CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — Thomas Zurbuchen watched Peregrine’s launch Monday like countless others did: from home.
“I woke up literally 15 minutes before the launch,” he said. “And it was incredible.”
But Mr. Zurbuchen wasn’t just a casual observer. The former head of science at NASA oversaw 100 missions in his six years with the agency and set in motion the program that led to Peregrine’s liftoff.
Shortly after the 2:18 a.m. spectacle, however, he went back to bed. Within hours, his phone was full of messages that something had gone awry.
For crews involved with mission control, there was no time to be devastated; there was too much to do. They barely slept the rest of the week as they struggled to keep their lunar lander powered on and the craft’s solar panels pointed toward the sun.
Early indications suggest the failure was caused by a faulty valve in Peregrine’s propulsion system that leaked pressurized helium, rupturing a tank just hours after the flawless departure from Cape Canaveral. Peregrine was supposed to be is NASA’s first trip back to the moon in 50 years — and North Side-based Astrobotic’s first ever mission.
Read More
But by Saturday afternoon, Astrobotic reiterated that a moon landing was “not possible” and that the lander was now “on a path towards earth, where it will likely burn up in the Earth’s atmosphere.”
All was not lost, however.
“I think they did a really good job,” Mr. Zurbuchen concluded toward the end of the week. “The hard part about space is, you basically find the problems when you fly.”
A new way of doing business
Peregrine was a high-risk venture for NASA.
It was also a bargain. The goal was for private companies to begin ferrying objects to the moon for NASA and whoever else was willing to pay for the ride. NASA funded various parts of the mission but made it clear it wasn’t the government’s mission.
NASA paid just $79.5 million to get the project on its feet in 2019. It added an additional $39 million to account for supply chain disruptions during the pandemic and after asking Astrobotic to change where Peregrine was to land.

That’s much cheaper than a typical NASA mission, said Mr. Zurbuchen, who oversaw NASA’s development of landers such as Peregrine as part of its Commercial Lunar Payload Services, or CLPS, program.
“A lunar lander by a normal standard that's within the agency would cost between a half a billion to a billion bucks, at a minimum,” he said.
That kind of price guarantees a 95% chance or higher of success, Mr. Zurbuchen said, but it’s not sustainable for the expanded lunar presence the agency now envisions.
“We knew that there's going to be more risk, but we're also going to take bigger leaps,” he said.
NASA’s next chance to send science to the moon will come in a matter of weeks, thanks to its next CLPS partner, a Houston-based startup called Intuitive Machines.
And later this year, IM and Astrobotic both will send landers to the moon’s south pole, where NASA hopes to study patches of frozen ice. India successfully landed on the south pole in 2023 after a failed attempt in 2019.
Catching rays
If all had gone according to plan, Peregrine’s first maneuver in space would’ve been pointing toward the sun to begin charging its onboard battery. But that seemingly simple task would prove to be the first major test for Astrobotic’s mission control staffers in Pittsburgh.
Astrobotic hasn’t said exactly how its engineers pulled it off, but what it called an “improvised maneuver” somehow righted the ship, giving hope to the seven countries represented onboard and legions of followers around the world.
Throughout the week as Peregrine continued to leak fuel and the chances of reaching the moon slipped away, mission control continued to respond to crises that could have ended the run.
“Overnight, the team faced another spacecraft point issue, but continues to persevere,” Astrobotic said on Tuesday, 32 hours after the launch.
It was one of several battles Astrobotic’s inaugural flight crew would win to keep its customers’ payloads alive, said Jay Apt, a former NASA astronaut and business professor at Carnegie Mellon University.
“It's much more than just sun orientation,” said Mr. Apt, who woke up Tuesday to several emails from Astrobotic employees. “They have done a very impressive job of not only activating their payloads, but also trading off their limited time and limited resources among the various payloads.”
That power gave continued hope to dozens of CMU students who were hoping to test their Iris rover — built to detach from Peregrine, drive a short distance on the moon, and take a photo looking back at the lander.
By noon Monday, there was barely glimmer of despair in the Cape Canaveral vacation rental that became their emergency mission control.
Monster energy drinks and Dunkin Donuts glaze kept the undergraduates moving as they talked through various options for non-lunar experimentation. Several Iris alumni who came down to witness the launch lent a hand during the tense negotiations.
At one point, as lead Iris scientist Zachary Muraskin demonstrated the rover with a USB adapter, and Peregrine with a stack of napkins, somebody else called out for thermal data.
A former grad student had it at the ready.
“Really, I'm overjoyed at how it all turned out,” mission control lead Nikolai Stefanov would later say, amazed by how his teammates came together as they finally caught a breath and shared a slice of pizza by the pool. “You can write stacks of documentation, you can write lines and lines of code, you can fasten so many bolts to a flight rover — but really, in some ways the biggest thing that you want to focus on is the team.”
Red Whittaker, the CMU professor overseeing Iris, said his students gained invaluable experience that would give them a leg up if they continue to work on space projects.
“I just hope their heads don’t get too big,” he said.
‘A great deal of goodwill’
Peregrine’s continued limp through space, out to more than 225,000 miles from Earth, allowed all of Astrobotic’s paying customers to make contact with their payloads, including NASA and the space agencies of Mexico and Germany.
NASA said its spectrometers were learning about radiation between the Earth and the moon, data that could help to protect electronics and astronauts on future missions.
But the selflessness from Astrobotic had another effect.
“It would have been very easy to just concentrate on their own spacecraft,” said Mr. Apt. “And they did that, of course, but they also — in a very limited amount of time — said, ‘OK, this is what we can do for our customers.’”
“They were extremely payload- and customer-oriented,” he said. “And they got a great deal of goodwill, I think, for doing that.”
NASA plans to send its water-detecting rover VIPER on Astrobotic’s next mission, targeting the moon’s south pole.
But Astrobotic also has a larger mission of making space accessible to a broader swath of participants. The six other countries that hitched a ride on Peregrine don’t necessarily have the current resources to get to the moon on their own, said Astrobotic’s chief executive, John Thornton.
“This is the dawn of a new era in terms of how we think about space,” he said minutes after the launch. “This is an opportunity for commercial payloads to fly to the surface of the moon on a regular, routine basis.”
Mr. Thornton was not naïve to the risks of space. In a December interview, he said Astrobotic should be prepared for the “equal chance” of failure. But he also said it was a marvel that Astrobotic had even made it to the launch pad.
“Pittsburgh is not the top place in the country to start a business,” he said. “And then we're going after space, a market that Pittsburgh doesn't do. And then we're going after the most aggressive, cutting-edge part of space, which is flying and landing on the surface of the moon.”
“So there are way, way, way more reasons to fail than to succeed. We probably should have failed, but we didn't. And here we are.”
The 16-year-old startup has already helped build a museum next to its North Side headquarters with the goal of inspiring others to reach for their “moonshot.”
Peregrine will likely become the first new exhibition.
A known failure point
Astrobotic used a new propulsion system on Peregrine that had never been flown before, said Mr. Zurbuchen.
It was developed by Dynetics, an Alabama defense contractor, with engines from Frontier Aerospace, a California startup that won a $1.8 million NASA award to develop the system in 2018.
Astrobotic told Space News in 2018 that no changes to the propulsion system were needed to support later missions with heavier payloads. In 2021, Astrobotic gave Frontier a second contract to build engines for its Griffin lunar lander.
“We’ve entrusted Frontier’s engines to perform the most critical propulsive maneuvers on GM1, building on our successful relationship from our first Peregrine mission,” Daniel Gillies, Griffin’s mission director said at the time.
With the launch of Griffin set for later this year, it wasn’t immediately clear whether Astrobotic planned to make changes to the lander’s propulsion system. So far, Astrobotic said, Peregrine’s propulsion issue seems limited to its plumbing system, separate from its engines.
But it will take months to verify the specific failure point, said Mr. Apt.
“In spacecraft and in aviation, the rule that I used to teach our people was: You never believe the first report right after a mishap.”
“And if the first report turns out to be accurate, it's generally just a coincidence,” he said. “The data have to be examined and really understood by not only the engineers who designed this system, but engineers who have designed and lived through failures on other spacecraft systems.”
Mr. Zurbuchen, the former NASA head, also worried about attributing blame too early. “We need to look in detail what happened,” he said.
But both experts said valve problems are a known sticking point, for startups and big players alike.
“Propulsion systems for spacecraft are extremely difficult to test, and they can't really be simulated,” said Mr. Apt, who remembered similar valve problems when he worked for NASA’s Jet Propulsion Lab lab in the 1970s.
Sometimes they’re caught before launch.
In 2021, Boeing was forced to scrap the launch of its Starliner capsule after engineers detected a valve problem in its propulsion system hours before liftoff.
In 1986, three days after the space shuttle Challenger explosion that killed all seven crew members, the Los Angeles Times noted that one of the rocket’s previous missions was nearly catastrophic because of a valve problem.
For Astrobotic, a mechanical issue will take longer to fix than a software problem. And even if corrected for Griffin, software could still keep it from a soft landing on the moon. The two prior private landing attempts, by an Israeli nonprofit in 2019 and a Japanese firm in 2023, both ended in crashes due to software glitches.
Peregrine’s flight software appears to have worked flawlessly, but without a landing attempt, that portion of its control will remain untested.
Astrobotic used a space simulation software developed by Ansys, a global software firm headquartered in Canonsburg, to train for its first missions.
Failure leads to innovation
Mr. Apt said everyone working in space, including governments and private companies, must learn “what works in their era.”
“The technology that's available in any one era is very different from the technology that was available even a decade previous to that,” he said. “It's a process of working through that and learning how, how to design and operate with that available technology.”
Even NASA has experienced its share of “monumental failures,” he said, including two fatal shuttle failures. “There are places that learn faster than others, and I'm hopeful that Astrobotic will be one of those that do.”
The upshot, he said, is that the propulsion failure didn’t immediately end the mission, and Astrobotic was still able to gather “an excellent amount” of data.
“Space is hard,” Mr. Apt added, “and no one should expect the first flight or flights to go perfectly.”
He noted that SpaceX — now the most reliable rocket booster company in American history — nearly folded after its first two failures.
“If their third flight had not reached orbit, they would have had to shut the company down,” he said.
Evan Robinson-Johnson: ejohnson@post-gazette.com and @sightsonwheels






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.