It’s a tough time for potential homebuyers.
Prices are much higher than they were prior to the pandemic and mortgage rates have risen sharply over the past couple of years. As a result, housing affordability is as low as it has been in four decades, but the situation in the Pittsburgh area is better.
Although area homebuyers, like those in the rest of the country, are facing the highest mortgage rates in decades, the area’s more subdued house price cycle means that housing is more affordable here than it is in the rest of the country.
The national housing market has been on a roller coaster ride over the past couple of decades. House prices surged during the housing boom of the early 2000s, increasing by more than 50% from the beginning of 2001 to its peak in 2007, according to the purchase-only house price index from the Federal Housing Finance Agency.
At the same time household incomes only went up by one-third. This led households to stretch themselves financially to purchase a home, taking on more debt relative to incomes. In addition, some lenders reduced their lending standards, extending credit to households that found themselves unable to make their mortgage payments. The result was a housing bust, with national house prices falling more than 20% from the peak in 2007 to the trough in 2011 (see Chart 1).
This decline in house prices made housing relatively less expensive, however, encouraging more potential homebuyers to enter the market. As a result, house prices gradually recovered, and were back to their 2007 peak level by 2016. But by that point, incomes were about one-third above their 2007 level, and so housing was much more affordable in 2016, relative to incomes, than it was in 2007. House prices continued to gradually increase over the next few years.
Read More
When the pandemic struck the U.S. in 2020, a number of factors simultaneously hit the housing market.
Aid from the federal government provided a huge boost to household incomes. Demand for single-family homes surged as families found themselves jammed together with many more adults working from home and kids being schooled virtually. And perhaps most importantly, the Federal Reserve undertook historic efforts to lower interest rates, including mortgage rates, in an effort to boost demand in the economy.
In a process known as quantitative easing, the central bank created money electronically and used the funds to purchase long-term U.S. government debt and mortgage loans that were bundled together and sold to investors, known as mortgage-backed securities. This caused the average interest rate on a typical 30-year mortgage to fall from 3.7% in late 2019 to as low as 2.7% a year later, the lowest mortgage rate on record (see Chart 2).
Consumers looking for more space were flush with cash to make down payments and historically low mortgage rates boosted the housing market in late 2020 and in 2021. Existing home sales soared to their highest levels since the tail end of the previous boom in 2006, and prices surged 8% in 2020, 17% in 2021 and 14% in 2022.
Last year, the cheap credit that fueled the boom came to an end, and as inflation picked up, the Federal Reserve worked to cool the economy. Instead of purchasing long-term Treasurys and mortgage-backed securities, last year the central bank started to let them mature and did not replace them. This put upward pressure on long-term interest rates, including mortgage rates.
The typical rate on a 30-year mortgage, which was below 3% as recently as September 2021, is now above 7%. Not surprisingly, much higher mortgage rates over the past couple of years have made it much more expensive to buy a home.
The National Association of Realtor’s housing affordability index, which takes into account home prices, household incomes and mortgage rates was down to 90 in the third quarter of 2023, meaning that a family earning the median income in the U.S. could afford to purchase a home costing 90% of the median sale price for an existing home. Right before the pandemic the affordability index was 170, meaning that a household earning the median income could have purchased a home costing 70% more than the median sale price.
The good news for Pittsburgh-area residents is that local housing is more affordable than it is in the rest of the U.S.
The housing market here is more mature compared to the rest of the country, with lower shares of the population moving in and out, and much less pronounced house cycles. As a result, house prices in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area are much lower relative to incomes, making Pittsburgh a very affordable place to buy a home. In fact, according to HSH.com, the Pittsburgh metropolitan area has the most affordable housing among large metropolitan areas in the country as of the second quarter, based on the income required to purchase a home.
While this is certainly good news for potential homebuyers, it is not all good news. Low home prices in Pittsburgh reflect weak demand, in large part due to the area’s declining population over the past couple of decades.
Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.