When Astrobotic’s first mission to the moon ended in a premature ball of fire over the Pacific, the North Side startup’s CEO, John Thornton, vowed to use the failure as a learning opportunity.
“I am more confident than ever now that our next mission will be successful,” he said in January.
Seven months after the pioneering voyage, a group of outside experts have now confirmed that a single helium pressure control valve in Peregrine’s propulsion system failed to close, releasing a burst of gas that ruptured the spacecraft’s fuel tank hours after launch. The private lander was carrying art and scientific instruments for NASA and other space agencies.
Changes have been made to Astrobotic’s next spacecraft, Griffin, as a result, Mr. Thornton said Tuesday at a press conference announcing the conclusion of Peregrine’s post-mission report.
“It is a single fault tolerant design for Griffin,” he said. “So that means that if that valve were to fail the same way as Peregrine Mission One, there is a backup system that would be able to control the helium.”
According to Peregrine mission director Sharad Bhaskaran, there were signs that the valve was a risk prior to launch.
Read More
Back in 2022, the valves leaked enough during testing to convince Astrobotic to swap suppliers.
Then, in the build up to the January launch, one of the new valves leaked and had to be repaired at the last minute.
Its twin, the one that ultimately failed, was buried deeper in the spacecraft, meaning any adjustments could have disrupted other components that had already been squared away, Mr. Bhaskaran said.
Because the risk of that valve failing was deemed “low,” they opted to fly without performing “extensive surgery.”
The decision was “influenced by cost and schedule,” Mr. Bhaskaran said.
“The decisions that were made at each point in time were sound engineering decisions and sound programmatic decisions,” John Horack, an Ohio State University professor and NASA veteran who led the review board, told reporters on Tuesday. “Sometimes hardware just fails.”
The ensuing anomaly sent control teams in Pittsburgh and Cape Canaveral scrambling, with members of the international space community pitching in to help save the private lander — NASA’s first attempt to return to the moon in a half century.
Their quick thinking managed to salvage data — enough for two scientific papers — and inspire onlookers who closely followed Peregrine’s saga on social media.
It also convinced Astrobotic that apart from the propulsion problem, their spacecraft was functional.
“This spacecraft flew successfully for 10 and a half days in cislunar space,” Steve Clarke, Astrobotic’s vice president of landers and spacecraft, said Tuesday.
“It's quite capable,” Mr. Thornton added. “We feel very confident that it could be a fantastic platform for future use.”
The mission was the first in-space test for the Carnegie Mellon University spinoff founded in 2007.
Its failure raised questions about Astrobotic’s next trip to the moon — a larger bet that was originally set to ferry NASA’s water-seeking rover. In July, the space agency decided to scrap that rover, leaving Astrobotic planning a mission without a primary objective.
But the startup is viewing that setback, too, as an opportunity.
“Now we have extra payload capacity,” Mr. Thornton said. “We are in conversations with multiple parties… for addition to flight by 2025.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.