HARRISBURG — Former U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge told Pennsylvania legislators on Monday that preserving the state’s nuclear power plants is crucial for national security and maintaining a resilient electrical grid.

The former Pennsylvania governor, who was in office when the state restructured its electricity market to open it to competition in the mid-1990s, joined a panel of nuclear advocates in arguing for the state to adopt legislation to subsidize forms of electricity that don’t emit climate-warming carbon dioxide — chiefly Pennsylvania’s five nuclear plants.

Mr. Ridge focused his testimony to the House Consumer Affairs committee on the national security implications of allowing nuclear plants to close in the face of competition from plentiful low-cost natural gas, a shift he said has the potential to create an energy monopoly for the booming fossil fuel.

“If current trends continue, nuclear could fall to just 10 to 15 percent of our energy supply” in the United States, he said. “In my judgment, that is a dangerously low percentage from a national security standpoint.”

Advertise with us

But opponents of the bill — including former Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission chairman Glen Thomas — called the proposal “an absolute competition killer” that would fatally interfere with the competitive energy markets that have lowered Pennsylvania’s electricity prices over two decades.

The bill “seeks to undo and limit the continued growth of natural gas generation in the commonwealth,” Todd Snitchler, vice president of market development for the American Petroleum Institute, said.

“The Legislature should not punish those who played by the rules in the electricity market and come in to help those who didn’t like the outcome,” Mr. Snitchler said.

Two of Pennsylvania’s five nuclear plants have announced plans to close well before their operating licenses expire and lawmakers are making the plants’ fate a focus of their attention this spring.

For legislators looking for a clear answer on whether electricity bills will rise higher with or without legislation to subsidize nuclear plants, the packed hearing on Monday offered competing data points instead.

Advertise with us

One answer is relatively straightforward — bills proposed in both the House and Senate are estimated to cost electricity ratepayers about $500 million a year, or $3 billion over the six years that participating nuclear plants would have to commit to operating under the program.

The other answer is harder and depends on which energy sources step in to replace shuttered nuclear plants and how much prices might rise as they fill the gap.

Kathleen Barrón, senior vice president for regulatory affairs at Exelon Corp., whose Three Mile Island nuclear plant near Harrisburg is scheduled to close in September, said a court challenge to a nuclear rescue in New York offered a telling answer.

When competitive generators sued over the Empire State’s $7.6 billion zero emissions credit program, they estimated that energy and capacity prices would have gone up by $15 billion over 12 years had the state not acted to include nuclear within the clean energy standard, she said.

Fossil fuel generators “were losing money because prices would go up if the state had let the (nuclear) plants shut,” she said. “They are here because they do not want to see prices stay low and they stand to benefit in terms of price and market share if you don’t act.”

Advertise with us

But Mr. Thomas said current competitive electricity markets are working: “Prices are down, reliability is up, diversity is strong.”

And when consumers are allowed to choose what they want, the winners might not be any of the traditional energy players at all.

“The way things are headed, more and more people are going to choose 100 percent renewable (energy) because it is in their economic interest to do so,” he said.

Mr. Ridge is a partner at Ridge Policy Group, a government relations firm whose clients include FirstEnergy Solutions, which operates nuclear power plants including the Beaver Valley Power Station in Shippingport that is slated to close in 2021. He was also once a member of the board of Exelon Corp.

The former governor also once served as an advisor to the Marcellus Shale Coalition, a natural gas industry group. On Monday, he called himself “an all-in advocate for energy.”

Advertise with us

The hearing was the first of four planned in the consumer affairs committee to discuss House Bill 11 over the next month. Other hearings are slated to include representatives for electric power generators, utilities, consumers, organized labor and regulators.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.