait staff.

Advertise with us

The questionnaires did not ask specifically in what way any food was contaminated, and no one offered any details, Ms. Hunter said.

But she heard a few gory stories while talking with college students with restaurant jobs when she was developing her survey questions.

“I remember someone told us how one food worker took an order at a drive-thru where the customer was unreasonably rude and demanding. So that person spit in their food before delivering it to them,” she said.

“The customer wouldn’t know, and other employees would laugh about it. But there were no consequences. So that is certainly scary.”

In another case at a sit-down restaurant, a kitchen staffer dealing with a “condescending and demanding” customer “put their fingers in the soup and touched all the bread” before sending it out, Ms. Hunter recalled.

Advertise with us

Her study also found other ways that restaurant employees lash out at customers besides defiling food.

The most popular response was making fun of people behind their backs, which was cited by 79 percent of participants. Ignoring customers, making them wait longer than necessary and being rude also were high on the list.

Some refused reasonable customer requests (25 percent), insulted a customer (14 percent), increased a tip without the customer’s permission (11 percent) or threatened a customer (5 percent).

“A lot of times, the thinking is that deviant behavior comes from a few bad apples that [business owners] can weed out,” Ms. Hunter said.

Instead, she said, most employees, if pushed far enough, will find ways to act out.

Advertise with us

Service employees face unique stressors in the workplace, because part of the job is hiding their true emotions, she said. Sometimes, overload from having too many customers will prompt an outburst.

But typically the trigger is a nasty customer.

“Usually it’s a tit-for-tat exchange. ‘This customer is rude, and I will get back at them in some extreme way.’ ”

Counterproductive work behavior is a hot topic among researchers, she said, because it can be very costly for businesses.

“The behavior of front-line employees impacts customer loyalty and customer satisfaction, and that affects the bottom line.”

Advertise with us

While plenty of research has been done concerning bad behavior directed at companies and among employees (such as theft, sabotage and harassment), little is known about similar behavior targeting customers, Ms. Hunter said.

She chose wait staff to study because she had been a waitress during high school and college.

She said she never saw any co-workers stoop to contaminating customers’ food. “I certainly never did anything like that,” she noted.

That’s not to say she didn’t observe some counterproductive activities.

She recalls two occasions when servers chased down customers in the parking lot to argue about a tip. One got fired.

Advertise with us

“You are so dependent on tips that when you don’t receive a tip that you think is fair, it can be a very emotional reaction,” Ms. Hunter said.

She said her research should remind business owners to offer service employees training in stress management. Frequent breaks help, too.

The lesson for customers who don’t want extra ingredients in their soup is, “Be a good customer,” Ms. Hunter said.

“There is a way to complain in a kind and patient way.”

Patricia Sabatini: psabatini@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3066.