The final piece of Shell Chemical’s fenceline monitoring plan — a hard-won victory for environmental groups concerned about air quality impacts from the new petrochemical complex in Potter Township — is now online.

Four monitors which sample the air continuously looking for volatile organic compounds went live in February, and began posting data publicly on March 1. The data is presented in 15-minute averages and is available on Shell’s website.

The continuous air monitors join a network of 20 passive air monitors at the Beaver County site, which show how much of each individual pollutant accumulated during the two-week sampling period. The passive monitors have been running for a year.

The monitoring network is in addition to Shell’s mandated reporting of certain pollutants as part of its air permit, such as rolling 12-month emissions totals for regulated pollutants including carbon monoxide, volatile organic compounds, and methane.

Advertise with us

That data allowed regulators to determine that Shell exceeded its permitted allotment for emissions of volatile organic compounds in October, November and December, and for emissions of nitrogen oxides in November and December.

Shell also posted the full 2022 year of hazardous air pollutant emissions. The company’s permit caps those at 32 tons on a rolling 12-month basis, with no more than 11 tons coming from benzene.

The facility stayed within its limits, according to the recently posted breakdown. It emitted a total of 8 tons of hazardous air pollutants in 2022. Nearly half of that was in the form of benzene and the majority of the benzene was emitted from the wastewater treatment plant. The plant also had about one ton of formaldehyde emissions last year.

The now substantial body of air emission data, coupled with malfunction reports that Shell is required to file, can be sliced and diced to evaluate operating trends and give the community a sense of its changing air landscape, not to mention provide hard evidence for advocacy efforts.

But those looking to identify a bad smell or a dark cloud of smoke coming from the plant in real time won’t find it here.

Advertise with us

The settlement agreement that Shell reached in 2017 with the Clean Air Council and the Environmental Integrity Project doesn’t require same day reporting from its continuous air monitors — the way that monitors around Shell’s ethane cracker in Norco, La. report to the community there.

In Beaver County, even data from the newly-activated continuous air monitors is posted two days later.

And if those monitors register a concentration of volatile organic compounds above a certain threshold — which automatically opens a canister to collect a 30-minute air sample — it will take up to two weeks to get results from a lab and then out to the public.

Sarah Kula, an attorney with the Environmental Integrity Project who has been monitoring Shell’s fenceline air screening program to ensure it complies with the settlement, said it appears the company has met its obligations.

Now comes the analysis.

Advertise with us

“It is a lot of data that was posted at once,” she said. “We’re still investigating it and evaluating it.”

She said it’s important to ensure that the data, which is now posted as a table in PDF format, is made accessible and meaningful to the average person.

Still, the universe of air emission measurements generated by Shell’s operation is vast and unique among industrial facilities in this region.

As is the network of community-grown environmental surveillance efforts around the plant.

For example, at about 3:30 p.m. on Feb. 13, a real-time camera feed trained on the western part of the Shell plant -— the Breathe Cam operated by Carnegie Mellon University’s Create Lab — showed a large flare with billowing black smoke. The images prompted calls to regulators. At the same time, residents could watch in real time as PurpleAir monitors in the area tracked particulates and volatile organic compound concentrations.

Advertise with us

An hour later, Shell posted a message on its Facebook page announcing the malfunction and warning of more flaring that evening.

An inspection report filed by the state Department of Environmental Protection revealed that a problem with the plant’s ethane cracking unit had cascaded into a compressor failure, which routed hydrocarbons to the flare system. Then, a glycol seal broke in one of the high pressure flares, venting a mixture of ethylene glycol and water onto Shell’s property.

In March, when Shell posted all the February data for its continuous monitors, it showed that volatile organic compound concentrations didn’t rise to the action levels that day (as they had many times during that first month).

“We also had a third-party environmental contractor located offsite performing air measurement and no Photoionization Detector measurements nor odors were detected at the time of the incident,” Shell spokesman Curtis Thomas said. He noted that the company also found “no off-site impacts or air quality impacts” from the glycol release.

Data from the passive monitoring system, which sampled the two weeks ending Feb. 15, showed increased levels of benzene at a monitor near the flare, but a field investigation attributed those to the wastewater treatment plant.

Advertise with us

Shell has 30 days to file its own malfunction report from the event, which should come any day. It will also estimate the emissions from the flare.

The data isn’t instantaneous, but it’s an unprecedented window into the region’s new industrial center.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com