Supporters of the data center project in a south-central Pennsylvania township tried to reset the court of public opinion Wednesday night, as residents got a preview of what a relationship with Big Data could do for them.

The presentation in Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, centered on a work-in-progress community benefits agreement, the framework of which was outlined by Supervisor Phil Neiderer at a regularly scheduled board meeting.

Neiderer said he has been representing the township in talks with PA Data Center Partners and PowerHouse Data Centers, the groups behind the PAX-1 data center project.

The agreement covers commitments — in addition to future property tax payments — the developers would agree to make as part of bringing the 16-building data center campus to life.

Advertise with us

“This is a voluntary contribution by the developer to the township and its residents ... as an acknowledgement of the impact of the proposed data center,” Neiderer said in introducing the package.

Neiderer said the two sides have reached agreements-in-principle on several items:

• $1 million payments for each of the next five years, starting in January 2027, to create a taxpayer relief fund.

Under the plan, supervisors would reduce the township’s property tax rate by an amount needed to offset the payment, thereby giving every business and residential property owner a break on their municipal taxes. For a homeowner with property assessed at $350,000, Neiderer said, that could take the township tax bill from $822 this year to $442 in 2027.

• A minimum $4 million contribution to the township for future parks and recreation projects.

Advertise with us

Neiderer said that money might help to acquire and develop land for a second municipal park, or to build a recreation center to develop year-round offerings with basketball and pickleball courts and classroom space.

• $2.5 million, paid in equal installments to the township over five years for investment in farmland and open space preservation.

• $1 million for police services.

That’s a $12.5 million total commitment over the next five years, which is roughly concurrent with the proposed construction timeline for the project.

But Neiderer said he’s not done, and is still talking with Carlisle Development Partners, the joint venture leading this project, about additional contributions for fire services, and possibly some form of compensation for the project’s closest neighbors.

Advertise with us

Neiderer stressed the still-emerging deal would be over and above annual property tax payments from the data center to the township, Cumberland County and the Cumberland Valley School District.

It is also separate and apart from any restrictions on hours of generator usage, road improvements and other requirements that will be attached to final land development plans.

Public opinion hasn’t been supportive

News of the proposed agreement comes after a rough spring in the court of public opinion for backers of the PAX-1 project in Middlesex Township.

First, blasting at the project site off Country Club Road has brought home to neighbors on all sides the reality of getting a massive industrial neighbor next door.

A new round of complaints was aired by several residents Wednesday about potential changes to the water quality in their residential wells.

Advertise with us

Then, a group of neighbors launched a legal challenge to the 2025 zoning ordinance changes that opened the door to the project.

PAX-1 developers propose to build three adjoining data center campuses for an as-yet-unidentified end user on nearly 700 acres of what was historically farmland.

The project will encompass 16 buildings and have a maximum computing power of 1.3 gigawatts, making it one of the largest complexes in the state.

Final land development plans are still under review by Middlesex officials.

A spokeswoman for the partnership reached after Wednesday’s meeting said she could not comment on the ongoing negotiations.

Advertise with us

What are data centers?

Data centers power the infrastructure for the Internet. They’ve been around for years to handle tasks like content streaming, online-banking services and cloud storage.

But hyperscale centers being built to help develop and deploy artificial intelligence are new to Pennsylvania.

Opponents argue that they will increase air and noise pollution, and, industry-wide, use so much electricity that rates will go up for average consumers.

Supporters, however, see property tax windfalls for schools and local government, good jobs and the potential for economic growth as support industries spin off.

Community benefit agreements of the type Middlesex and Carlisle Development Partners are negotiating have become a pot sweetener for elected officials trying to capture forward-looking growth while respecting worries of anxious citizens that Big Tech companies are simply being enriched at their expense.

Advertise with us

In Pennsylvania, Gov. Josh Shapiro recently made such agreements one of the conditions for data center projects’ entry into his administration’s Fast Track program for expedited review of needed state permits.

In Lancaster, last year, developers behind a $6 billion CoreWeave data center there pledged $20 million in payments toward local causes and a commitment to use 100% renewable energy.

The Lancaster agreement also requires any active appeals of approvals for the CoreWeave center to be settled before the payments begin.

An expert on these agreements says they do spread out the value of major, and potentially disruptive, development projects.

“They’ve proved to be a useful tool to help mitigate the local impacts of large development projects and help to ensure that local communities share in some of the benefits of those projects,” said Romany Webb, deputy director of the Sabin Climate Change Law Center at Columbia Law School. “There are challenges associated with them — enforcement is one big one — but they can still be really useful.”

Advertise with us

What happens next

Neiderer said his intent is that any final agreement brought before the Middlesex board will become binding on the PAX-1 developers and be transferable to any successor owners of the 693-acre tract.

Most residents turning out to Middlesex meetings are adamantly opposed to the PAX-1 project, so the agreement didn’t change minds there Wednesday.

“The bottom line is no amount of compensation for being given something you don’t want at the cost of something you don’t want to lose is going to make up for it,” said Kyle Gerber, one of the appellants in the zoning case.

“Appreciate it to the degree that it’s a fair and an honest gesture of goodwill. But it still doesn’t change the fact that the way things are being altered here is something we don’t want pretty much at any cost.”

Some Country Club Road neighbors told Neiderer they appreciate the effort.

Advertise with us

But they stressed it’s just as important to them to get some relief from the effects of on-site blasting and grading that they’re feeling now.

“I’m going to tell you a tax abatement for five years isn’t going to fix these problems and it isn’t going to fix the noise that’s coming once this is up and running,” said Viola Byerly, another appellant who lives directly across from the site.

“So please, while you’re doing this... try to get answers for your residents that live here now,” Byerly said.

Neiderer said he’s aiming to bring a final version of the community benefits agreement to supervisors for action by summer’s end.